Costs will rein in Arizona's immigration crackdown

Arizona can arrest illegal immigrants now, but then what? Prison and deportation are both too expensive to sustain.


  • close
    Arizona rancher David Walker stands at the border wall with Mexico on Aug. 15, in Hereford, Ariz. Walker was attending the United Border Coalition Tea Party Rally in support of Arizona's immigration law, SB1070, along a remote stretch of the Arizona-Mexico border.
    View Caption

Suppose the US Supreme Court largely upholds Arizona's tough immigration law and, as a result, Arizona police pick up an extra 5,000 or 10,000 unlawful immigrants next year. Then what?

Arizona could slap illegal aliens with a $100 fine. It could arrest them. Or it could turn them over to federal officials, supposedly to be deported. The latter two options turn out to be expensive.

Around the world, country after country is facing the costly dilemma of what to do with perhaps 50 million illegal, undocumented immigrants collectively. It's a problem for Canada, Britain, France, Italy, and Spain. India tries to limit immigrants from Bangladesh. South Africa has troubles with illegal Zimbabwean immigrants.

Recommended: Do you know the facts behind Arizona's immigration law? Take our quiz.

Even Mexico has to deal with illegal aliens from Honduras and Guatemala.

Some countries try to obscure the problem. Japan puts black immigrants from Africa, called "trainees," to work at night on construction jobs where they are less visible, says Joseph Chamie, director of the Center for Migration Studies in New York. Other countries ignore the issue. Israel figures that almost half of its 220,000 foreign workers have no work permits.

Beside the moral, humanitarian, and legal issues surrounding illegal immigrants, their apprehension poses a sizable financial cost. In Arizona, police could arrest them under the new state law, but keeping them in already crowded jails costs roughly $100 a day per person. For 5,000 people, imprisonment costs could add up to $182.5 million a year. That's a hefty charge for a state struggling with a budget deficit of at least $368 million.

Presumably Arizona could save money by handing illegal immigrants over to the federal government for deportation. In fiscal 2008, the US deported 369,221 people. Deportations rose to 389,834 in 2009 under the Obama administration, and are predicted to reach 400,000 this fiscal year.

Whether Washington will pay for more deportations is problematic. The United States deports each year less than 4 percent of its estimated 11 million illegal immigrants. At that rate, it would take more than two decades to deport all of them.

The cost to deport all illegal immigrants would be at least $94 billion, Julie Myers, then-head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), estimated in 2007. Other estimates put the cost at three times that.

Because of a limited budget and political factors, each Washington administration has given ICE a set of priorities in enforcing immigration law. The priorities for the Obama administration are aliens who pose a danger to national security or a risk to public safety, recent illegal entrants, and fugitive aliens (already convicted of crimes or previously deported), according to John Morton, the present head of ICE, in a memo dated June 30. ICE, however, "only has resources to remove approximately 400,000 aliens per year." In other words, Congress has not approved the money to enforce fully the immigration laws it has passed.

That leaves Arizona with the option of using fines and arrests to make life uncomfortable for illegal immigrants. Any serious enforcement of the Arizona law, notes Steve Camarota, research director of the Center for Immigration Studies in Washington, would probably cause some illegal immigrants to go home or move to some other state. That would save taxpayer money.

Polls show the general public would approve of Arizona's measures to shrink its illegal immigrant population, estimated at 460,000.

David R. Francis writes a weekly column.

Share this story:

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.




eZ debug

Clear cache:

Quick settings:

Timing: Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Script start
Timing: Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Module start 'content'
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 158
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 175
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 158
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 175
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Undefined index: meta_remote_id_ms in /var/www/ on line 1028
Warning: PHP: E_WARNING Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
exif_read_data(0803-Arizona-Immigration.jpg): Incorrect APP1 Exif Identifier Code in /var/www/ on line 61
Timing: Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Module end 'content'
Timing: Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Before parse_includes
Strict: PHP: E_STRICT Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Non-static method MugoViewExtras::get_view_extras() should not be called statically, assuming $this from incompatible context in /var/www/ on line 37
Warning: eZTemplate:def @ extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/extra/archive.tpl:21[1] Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
Variable 'view_extra_node' is already defined.
Timing: Jul 09 2014 11:14:44
After parse_includes
Timing: Jul 09 2014 11:14:44

