Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Opinion

Could Congress shut down YouTube with Internet-blacklist bill?

The Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act (COICA) passed a Senate committee last year. If it becomes law, this flawed attempt to curtail online copyright infringement could spell big trouble for Internet freedom.

(Page 2 of 2)



If we don’t think China should be able to outlaw Twitter, perhaps we shouldn’t start banning websites in our own country. The good intention of protecting online media rights isn’t enough to merit hypocrisy.

Skip to next paragraph

Already laws in place

People should be paid for what they produce, and copyrighted material shouldn’t be distributed unlawfully; however, there are already laws in place to protect these rights, such as the Digital Millenium Copyright Act (DMCA). The DMCA requires that copyrighted material be removed from infringing websites, but the websites on which they are found can remain active.

Top 5 Google Labs projects

The new COICA bill would take censorship to a new level in the United States. Under this bill, non-infringing material would be removed as well. [Editor’s note: The original version misstated one of the legislation's penalties.]

Though the bill is directed at pirating and file-sharing websites, there are countless other websites that could potentially be indicted if a court decides that enough people use them for copyright infringement.

YouTube, for example, is an Internet hub for sharing political and social thought as well as for creativity and entertainment. If COICA became law and a court deemed that a large-enough proportion of YouTube users were violating copyrights, YouTube could be blacklisted entirely.

A damaging double standard

COICA sends the wrong message to a generation of young Americans who rely on free Internet discussion for public discourse. And such blanket censorship by the US government would dangerously undercut America’s support for freedom of expression abroad. Censorship and “the land of the free” don’t have much in common, and it seems strange, particularly now, to combine them. Especially since our president has publicly claimed to oppose Internet restriction internationally.

The DMCA takedown process is already in place to protect copyright material in the US. The proper course of action is to use the laws we already have.

Perhaps the US Senate needs a dose of old wives’ wisdom: Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. Continue to police for copyright infringement, but don’t interfere with Internet innovation and technological growth.

Gina Tomaine is a freelance journalist who focuses on technology.

Permissions

Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story