Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Don't listen to the Chicken Littles: Obama made smart investments in green tech

A few falling acorns (Solyndra and A123) don't mean the sky is falling on clean technology. Far from it. The federal government’s track record on supporting green energy tech is an enviable one. And this investment is improving America’s energy, economic, and environmental fortunes.

By John Rogers and David Friedman / January 4, 2013

Tesla workers cheer for one of the first Tesla Model S cars sold, seen here at the Tesla factory in Fremont, Calif., June 22. Op-ed contributors John Rogers and David Friedman say 'clean tech is on the rise nationwide in large part due to federal investment.' Yes, 'there are risks when government and industry invest boldly in new technology. But if they don’t, America will cede its leadership on [clean tech] to other nations like China...'

Paul Sakuma/AP/File


Cambridge, Mass. and Washington

There seem to be a lot of Chicken Littles yelling about the clean technology industry lately. Despite a myriad of successes, a few falling acorns are mis-portrayed in a wave of statements and stories claiming the sky is falling on clean technology. Unfortunately, these predictions of economic collapse often lack context, focusing on a single failed company instead of the success of the clean technology industry as a whole.

Skip to next paragraph

Take the stories about A123 Systems, a Massachusetts-based electric-car battery manufacturer that received funds from the 2009 economic stimulus package to build a factory in Michigan. It spent a little more than half of the $249 million it was approved for before declaring bankruptcy in October.

Politicians and advocacy groups quickly portrayed the bankruptcy as a sign that clean tech was a bad investment and that the Obama administration made a mistake when it put support for energy innovators and the jobs they create as one of the centerpieces of its 2009 stimulus package.

Yes, a battery company failed. But that doesn’t mean that the sky is falling. Far from it. These programs are succeeding because, not in spite of, a willingness to take some risks on a better future.

Federal backing supports technologies that promise great rewards for the US, but carry greater risks than private investors are usually willing to take on their own. America simply cannot afford to pass up the opportunity to bolster growing industries that improve our nation’s energy, economic, and environmental fortunes. The country started subsidizing oil and gas development nearly 100 years ago because of the benefits they could provide then. Now it makes sense now to nurture new, promising low-carbon alternatives instead.

The federal government’s track record on supporting clean tech is an enviable one, with far more winners than losers. Of the 30 battery and electric-drive firms that received stimulus funding, 28 continue to deliver. And in the case of A123 and EnerDel, the other such company that went into bankruptcy, work will continue at these US facilities. Further, A123 and EnerDel represent just 18 percent of the vehicle battery grants, meaning 82 percent of that portfolio is still performing.

The large number of renewable energy companies that received taxpayer backing are doing well, too. In fact, of the 26 that received federal loans, 23 are still on track. One other, Beacon Power, is going through bankruptcy, but it is still operating, and has nearly paid back its entire federally backed loan. The other two were Abound and Solyndra, the latter of which became the first failed company the Chicken Littles thoroughly politicized. But the collective risk from those three companies totals just 6 percent of the portfolio. In other words, 94 percent of the investments are still performing.


  • Weekly review of global news and ideas
  • Balanced, insightful and trustworthy
  • Subscribe in print or digital

Special Offer


Editors' picks

Doing Good


What happens when ordinary people decide to pay it forward? Extraordinary change...

Endeavor Global, cofounded by Linda Rottenberg (here at the nonprofit’s headquarters in New York), helps entrepreneurs in emerging markets.

Linda Rottenberg helps people pursue dreams – and create thousands of jobs

She's chief executive of Endeavor Global, a nonprofit group that gives a leg up to budding entrepreneurs.

Become a fan! Follow us! Google+ YouTube See our feeds!