Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Rebellion in GOP ranks: How Boehner lost control of the House this week

Republican freshman – tea partyers and others – keep breaking ranks, leading to shocking legislative defeats. Now, 87 representatives and 11 senators have written to Speaker of the House John Boehner to insist on $100 billion in budget cuts.

By Staff writer / February 10, 2011

Rep. John Boehner (R) of Ohio, gives a news conference on Capitol Hill in Washington, Feb. 10. A week of setbacks and legislative defeats has shaken the GOP leadership.

Manuel Balce Ceneta / AP



It’s been a long week for the new House Republican majority, stunned by losing two floor votes, having to postpone a trade vote, then scrambling to find a working majority in their own ranks on their No. 1 issue – reducing the size of government.

Skip to next paragraph

Republican leaders Wednesday floated a preliminary list of $32 billion in spending cuts for fiscal year 2011, now funded only through March 4. It’s draconian by historic standards for cuts in a single fiscal year. But party conservatives at a closed meeting on Wednesday dug in for cuts closer to the $100 billion pledged in the 2010 campaign, forcing GOP leaders back to the drawing board.

“We’re working with our members and committee chairmen to achieve the largest cut that is possible,” said Speaker John Boehner (R) of Ohio at a briefing with press on Thursday. He says he expects to take the measure to the floor next week.

“We’re in a new era. I made it pretty clear we’re going to allow the House to work its will,” he added. “It means that the leaders may not get what they want every day.”

Typically, opposition to spending cuts comes from those defending the programs facing the ax. For GOP leaders, the tough sell is to their own newest members – their majority makers who say the cuts aren’t deep enough.

A tough, intraparty struggle has been expected ever since voters sent 87 GOP freshman to the House after a campaign that turned on debt and spending. Eighty-nine members of the Republican Study Committee, the conservative wing of the GOP caucus, signed a letter to Speaker Boehner calling for $100 billion less than House Democrats proposed spending.

This week’s floor defeats – on measures expected to pass easily – further rattled GOP leaders, sparking speculation that the majority couldn't govern, or at least count votes.

  • On Tuesday, 26 Republicans broke party ranks to vote down a measure to extend expiring provisions of the Patriot Act, an antiterrorism bill rushed through Congress after the 9/11 attacks. The bill comes back to the floor on Friday.
  • Next, GOP leaders pulled a trade bill, also headed toward defeat.
  • On Wednesday, Republicans lost a vote on what was expected to be a popular measure to require the United Nations to refund $179 million in overpayments. All but 23 Democrats plus two Republicans opposed the move after the Obama administration made a case that the bill would defund new security measures at the UN.

Democrats said the past week shows that Republicans aren’t ready to govern. “The majority is giving us paralysis – all talk and no jobs,” said Rep. Robert Andrews (D) of New Jersey, on the House floor on Thursday. Moreover, the Patriot Act extensions and other recent measures came to the floor without hearings, he added.

“I thought all along that the Republicans would have a hard time finding a working majority,” says pollster G. Terry Madonna, who directs the Center for Politics and Public Affairs at Franklin and Marshall College in Lancaster, Penn.


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story