Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Healthcare reform 'fixes' pass, but is bipartisanship lost?

Other large social programs like Medicare and Social Security passed with strong bipartisan majorities, but healthcare reform and its package of 'fixes' lacked a single Republican vote. Republican leaders call the process used to pass healthcare reform a 'game-changer.'

(Page 2 of 2)

When then-majority Republicans tried to change the rules of the Senate to ease passage of President Bush’s judicial nominations in 2005, Graham joined the bipartisan “Gang of 14” to work out a compromise to preserve minority rights. He says the process used to pass healthcare reform was worse than the changes contemplated by then-majority Republicans over judicial nominations. “The minority has played an important role in our democracy,” he says.

Skip to next paragraph

Three Democrats who had voted for the Senate healthcare bill on Dec. 24, 2009 – Sens. Blanche Lincoln and Mark Pryor of Arkansas and Sen. Ben Nelson of Nebraska – split with party leaders over this week’s vote on fixes, which passed 56 to 43. “I vote independently," said Senator Nelson. "I told [Democratic leaders] I was not going to be part of a bloc voting a certain way.”

Commenting on the absence of Republican votes on healthcare reform, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D) of Rhode Island says: “It has the superficial appearance of being a discouraging thing and not reflecting well on the bill. But the unfortunate fact is that Senate Republicans early on adopted a clear plan and now-admitted strategy that they were going to deny Republican support to anything and everything to wound and diminish America’s new president.”

“I hope this week’s passage of healthcare reform represents a turning point in that strategy,” he adds.

On the House side, parties traded shots over who is responsible for the ugly tone on the House floor and threats to members of Congress who voted for healthcare reform. House leaders report that since voting for healthcare reform, some 10 Democrats have been threatened or had offices vandalized.

“I know many Americans are angry over this healthcare bill and angry at Democrats here in Washington for not listening. But as I've said before, violence and threats are unacceptable,” said House Republican leader John Boehner in a briefing on Thursday. “We need to take that anger and channel it into what I would describe as positive change."

Responding to criticism in her own caucus that Republicans have fired up angry crowds and raised the threat level, Speaker Nancy Pelosi said: "I don't subscribe to the fact that these acts of violence sprang from any words of my colleagues. But I do think that this Congress and this House of Representatives is a classroom, and that it's inappropriate for members of Congress to stand up and cheer when these sentiments are expressed in the gallery. That's different from saying that it provoked it.”

She added: “But I think we have to manage this issue very carefully, recognizing we are a democracy."