Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


North Korea ready for six-party talks – with caveat

North Korea told China's visiting Prime Minister Wen Jiabao it will return to six-party talks it abandoned in April. But first, it wants bilateral talks with the US.

(Page 2 of 2)



Repeated efforts to move toward such a solution have been thwarted by bickering and mutual recrimination over unmet promises.

Skip to next paragraph

"The problem has always been sequencing," says David Kang, a Korea expert at the University of Southern California. "Both sides agree the deal is nukes for normalization; the problem is who goes first."

To overcome this difficulty, and to prevent North Korea from quibbling over every detail, South Korean president Lee Myung-bak late last month proposed a "grand bargain" resolving all the issues in one fell swoop, rather than step by step.

North Korea prioritizes deal with US

Pyongyang appears to be seeking a similar deal with the US, which it regards as its main threat, bypassing the Chinese-brokered six party talks.

Though North Korea has not publicly stated its agenda for the talks it would like to hold with Washington, the beleaguered pariah state is likely to demand an end to US financial sanctions that are hobbling its foreign-currency transactions, as well as a wide range of deeper concessions.

Those would probably include a demand that Washington treat Pyongyang as a nuclear-power equal, and agree to remove South Korea from the US nuclear umbrella, removing US troops from the country, in return for North Korean denuclearization.

Even without such far-reaching demands, however, Washington appears reluctant to be drawn into substantial negotiations alone with North Korea. US officials have reassured other parties to the multilateral talks that in any bilateral meetings, Washington would discuss only a resumption of six-party talks.

"Washington will be very careful in consulting repeatedly at a high level with the other parties about any bilateral dialogue," says David Straub, a former US diplomat in Seoul who accompanied former president Bill Clinton on his trip to bring two detained American journalists home from Pyongyang this summer.

At the same time, suggests Professor Kang, "If the Americans can see a path to somewhere, they might be willing to do something," as long as it did not entail too many risks.

That might give Mr. Kim something he has long wanted, says Paik Hak-soon, a political analyst at the Sejong Institute in Seoul. "Dear Leader" Kim "wants to restructure the whole negotiations to get away from low-level technical issues," such as verification, "to a high-level agreement" with the US, says Mr. Paik.

Though Kim agreed conditionally to return to the six-party talks, Zhang Liankui, a professor at the Chinese Communist Party Central School in Beijing, says North Korea actually believes those negotiations "are dead."

Since China chairs those talks, however, explains Professor Zhang, "it was not a good idea to reject the idea of six-party talk in front of a Chinese leader."

Follow us on Twitter.

Permissions