BP oil spill cleanup: US says the coast is nearly clear. Is it? (+video)
Three years after the BP oil spill, the US Coast Guard says only 95 miles of coastline remain to be cleaned. But critics say the full extent of the damage is not yet known, especially in Louisiana, where oil is deep in the coastal environment.
(Page 2 of 2)
Environmental groups are also worried because they say the oil-soaked environment continues to damage wildlife reproduction cycles, which will receive less attention once the recovery effort ends. A NWF report, released in April, uses data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) to show that dolphin deaths are above average since the spill and that infant dolphins were found dead at six times the average in January and February. Killifish, sea turtles, and coral species are also badly damaged, the report says.Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
“The idea that just because BP discontinues their active response that [the coast] is cleaned up is untrue,” says Mr. Muth.
The state says the recovery efforts so far have primarily focused on beaches, a problem since the majority of Louisiana’s coast consists of wetlands, which makes beach remediation largely unnecessary.
“BP has refused to do any type of proactive oil reconnaissance effort” in Louisiana,” says Mr. Graves, who is leading Louisiana’s efforts to restore its wetlands. “They are refusing to go find the oil in areas adjacent to our wetlands, yet they walked and drove entirely shorelines in Mississippi, Alabama, and Florida for years – where relatively little oil shored.”
BP spokesman Jason Ryan characterizes Graves's assessment as "misleading." "We have proactively carried out a comprehensive effort to locate and remove residual oil from the Louisiana shoreline," he says. [Editor's note: This paragraph was added to the original story once BP returned the reporter's phone call.]
The state is also wary of the relationship between BP and the Coast Guard. Howell says that while his agency “has federal oversight to oversee all operations,” the shoreline crews are BP contractors hired largely from Danos, a Louisiana company whose relationship with the company dates back to 2009, one year before the spill.
“We have shoreline treatment regulations they have to follow,” he says. “The Coast Guard is out there making sure the recommendations are followed.”
Graves disagrees, saying “BP runs the show” in the recovery on the ground.
“It has been fascinating and frustrating to experience a private company dictating federal agency actions – a modern day case of Stockholm Syndrome. We have seen nothing that anyone other than BP is supervising their cleanup contractors,” he says.
However, one of the difficulties from treating oil in a wetlands environment is that exposure could cause more damage than letting it natural degrade over time, says Frank Galgano, an expert on coastline ecology at Villanova University outside Philadelphia.
“If it never gets exposed again, it’s just going to decay,” Dr. Galgano says. The fragility of the wetlands means “it’s not a very responsive or resilient environment,” so active dredging, and other recovery techniques, means the possibility of creating damage.
“There’s always unintended consequences when you change the natural system,” he says. While walking away from an active recovery phase may “sound like someone is trying to get out of their obligation, but maybe not. Sometimes the cure is worse than the disease.”
While BP has paid about $14 billion in response activities and settlement payouts to damages unrelated to restoration, a civil trial enters its second of three phases in September that will ultimately determine how much the company is on the hook to pay out in environmental penalties. The civil damages from the upcoming trial are estimated at about $20 billion.
According to comments made by BP CEO Bob Dudley in July, the company, which has set aside $42.4 billion overall for Gulf oil spill compensation, is less likely to negotiate a settlement and, instead, is prepared to fight in court.
"It's highly unlikely we are now going to enter into some sort of detailed settlement discussions. Unfortunately, some of the circumstances that are happening today suggest that it may be in the best interests of our shareholders now to play it long,” he said, according to Dow Jones Newswires in July.
In the meantime, the Gulf Coast Ecosystem Restoration Council, which includes the governors of all five coastal states, will meet in New Orleans on Aug. 28 to vote on a restoration plan that was finalized in May. The council will oversee the spending of 60 percent of any BP oil spill fines, 30 percent of which will be administered according to the plan.
RECOMMENDED: Legacy of an oil spill on the Gulf Coast