Will Blunt amendment backfire on Republicans?

Senate Democrats didn’t want to bring the culture wars to Congress, but on Thursday, some were more than happy that Republicans did. 

The Blunt amendment, which would have allowed employers to opt out of a new federal health-care mandate for their employees if they have religious objections, failed to win the 60 votes needed to overcome a filibuster. The vote was 51 to 48.

Despite the measure’s GOP origins, the vote was in many ways more politically perilous for Republicans than Democrats – and particularly for freshman Sen. Scott Brown (R) of Massachusetts, who is facing reelection this fall. It was an example of why Congress rarely likes to take on big issues in an election year: Every controversial vote can become a weapon in the hands of an opponent.

On Thursday, some Democrats were just short of gleeful that Republicans had given them this chance.

In a press conference following the vote, Sen. Charles Schumer (D) of New York characterized the measure as so politically odorous that moderate Republican senators “voted for it with clenched teeth.”

The amendment grew as a protest against President Obama’s mandate that all businesses – even ones affiliated with religion – include health-care providers that offer contraception. It would have been appended to a highway bill that had received widespread bipartisan support. 

Republicans characterized the amendment as an issue of religious freedom; Democrats panned is as a war against women.

“You can’t alienate large numbers of Hispanics, large numbers of women, particularly suburban independents, and win elections,” said Senator Schumer.

Senator Brown, who must consider both Catholic voters and the leftward leanings of the Massachusetts electorate, voted in favor of the amendment. Schumer noted, with particular relish, that it would be “hard to defend [the vote] back home, especially in places like New England.”

Brown, a tea party favorite who nearly derailed Mr. Obama’s healthcare legislation by winning a special election for the seat previously held by liberal icon Ted Kennedy, is facing a tough reelection matchup against liberal firebrand and Harvard professor Elizabeth Warren. Brown has tacked to the political middle on a number of issues, most recently writing an op-ed in favor of breaking the “brass ceiling” to allow women to serve on the front lines in war. 

1 | 2

Next