Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Culture Cafe

Benjamin Zander and the Youth Philharmonic Orchestra are a lesson in dedication

The New England Conservatory's Youth Philharmonic Orchestra, led by renowned conductor Benjamin Zander, find that dedication and hard work make a world of difference. Starting June 14, the Youth Philharmonic Orchestra is going on tour to Austria, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia to commemorate the 100th anniversary of Gustav Mahler’s death

(Page 2 of 2)

Almost every musician, whether it’s an eight year old pianist or an experienced, professional violinist, has been told to play beyond the black and white notes on the page. However, Mahler’s Symphony No. 9 goes a bit further. The notes on the page only begin to suggest the emotion that can be pulled out of the piece, and each note is metaphorically significant to that time in Mahler’s life. The Ninth was Mahler’s last completed composition and serves as a farewell to the world as well as a reflection of the atmosphere of those last years. As a composer, Mahler was stuck in the middle of two periods in musical history—the dissipating world of expressive Romanticism, and the emerging methods of the Second Viennese school (Schoenberg, Webern, Berg) that suggested the movement of music to more cerebral realms. This struggle is evident in the first movement, with the pushing and pulling of these two forces presented in opposing passages that represent these different worlds. The second movement can be seen as a whole metaphor in and of itself. The movement is written as a Viennese dance called a Ländler, but is shaky, unstable, and distorted into an almost unrecognizable version of the traditional dance. Occasional fragments of the original theme surface, but it’s often overtaken by an almost sinister guide. According to Zander, this movement is meant “to convey the feeling that the splendor and warmth of traditional Vienna have vanished, that only their shadow remains.” Zander said of the symphony, "If I only had to conduct one piece of music before I died, the Mahler 9 would be it."

Skip to next paragraph

Recent posts

Not only does Mahler’s symphony demand the ability to play emotionally beyond the written notes, but it demands an understanding of all the musical metaphors present. The YPO understands. They played further than the score, but they played even further than the music itself. Their tone as an orchestra was full and rich, and their confidence was evident in their sound as well as their entrances and layering. The attacks of the separate parts were assured, such as in the third movement, which tips its hat to Baroque moods with ubiquitous counterpoint. Each line of the orchestra, from the trumpets to the determined strings, was confident in its duty; like a spider web, each strand is crucial to the construction of the symphony, and the YPO kept it gleaming and certain. Some of the most breathtaking parts of the Mahler Ninth are the translucent areas where the curtain of sound is thin. In the massive , heart-wrenching fourth movement, this happens multiple times—the bassoon solo, the French horn solo that soars over the hushed orchestra, and, especially, when the violins are hanging by a thread on a high-register melody while the cellos and basses lurk behind them. These are delicate areas, and they were played with care. The YPO was able to understand the layers of the symphony while staying true to its intricacy. “One of the problems with a modern interpretation of Mahler is that the great orchestras are so familiar with it, and they find it easier to play; they forget its complexity,” said Zander. The YPO didn’t only make me live inside Mahler’s music, but in Mahler’s concluding life.

When listening to the YPO’s recordings, I didn’t feel as though I was listening to a youth orchestra. However, it wasn’t that I pictured an adult orchestra playing the pieces—it was that the YPO sounded capable and determined, two adjectives that are often associated with older ensembles. Age often obscures success, and the YPO was able to transcend that and make me think only of the music that they performed. Though it sounds simple, for a youth orchestra it’s one of the most difficult tasks to make an audience forget that they are a youth orchestra and to just become source of music. "Music is really a mysterious force, and we don’t really know how it works, but it transforms people, and the audience was transformed on that night," said Zander of the concert on June 3rd.

Hitting the right notes, shaping phrases expressively, creating perfect moments of silence—these are certainly things that make music sound great. But something that isn’t as measurable, but is certainly evident, is dedication. Zander believes this dedication begins with teaching. He said, “One of the things I do is I give all my kids an A in the first month of the year. They’re all A students. I teach the person who they see as the person they want to be." Here’s one of the areas where dedication morphs into inspiration.

Then it got me thinking; dedication comes in threads. Mahler was loyal to his craft, and out of it came music that not only brings tears to the eyes of listeners a century later but serves as a mirror into his inner workings. Through composers’ commitment, conductors are inspired. Conductors of orchestras must be devoted to the music they choose to work on, such as Zander’s dedication to Mahler. “I’ve had a lifetime of thinking about this music and I come home to my youth orchestra and bring home all that I’ve learned and discovered about this piece,” he said. Conductors must also be committed to the process of leading—Zander said, “It takes 30 years to build an orchestra like this. We’ve been on 15 international tours. This is the culmination.”

Musicians’ dedication fuels their inspiration to perform. In turn, listeners are inspired by them, and so on. It may be easy to give up on things and to turn our backs on daunting tasks. But, if we’re lucky, we can get picked up on one of these threads. “Let’s not kids ourselves—it’s not magic,” says Zander of the music he conducts. And he’s right; it’s simply hard work. But if we just close our eyes, it can certainly feel like magic.

Elena blogs at Neo Antennae.


The Christian Science Monitor has assembled a diverse group of music, film, and television bloggers. Our guest bloggers are not employed or directed by The Monitor and the views expressed are the bloggers' own and they are responsible for the content of their blogs. To contact us about a blogger, click here.

Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story