Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Senate Democrats shoot down GOP's House budget plan. Now what?

Wary of the impact on Medicare, five Republicans joined Senate Democrats in defeating the Republican budget plan written by Rep. Paul Ryan. But the Democrats have no plan of their own, and this could hurt them.

(Page 2 of 2)

“The only way we are going to get a real budget is by Democrats and Republicans sitting down together,” he said in a conference call with reporters on Monday.

“If you may remember, when we had the vote on H.R. 1, and it was defeated roundly, it helped many in the GOP understand that they're going to have to work together on a bipartisan strategy,” he added, invoking the defeat of a House bill to fund the balance of FY 2011, also gridlocked.

But Republicans charge that Democrats are simply avoiding the responsibility of laying out a plan of their own for FY 2012 spending, including specifying how they will rein in deficits.

Skip to next paragraph

“It’s a shocking display of irresponsibility,” said Sen. Jeff Sessions (R) of Alabama, after the vote. “They have said: we’re not going to produce anything. We’re just going to attack what you’ve done.”

The Senate Budget Committee has not marked up its own vision for the current fiscal year and beyond, even though the congressional budget process requires the Senate panel to report a budget resolution by April 1 and the Congress to complete action on a budget resolution by April 15.

Waiting for the 'Gang of Five'

Questioned on the absence of a Senate plan after today’s vote, Senator Reid said that Democrats haven’t produced their own budget in deference to ongoing bipartisan talks in the so-called Gang of Five and the leadership group led by Vice President Biden.

“If something happens with the Gang of Five or bipartisan group we have to have an instrument to get to the floor,” he said.

But Republicans and some independent analysts say that it’s a risk for Democrats to try to ride out the FY 2012 budget debate.

“Politically, it’s a problem for Democrats,” says Julian Zelizer, a congressional historian at Princeton University in Princeton, New Jersey. “There are economic and budget problems that are very real, and the polls show that voters care about this.”

Democrats can try to avoid controversial votes but there’s a cost to that,” he adds. “You can avoid tough votes [on a Democrat budget plan], but it gives Republicans the opportunity to fill in the blanks and say what Democrats are about. It’s an unhappy electorate. Being quiet and just playing defense for the next year won’t necessarily work.”


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story