Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Accounting sleuths on the trail of Madoff money

Teams of 'forensic accountants' get set to trace – and maybe recover – funds lost in $50 billion Ponzi scheme.

(Page 2 of 2)



Yormark used this approach in 1991 when, then at Kroll Inc., he was hired to trace the assets of John McNamara, who was involved in a Ponzi scheme involving General Motors Acceptance Corp. (GMAC). From 1980 to 1991, Mr. McNamara, a developer and car dealer, said he was buying new vans and other vehicles, modifying them, and shipping them overseas for sale. GMAC would fund the purchases of the vehicles.

Skip to next paragraph

However, there weren't any vehicles, although McNamara had told GMAC he was buying 40,000 vehicles per month. "He was their best customer," recalls Yormark.

By the time the scandal was revealed, GMAC was out $436 million.

In tracing the assets, Yormark found much had gone into purchasing real estate, plus a gold mine in Nevada. GMAC got some of its money back, but Yormark is not certain how much.

In some Ponzi schemes, however, investors have been fortunate to get a significant amount back. In the late 1990s, Credit Bancorp siphoned $200 million in marketable securities from several hundred investors in a Ponzi scheme. Those investors got back all but $25 million.

In the Credit Bancorp situation, the company persuaded executives to turn over restricted stock, or controlled stock – stock that has to be held years before it can be sold – in return for a dividend. Credit Bancorp used the stock instead to take out loans.

Carl Loewenson, a partner at the New York law firm Morrison & Foerster, hired the accounting firm KPMG to trace the assets and help with complicated tax issues.

"Some of the money we got through an insurance policy from Lloyds of London," says Mr. Loewenson, "and some of the securities were still there."

In the case of the Madoff scheme, accountants expect that sorting out the assets will be time-consuming.

"You will have to take each person's account and follow the money bit by bit," says Roger Nearmyer, president of the Forensic Accountants Society of North America, in Minneapolis. "People will have to prove the investment dollars they put in."

The accountants will also track money that Madoff sent to his investors. If any investors asked for the money because they became suspicious of Madoff's empire, the trustee running what's left of the Madoff empire can ask for the money back, says Loewenson.

"The critical question will be whether the customer acted in good faith," he says. "If you got nervous and said, 'I want my money back,' that is money that could be recovered by the trustee," he says. "But if you got worried, conducted due diligence, and everything turned up OK but you still asked for your money back, then you showed good faith and may be able to keep the distribution."

One thing is for certain: The investors will have to spend hours with forensic accountants and lawyers.

"We don't know everything yet," says Yormark. "And these cases always turn up odd things."

Permissions