Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Peanut butter whoopie pies

Whoopie pies are a chocolate 'cakey' cookie with a cream filling.

By Carol RamosThe Pastry Chef's Baking / February 10, 2011

Whoopie pie fillings come in many flavors. This peanut butter version is especially decadent.

The Pastry Chef's Baking


Up until last month, I'd never had a whoopie pie. I knew what they were – cakey cookies sandwiched with filling - but I'd never made them before. Maybe it was because I didn't think cookies should be cakey. We all know how I feel about that subject. Maybe because I thought the name was silly - it's a pie? It's a cookie? It's whoopie? Okay, I get odd notions sometimes. In any case, whoopie pies were not in my every day baking arsenal.

However, last month, I made the Spiced Pumpkin Cookie Cakes which were essentially pumpkin whoopie pies. Those turned out pretty well so I was a bit more broad-minded when I saw this recipe for peanut butter whoopie pies from Martha Stewart's Cookies book. It was the same concept – cakey chocolate "cookies" with peanut butter filling. The main selling point though was it used 2 cups of buttermilk and I had a pint to use up this week before the expiration date so it seemed like a good opportunity to make whoopie (yeah, you know I had to get a bad pun in) ... pies.

These turned out really well. The batter is softer than a cookie dough but more firm than cake or brownie batter. I used two spoons to shape the blob of cookie dough/batter back and forth before dropping onto a parchment-lined cookie sheet. I made the blobs fairly smooth and they smoothed out even further and baked into thick, puffy cookie-like shapes. I wouldn't call them cookies though since they had the texture and softness of a little cake. Definitely only bake these for 8 minutes as that's long enough to give them a nice, moist texture without being raw or dry. I only made half the peanut butter filling recipe since I tend to go light on fillings and knew a full recipe would be too much. I ended up a little short but I sandwiched the remaining cookies with dulce de leche that my friend Jenny brought back for me from South America. Heaven. Instead of cookies or "pie", think of these as little chocolate cakes sandwiched with peanut butter filling. Regardless of the nomenclature, they go down really well and look nice, too.

Skip to next paragraph

The Pastry Chef’s Baking

Recent posts

(See recipe next page)


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story