Pushing a Tesla Motors Model S to the edge of its range
A Tesla Motors Model S owner tests the range of his electric car on a cool, hilly 168-mile drive.
(Page 2 of 3)
The first thing I noticed was that the regenerative braking virtually disappeared with the 100-percent charge. Charge rates in max regen can approach 40 kW, way too much for a nearly full battery.Skip to next paragraph
2011-2012 Dodge Charger recalled for overheating headlights
Autolib electric car-sharing service eyes London
Dodge Viper worth tens of thousands? Crush it, Chrysler orders.
Americans' mass transit use highest in decades
2015 Audi A3 will include in-car 4G connectivity for less than $17 per month
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
Going down a long, steep hill near my house, I actually had to use the brakes. Damn! Wasting precious energy already!
Fortunately, full regeneration came back quickly, within 10 miles.
I don't have a lot of faith in the Model S range meter. Its number is a projection based on rule-of-thumb efficiency assumptions, battery temperature, and a safety fudge factor. (New York Times reporter Jonathan Broder famously fell victim to wildly fluctuating range numbers.) I call it the guess-o-meter.
Instead, I monitor the dashboard readout of trip efficiency, measured in Watt-hours per mile. During my earlier shorter stints of highway driving, in warm weather, I'd averaged 290 to 300 Wh/mi.
I figured if I could maintain that level of efficiency, I'd make it to Danville with about 30 miles to spare. The Wh/mi reading thus became my prime focus for the trip.
For the open stretches of Interstate, I set the cruise control on 74 mph. (I figured no self-respecting cop would stop me for breaking the speed limit by single digits.
Forty miles out, along I-84, the e-meter settled in at around 310 Wh/mi. With the usual minor ups and downs for hills, the number crept steadily upward as I crossed into Pennsylvania. By the time I reached Wilkes-Barre--about halfway--it was reading 330.
At this rate I'd be totally out of energy at 182 miles. Way too close for comfort.
But I was pretty sure that the culprit was elevation. From previous trips, I'd learned that elevation changes have a huge effect on the range of the Model S.
For example, when I make the 60-mile drive from my house (elevation: 423 feet) to New York City (sea level), I typically average 270 Wh/mi in warm weather. The return trip, slightly uphill, averages about 310. A mere 400-foot elevation change over 60 miles alters efficiency by almost 15 percent.
I'd checked the elevation of Danville (578 feet) before I left, but hadn't paid attention to the intervening terrain. Hopefully, I'd soon begin descending.
Sure enough, as I passed Wilkes Barre, the e-meter began to come back down toward 320 kWh/mi, then 310. I breathed a sigh of relief; I had it in the bag.
(I later determined that I'd reached a peak elevation of about 1800 feet along I-84 just east of Wilkes-Barre.)
By the time I got to Danville, my energy usage had dropped to 295 wH/mi--right in the middle of my target zone.
The range meter read 24 miles when I finally arrived at a funky farmhouse. It was home to an affable banjo-picker named Mark Doncheski, two Corvettes, and a Tesla Roadster. Mark had agreed to make his Tesla charger available to Sherman and me.