Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Big squeeze for grads: Student loans rise, job opportunities dim

College grads have to pay back ever bigger student loans. But job opportunities are slim. Is US competitiveness at stake?

By Margaret PriceCorrespondent / October 5, 2011

Graduates of the University of Rochester convened on the school’s Eastman Quadrangle in Rochester, N.Y., in May. As the burden of student loans grows, the prospects of paying them off dim as job opportunities are scarce.

Melanie Stetson Freeman/Staff/File


New York

After losing a retail job in 2009, David Corgan of Coon Rapids, Minn., went to college to boost his job prospects. Now in his mid-30s, the third-year student at a local community college faces the prospect of $35,000 in student debt once he finishes up, he hopes, at the University of Minnesota.

Skip to next paragraph

"It's terrifying," says Mr. Corgan, who is majoring in astrophysics. "I know I can repay the debt. But whether it will improve my job prospects, that's hard to judge."

Granted, a job in astrophysics may be harder to land than, say, one in retail sales. Still, the squeeze Corgan is feeling is increasingly common among college students and graduates in many majors. On one side, the costs of tuition have been rising steadily, even as grant programs fail to keep pace with them. On the other side, job opportunities are scarce. Finding good-paying jobs to repay those student loans has become a tall order. As of July, 13 percent of college grads ages 20 to 24 were unemployed.

The squeeze could intensify if policymakers, now tackling the federal deficit, trim education subsidies beyond the cuts already made. Already, students' growing debt burden threatens their ability to spend as young adults and contribute to the economy. If high school grads forgo higher education because its costs appear to outweigh its advantages, the nation's long-term competitiveness will likely suffer.

"The situation is bad, really bad, and getting worse," says Rich Williams, higher education advocate at the U.S. Public Interest Research Group in Washington, D.C. "About 10 to 15 years ago, only about one-third of students needed to borrow money to graduate" from college, "and borrowers needed only about $12,000" on average, he says. Today, some two-thirds of college students need loans. Their average borrowing exceeds $27,000, says Mark Kantrowitz, publisher of and

Last year, student-loan debt surpassed US credit-card debt. By January, says Mr. Kantrowitz, it's expected to hit $1 trillion. To be sure, the default rate on federal student loans – at 8.8 percent in the 2009 fiscal year, according to the Department of Education – is still below double-digit levels. Also, a number of forbearance and debt repayment programs help former students manage loan repayments.

Debt loads are "troubling for some students, but for the vast majority of students they are not a problem," says Donald Heller, education professor at The Pennsylvania State University in University Park. "But if the economy doesn't improve in two to three years, student debt could become a much greater problem for the nation."

Annabel Pollioni, one of eight children of a financially struggling family, expects to graduate from Rutgers University in New Brunswick, N.J., with a political science degree and $34,000 of student debt (counting borrowing at a previous college). The college senior is planning for a career working for nonprofit organizations. This would lead to her goal – to run for US president – and help qualify her for federal student loan forgiveness.

Ms. Pollioni considers herself to be among the luckier students and believes her student debt will be manageable. But to her, the debt problem nationally is "out of control." For many such borrowers, repayment will be a long ordeal.


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story