Supreme Court: judges have leeway on criminal restitution deadline

A federal law mandates that judges decide restitution in criminal cases within 90 days of sentencing. But the Supreme Court ruled Monday that judges could impose the dollar figure after the deadline so long as they said beforehand that they were going to order restitution.

By , Staff writer

  • close
    The US Supreme Court ruled on the issue of criminal restitution Monday.
    View Caption

The US Supreme Court on Monday ruled that judges can order restitution payments in criminal cases even after a 90-day deadline has expired.

At issue in the case was how to interpret the federal statute that authorizes the imposition of restitution payments, and which includes the provision of the 90-day deadline. The court split 5 to 4 in the decision.

Writing for the majority, Justice Stephen Breyer embraced a flexible view of the statute. He stressed that as long as a judge made clear that restitution would be part of the sentence, the judge could take longer than 90 days to impose that penalty.

Recommended: Do you know the facts behind Arizona's immigration law? Take our quiz.

“We hold that a sentencing court that misses the 90-day deadline nonetheless retains the power to order restitution,” Breyer wrote. He said the decision is limited to those judges who “made clear prior to the deadline’s expiration that it would order restitution, leaving open only the amount.”

Chief Justice John Roberts dissented. He said the majority’s position undercuts the value of finality of an imposed sentence.

“The rule is that a trial court cannot alter a sentence after the time of sentencing,” Roberts said.

Not the usual suspects

The decision is interesting in part because it drew a somewhat unusual lineup of justices. Justice John Paul Stevens – who frequently votes with the court’s liberal wing – joined conservative Justices Antonin Scalia and Anthony Kennedy in signing on to the Roberts dissent.

Meanwhile, Justice Clarence Thomas – who frequently votes with the court’s conservatives – provided the key fifth vote for Breyer’s majority opinion.

The sentencing issue arose in the case of Brian Dolan, who pleaded guilty in 2007 to a federal charge of assault resulting in serious bodily injury. Dolan was sentenced to 21 months in prison and three years of supervised release.

Restitution in the case was mandatory, but the judge acknowledged that he had insufficient information to order full restitution at the time of the sentencing hearing. During the hearing, the judge said he was leaving the restitution issue open to receive more information.

The federal probation office provided the extra information more than two months after Dolan’s sentencing hearing – but still more than three weeks before the 90-day statutory deadline would expire.

Despite the approaching deadline, the judge set a hearing on the restitution issue nearly four months later. At that hearing, Dolan’s lawyer complained that the deadline to impose restitution had already passed. The judge rejected the argument.

A month later, the judge ordered Dolan to pay his victim nearly $105,000 in restitution. By the time the order was issued, Dolan had already been released from prison.

On appeal, the Tenth US Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the district judge upholding the restitution order.

Split decisions

Federal appeals courts were split on the question of whether the statute permitted restitution orders beyond the 90-day deadline. Two circuits, the First based in Boston and the Eighth in St. Louis, had ruled that such orders were permitted after the 90-day deadline. Two other circuits, the Seventh based in Chicago and the Eleventh in Atlanta ruled that the statute created a firm deadline and that no restitution orders were authorized after the deadline.

“Unless one reads the relevant statute’s 90-day deadline as an ironclad limit upon the judge’s authority to make a final determination of the victim’s losses, the statute before us itself provides adequate authority to do what the sentencing judge did here,” Breyer wrote for the majority.

Roberts and his fellow dissenters read the statute as imposing an ironclad limit. “These provisions authorize restitution orders at sentencing,” he wrote. “They confer no authority to order restitution after sentencing has concluded.”

The chief justice added: “The court’s suggestion to require notice of intent to augment the sentence at some future date may be a good idea. But an even better one might be to set a particular date – say, 90 days after sentencing – on which the parties could base their expectations.”

Roberts said, “That was Congress’s choice, and it should be good enough for us.”

Other Supreme Court news Monday:

Share this story:

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.

Loading...

Loading...

Loading...

eZ debug

Clear cache:

Quick settings:

Timing: Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Script start
Timing: Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Module start 'content'
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: path in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezwebin/autoloads/ezpagedata.php on line 158
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: path in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezwebin/autoloads/ezpagedata.php on line 175
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: path in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezwebin/autoloads/ezpagedata.php on line 158
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: path in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezwebin/autoloads/ezpagedata.php on line 175
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezfind/classes/ezfindresultnode.php on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezfind/classes/ezfindresultnode.php on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezfind/classes/ezfindresultnode.php on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezfind/classes/ezfindresultnode.php on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_remote_id_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/csm_base/classes/CSMFunctionCollection.php on line 1028
Warning: eZTemplate:def @ extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tpl:10[1] Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Variable 'story_source' is already defined.
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/ezfind/classes/ezfindresultnode.php on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Undefined index: meta_remote_id_ms in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/csm_base/classes/CSMFunctionCollection.php on line 1028
Timing: Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Module end 'content'
Timing: Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Before parse_includes
Strict: PHP: E_STRICT Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Non-static method MugoViewExtras::get_view_extras() should not be called statically, assuming $this from incompatible context in /var/www/www.csmonitor.com/extension/mugo_view_extras/autoloads/template_operators.php on line 37
Warning: eZTemplate:def @ extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/extra/archive.tpl:21[1] Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
Variable 'view_extra_node' is already defined.
Timing: Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
After parse_includes
Timing: Jul 09 2014 12:58:45
End

