Automakers' recovery plan: Get small.
Their CEOs visit Washington, trying a second time to win lawmaker approval for an auto industry bailout.
(Page 2 of 2)
Figures contained in GM's outline indicate the firm plans to reduce hourly and salaried employees from today's level of about 96,000 to between 65,000 and 75,000 by 2012.Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
Dealer locations will be slashed from 6,450 to 4,700 over the same period, according to the plan. Only four core brands will remain: Chevrolet, Cadillac, Buick, and GMC.
Ford plans workforce cuts, too
Ford, for its part, noted it has already announced plans to cut about 10 percent of its North American salaried workforce of 22,600. Overall cuts in operating costs for 2009 will reach $1 billion, Ford said.
Chrysler, a privately held firm, said it would produce its first full-function electric vehicle by 2010 and expects to pump out more than 500,000 such cars by 2013.
High-stakes congressional hearings Dec. 4 and 5 will examine the automakers' plans, as lawmakers decide what to do. Democratic leaders have voiced concern about the industry's plight but have made no commitments.
"It is my hope that we would" pass auto rescue legislation, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said late Tuesday.
Striking by its absence in the auto plans is a recognition of what Detroit's long-term problem really is – the appeal of the products, says Mr. Winston of the Brookings Institution in Washington.
The Big Three have lost market share because foreign firms have beat them with a ground game: products that offer better basic attributes, such as price, power, reliability, and styling, according to a paper in the International Economic Review co-authored by Winston.
Just offering more US-made hybrids won't save the industry, in Winston's view. Detroit has to make better hybrids – and those from Japan are already pretty good.
"Economics have nothing to do with this," he says.
How to get the union to go along?
The plans assert that Detroit will reach labor cost competitiveness with foreign competitors by 2012. But they don't say how they will get the United Auto Workers to accept the deep pay cuts needed to reach that goal, says Peter Morici, a University of Maryland economist and professor of business who appeared on a panel with the auto CEOs at last month's congressional hearings.
Even if GM can reduce its dealership numbers to 4,700 – a doubtful proposition – that's still too many, says Mr. Morici. Honda, for its part, has 1,300 US dealerships.
GM says it will focus on four brands, but the fine print in its plan says models will be reduced only from today's 48 nameplates to 40 by 2012.
"The GM plan is a fantasy," says Morici.
Still, both Morici and Winston predict that Washington will approve some kind of auto assistance. "I'll be amazed if they don't," says Winston.