The economics of gratitude
Market transactions only measure a portion of the true economy. Here are ways to extend our resources without additional spending.
Yes, our economy seems pretty dreadful. Unemployment is still too high. Housing sales are too low. Browsers still outnumber buyers at the mall.Skip to next paragraph
Credit card debt: Are consumers returning to bad habits?
New Year's resolution (and modern fable): Spend more!
In budget battle, voters are the 'adults in the room'
Is the curtain falling on the eurozone?
FedEx delivery video: Package thrown. FedEx apologizes on YouTube.
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
But the weakness in the measurable economy doesn't mean there aren't reasons to be grateful this holiday season. Market transactions measure only a part of our true economic capacity. We can be resourceful beyond what the numbers tell us.
For example: When incomes are lean and unreliable, as they are today, consumers tend to be more grateful for what they already have. Economists call this phenomenon "consumer surplus," which is the value placed on goods and services over and above the market prices paid for them. It's a particularly useful idea around the holidays when so many people lack the money to buy the gifts they want.
Cash income does not necessarily reflect how rich people are. They have far more resources that can be put to good use with a little creativity.
Take your own human capital. These are the talents and skills you possess that have value even if they are not all bought or sold in the traditional sense. When the marketplace won't hire you, those skills can still be put to good use – bartered or donated to produce nonmonetary benefits to both yourself and to others. You might call the benefit "satisfaction" or "thrill" from helping a charity or a loved one.
The same goes for goods. Most Americans have lots of underutilized goods right under their roof. Would they do more good donated to a toy or clothing drive?
Small businesses are rediscovering the benefits of bartering. Cash-strapped consumers can adapt that idea this holiday season. Instead of buying new items for those on your gift list, spend some time rediscovering the neglected treasures you already own. Recycle and renew the wealth you already have.
Even if you shun the idea of "regifting" to others, the holidays are a wonderful time to regift to oneself. For example, the list of items I'm regifting to myself this year includes: my fitness DVDs, those designer clothes I bought at bargain prices from eBay but still haven't worn, the books I haven't quite yet had the chance to read or would love to read again, and the sheet music I haven't yet learned to play on my piano.
Either way, regifting can transform something of no current value into something producing positive consumer surplus.
Depressed about our politicians' seeming inability to work together to improve our nation's economy? Think the only way to influence them is with money? Wrong.
Just as the "Occupiers" and tea partyers have discovered, there's tremendous potential power in using one's freedom of speech – whether it's attending rallies, writing letters to politicians or local newspapers, speaking up on social networks, or exercising the right to vote. These are all free ways each one of us can make a difference.
These ideas are not intended to minimize or gloss over the big economic difficulties facing many families. The United States must find a way to create more jobs and bring government spending under control. At the same time, we can recognize that our economic capacity is much bigger than it seems. The US economy can produce far more jobs, once confidence returns, and has the resources to plug any fiscal shortfalls, once we get politicians to cooperate.
In the meantime, if we look around and look within, we may find we're far "richer" than what the markets are currently telling us. That's something to be grateful for.
– Diane Lim Rogers is chief economist of the Concord Coalition, a nonpartisan group advocating fiscal responsibility.