Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Modern Parenthood

Kids, educators debate recess plan that may prevent bullying

Kids and educators debate effectiveness of new, structured recess plan that may help prevent bullying and lead to safer schools. A new study shows conflicting opinions on the Playworks program.

By Correspondent / April 17, 2012

Kids and educators debate effectiveness of new, structured recess plan that may help prevent bullying and lead to safer schools. A new study shows conflicting opinions on the Playworks program that has been implemented in hundreds of low-income school across the country.

Adam Nadel / Special to The Christian Science Monitor

Enlarge

One of the largest independent recess programs in the country reduces bullying, improves classroom behavior and creates safer schools – at least according to teachers. Students, however, seem to have a different point of view.
 
This is from a new rigorous, random assignment study by researchers at Mathematica Policy Research and the John W. Gardner Center for Youth and Their Communities at Stanford University, in Stanford, Calif. The researchers compared schools using Playworks – a recess initiative that has won hundreds of millions of grant dollars and is used in hundreds of low income elementary schools – to those that had requested, but did not yet have, the program.
 
 To advocates of Playworks, including chief executive officers Jill Vialet, the findings add to a growing body of research pointing to the importance of play and recess for children.

Skip to next paragraph

Correspondent

is a longtime Monitor correspondent. She lives in Andover, Mass. with her husband, her two young daughters, a South African Labrador retriever and an imperialist cat..

Recent posts

 “We’re really excited to see the results,” Ms. Vialet said. “We’re not even an anti-bullying program. [The research] pointed to me how clearly bullying is really a behavior. It’s a behavior that can be addressed by emphasizing other behaviors and giving kids skills.”
 
 But take closer look at the study and there are some significant questions, as well.
 
 Most notably, there’s a big difference in how teachers and students perceived the impact of Playworks – a program that gives more structure to recess, with “coaches” leading games, helping kids moderate conflicts and encouraging physical activity.
 
 While teachers in schools using Playworks reported significantly less bullying and exclusionary behavior, there was no difference in student perception of aggressive behavior, the ability to get along with other students or resolving conflicts.
 
 So what’s up?
 
 Susanne James-Burdumy, associate director of Mathematica Policy Research, said researchers have been thinking about why the disparity exists.
 
 It could potentially be study related, she said. While teachers filled out their surveys based on observations of first through fifth graders, the only students to fill out surveys were in fourth and fifth grade. (Researchers worried that younger kids would not give accurate results.) Or, she said, there might simply be different perspectives about Playworks.
 
 “Students and teachers may have different perceptions of what’s happening during recess and during the school day,” she said.
 
 Which leads to another big finding. One of the most statistically important findings was that with Playworks, teachers believe students move more effectively from recess to the classroom.
 
 This, it seems, would make sense. Playworks is structured by design, and began as a way to make the school day easier for teachers – while preserving play at the same time.
 
 Vialet says she was inspired to start the program after talking with principals who told her that recess was the worst part of the day – a time when kids would get out of control and fights would start, often leading into the classroom. She says that it seemed that students were not using recess for the sort of beneficial play that she remembered as a kid.
 
 “What I was seeing out in schools was that the recess I remember wasn’t happening,” she said.

She believed that replicating the sort of sandlot structure of older kids teaching younger kids how to play games – of introducing games like “rock, paper, scissors” to resolve conflicts,  of “mapping” out a playground so everyone knew that basketball would be played here and jump rope there – would go far in both making a more fulfilling recess for kids, and a better school day for the grown-ups.
 
 But does an easier time for teachers translate into effective play? Certainly for beleaguered public schools administrators. But for kids?
 
 More results from the study – due to come out in about a year – may give more insight. That data will explore the difference in recess behavior between students in Playworks and non Playworks schools.

Permissions

Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story

  • Weekly review of global news and ideas
  • Balanced, insightful and trustworthy
  • Subscribe in print or digital

Special Offer

 

Doing Good

 

What happens when ordinary people decide to pay it forward? Extraordinary change...

Endeavor Global, cofounded by Linda Rottenberg (here at the nonprofit’s headquarters in New York), helps entrepreneurs in emerging markets.

Linda Rottenberg helps people pursue dreams – and create thousands of jobs

She's chief executive of Endeavor Global, a nonprofit group that gives a leg up to budding entrepreneurs.

 
 
Become a fan! Follow us! Google+ YouTube See our feeds!