Timing points:

CheckpointElapsedRel. ElapsedMemoryRel. Memory
Script start 0.0000 sec0.0122 sec 1,286.1328 KB1,162.2813 KB
Module start 'content' 0.0122 sec1.5861 sec 2,448.4141 KB12,367.0313 KB
Module end 'content' 1.5983 sec0.0169 sec 14,815.4453 KB396.7656 KB
Before parse_includes 1.6152 sec0.0360 sec 15,212.2109 KB273.2109 KB
After parse_includes 1.6511 sec0.0007 sec 15,485.4219 KB-184.3906 KB
End 1.6519 sec  15,301.0313 KB 
Total runtime:1.6577 sec
Peak memory usage:21,083.5625 KB

Time accumulators:

 Accumulator Elapsed Percent Count Average
ini_load
Load cache0.0079 sec0.4753%370.0002 sec
Mysql Total
Mysqli_queries0.1542 sec9.2886%2180.0007 sec
Looping result0.0395 sec2.3785%2070.0002 sec
Template Total1.6070 sec 96.8% 8 0.2009 sec
Template load0.0079 sec0.4780%80.0010 sec
Template processing1.5989 sec96.3320%80.1999 sec
Template load and register function0.0003 sec0.0175%40.0001 sec
states
state_id_array0.0075 sec0.4500%150.0005 sec
state_identifier_array0.0110 sec0.6627%200.0005 sec
override
Cache load0.0078 sec0.4725%1060.0001 sec
eZ Find
Search0.2348 sec14.1438%20.1174 sec
Query build0.0054 sec0.3226%10.0054 sec
Class attribute list0.0755 sec4.5480%10.0755 sec
Engine time0.0264 sec1.5911%10.0264 sec
MoreLikeThis0.0000 sec0.0000%00.0000 sec
Sytem overhead
Fetch class attribute can translate value0.0048 sec0.2908%50.0010 sec
Fetch class attribute name0.0003 sec0.0168%120.0000 sec
XML
Image XML parsing0.0083 sec0.4980%50.0017 sec
class_abstraction
Instantiating content class attribute0.0001 sec0.0084%150.0000 sec
General
String conversion0.0000 sec0.0008%30.0000 sec
dbfile0.0023 sec0.1390%700.0000 sec
View Extra building0.0102 sec0.6129%40.0025 sec
Total script time:1.6597 sec

CSS/JS files loaded with "ezjscPacker" during request:

CacheTypePacklevelSourceFiles
01a980f93dc967c6e39d52a11ae2108b_1404899611_all.cssCSS3extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/stylesheets/normalize.css
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/stylesheets/html5b.css
design/standard/stylesheets/debug.css
extension/ezwt/design/standard/stylesheets/websitetoolbar.css
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/stylesheets/jquery-ui-1.10.3.custom.min.css
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/stylesheets/desktop.css
ede0a88fd146f1a095d27fb22227d0e5_1398846822.jsJS2extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/modernizr.js
extension/csm_base/design/standard/javascript/jquery-1.10.2.min.js
1650da1ba852ac5f9af81af07e8fa105_1404899611.jsJS2extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/jquery-ui-1.10.4.min.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/json2.js
extension/csm_base/design/standard/javascript/jquery.cookie.min.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/jquery.mobile.custom.min.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.arthole.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.sticky.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.csmstory.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.right_column.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.csmstory_editorspickdialog.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.sailthru_signup.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.jcarousel.min.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.history.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.mainNav.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.gallery.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/plugins/jquery.staffdialog.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/jQuery.rollChildren.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/pubService_extended.js
extension/csm_base/design/standard/javascript/csm/csmNew.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/jquery.quiz.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/jquery.spectrumQuiz.js
extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/javascript/global.js

Templates used to render the page:

UsageRequested templateTemplateTemplate loadedEditOverride
1node/view/full.tplfull/article.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/full/article.tplEdit templateOverride template
20content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/paragraph.tpl<No override>extension/ezwebin/design/ezwebin/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/paragraph.tplEdit templateOverride template
3content/datatype/view/ezimage.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezimage.tplEdit templateOverride template
2content/datatype/view/ezstring.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezstring.tplEdit templateOverride template
20content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/link.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/link.tplEdit templateOverride template
4content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/header.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/header.tplEdit templateOverride template
2content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/strong.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/strong.tplEdit templateOverride template
4content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/li.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/li.tplEdit templateOverride template
2content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/ul.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/ul.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezobjectrelationlist.tplcontent/datatype/view/story_images.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/story_images.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/eztext.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/eztext.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezstring.tplcontent/datatype/view/image_credit.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/image_credit.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tplcontent/datatype/view/story_info_box.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/story_info_box.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezmatrix.tplcontent/datatype/view/ezmatrix_article_related_external_links.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/ezmatrix_article_related_external_links.tplEdit templateOverride template
1pagelayout.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/pagelayout.tplEdit templateOverride template
1modules/mugo_view_extras/extra_cached.tpl<No override>extension/mugo_view_extras/design/standard/templates/modules/mugo_view_extras/extra_cached.tplEdit templateOverride template
1setup/debug_toolbar.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/setup/debug_toolbar.tplEdit templateOverride template
 Number of times templates used: 68
 Number of unique templates used: 19
 Time used to render template usage: 0.0005 secs