Timing points:

CheckpointElapsedRel. ElapsedMemoryRel. Memory
Script start 0.0000 sec0.0139 sec 1,285.9922 KB1,162.1563 KB
Module start 'content' 0.0139 sec1.8260 sec 2,448.1484 KB12,400.1172 KB
Module end 'content' 1.8399 sec0.0362 sec 14,848.2656 KB398.0078 KB
Before parse_includes 1.8761 sec0.0535 sec 15,246.2734 KB271.3359 KB
After parse_includes 1.9296 sec0.0016 sec 15,517.6094 KB-183.3438 KB
End 1.9312 sec  15,334.2656 KB 
Total runtime:1.9383 sec
Peak memory usage:21,099.4063 KB

Time accumulators:

 Accumulator Elapsed Percent Count Average
Load cache0.0073 sec0.3753%370.0002 sec
Mysql Total
Mysqli_queries0.1855 sec9.5625%2260.0008 sec
Looping result0.0545 sec2.8096%2150.0003 sec
Template Total1.8714 sec 96.4% 7 0.2673 sec
Template load0.0078 sec0.4028%70.0011 sec
Template processing1.8635 sec96.0390%70.2662 sec
Template load and register function0.0003 sec0.0156%40.0001 sec
state_id_array0.0093 sec0.4786%180.0005 sec
state_identifier_array0.0173 sec0.8932%240.0007 sec
Cache load0.0079 sec0.4048%1070.0001 sec
eZ Find
Search0.0828 sec4.2678%10.0828 sec
Query build0.0754 sec3.8845%10.0754 sec
Class attribute list0.0706 sec3.6370%10.0706 sec
Engine time0.0049 sec0.2541%10.0049 sec
MoreLikeThis0.0000 sec0.0000%00.0000 sec
Sytem overhead
Fetch class attribute can translate value0.0023 sec0.1194%50.0005 sec
Fetch class attribute name0.0002 sec0.0127%110.0000 sec
Image XML parsing0.0085 sec0.4385%50.0017 sec
Instantiating content class attribute0.0001 sec0.0073%130.0000 sec
String conversion0.0000 sec0.0011%30.0000 sec
dbfile0.0022 sec0.1134%670.0000 sec
View Extra building0.0131 sec0.6736%40.0033 sec
Total script time:1.9403 sec

CSS/JS files loaded with "ezjscPacker" during request:


Templates used to render the page:

UsageRequested templateTemplateTemplate loadedEditOverride
1node/view/full.tplfull/article.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/full/article.tplEdit templateOverride template
22content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/paragraph.tpl<No override>extension/ezwebin/design/ezwebin/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/paragraph.tplEdit templateOverride template
3content/datatype/view/ezimage.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezimage.tplEdit templateOverride template
20content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/link.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/link.tplEdit templateOverride template
2content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/bodyemphasis.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/bodyemphasis.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezstring.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezstring.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezobjectrelationlist.tplcontent/datatype/view/story_images.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/story_images.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/eztext.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/eztext.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezstring.tplcontent/datatype/view/image_credit.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/image_credit.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tplcontent/datatype/view/story_info_box.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/story_info_box.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezmatrix.tplcontent/datatype/view/ezmatrix_article_related_external_links.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/ezmatrix_article_related_external_links.tplEdit templateOverride template
1pagelayout.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/pagelayout.tplEdit templateOverride template
1modules/mugo_view_extras/extra_cached.tpl<No override>extension/mugo_view_extras/design/standard/templates/modules/mugo_view_extras/extra_cached.tplEdit templateOverride template
1setup/debug_toolbar.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/setup/debug_toolbar.tplEdit templateOverride template
 Number of times templates used: 59
 Number of unique templates used: 16
 Time used to render template usage: 0.0003 secs