Sacred spaces: Church buildings repurposed as community hubs
| St. Louis
As religious congregations dwindle, developers have jumped at the chance to transform church buildings into luxury condos, cafes, even a Dollar Tree.
But in some cities, residents are breathing new life into sacred spaces by giving fresh thought to what it means to serve, and who can constitute a congregation.
Why We Wrote This
As churches close across the U.S., is their role in bringing people together being lost as well? In three cities, communities are repurposing church buildings as a way of ministering to new “congregations.”
After closing last summer, St. Matthew’s Episcopal Church in Hallowell, Maine, offered the building to Capital Area New Mainers Project, which supports the growing number of refugees and other immigrants in the area.
The congregation chose CANMP because it “felt like we would be carrying on the mission,” says Chris Myers Asch, CANMP’s co-founder and executive director. “We take that responsibility very seriously. It’s hallowed ground.”
Mr. Myers Asch and his team of volunteers are currently renovating the sanctuary to create the Hallowell Multicultural Center. When it’s ready, anyone in the community will be able to host events that bring people of different backgrounds together.
“It’s a place,” he says, “where we can celebrate becoming America together, bringing the newest Americans into the fold.”
Victoria Stadnik glides on roller skates down one side of a wooden halfpipe decorated in neon spray paint. Light pours in through stained-glass windows, catching her body as she rotates through the air in the nave of what used to be St. Liborius Catholic Church.
After the church shut down in 1992, the building served briefly as a homeless shelter. Now, St. Liborius is better known as Sk8 Liborius – a skate park in use informally for a decade, with plans to open officially in three years.
St. Liborius is one of hundreds of churches across the United States beginning a second life. As congregations dwindle – only 47% of American adults reported membership in a religious organization in 2020, down from 70% in 1999 according to a Gallup poll – churches are closing doors and changing hands. Developers have jumped at the chance to transform the consecrated spaces into luxury condos, cafes, mansions – even a Dollar Tree.
Why We Wrote This
As churches close across the U.S., is their role in bringing people together being lost as well? In three cities, communities are repurposing church buildings as a way of ministering to new “congregations.”
For some, the trend brings with it a sense of dismay.
“Congregations are the major community hubs,” says Ram Cnaan, director of the Program for Religion and Social Policy Research at the University of Pennsylvania. “And I’m talking as a person who is not spiritual, who does not believe in any God, just as a social scientist. Those congregations are the fabric of our society.”
But in some cities, residents are breathing new life into sacred spaces by giving fresh thought to what it means to serve, and who can constitute a congregation. Groups in St. Louis, Philadelphia, and Hallowell, Maine, are finding that one fundamental purpose of church – community uplift – can take many forms.
“These places are very powerful links to the history and the evolution of our neighborhoods,” says Bob Jaeger, president of Partners for Sacred Places, based in Philadelphia. Even though a church “may need repair, even though it may be empty, ... it’s a bundle of assets. It’s a bundle of opportunities.”
For Ms. Stadnik, the skate church offers more than an adrenaline rush.
“It’s hard to make friends as an adult,” says Ms. Stadnik, who moved to St. Louis with few connections, as she catches her breath from her halfpipe run. But at Sk8 Liborius, “it feels like I unlocked the secret.”
Falling, then getting up
When Dave Blum, co-owner of Sk8 Liborius, speaks about his plans for the church, his voice echoes out across the sanctuary, ringing with the hope and certainty of a sermon. His team is creating not only a skate park but also an urban art studio where local artists can display and sell their work and children can learn skills ranging from metalworking to photography.
In every empty nook and cranny, he sees the potential to support a new congregation: underserved urban youth. He hopes skateboarding will get kids in the door – where vital lessons await.
Skating is about learning how to get up when you fall, both physically and mentally, says Joss Hay, another co-owner. If your friends fall, “You don’t tell them to give up. You’re always lifting them up.”
The church was completed in 1889, and after years of neglect, it has a long way to go before it can pass an inspection and be formally opened to the public. Emergency exits, bathrooms, window repair, plumbing, electricity, and heat are just a few of the items on a to-do list of fixes estimated at $1 million. But donations are pouring in from supporters, and local skaters like Ms. Stadnik, who also works as a skating coach, spend weekends helping with repair work.
“A whole community came together to build these structures because it was important to them. And now, what we’re trying to do is have a whole community come together to maintain this structure,” says Mr. Blum.
“Becoming America together”
Welcoming newcomers into the fold is another function churches often fulfill. In Maine, a local nonprofit is continuing that mission by turning a former holy space into a home and community center.
Ali Al Braihi and Mohammed Abdalnabi came to the U.S. as refugees because war – in Iraq for the first and Syria for the second – made staying home impossible. Their journeys were different, but their families both ended up in Hallowell, Maine. Housing was limited, says Mr. Abdalnabi, and squeezing all nine members of his family into a two-bedroom apartment was “rough.” Mr. Al Braihi had the same difficulty.
Now, the 18 people that make up both families live in what used to be St. Matthew’s Episcopal Church, a classic white, wooden structure in Hallowell’s small downtown.
“What I feel is fortunate and thankful,” says Mr. Al Braihi, now a college student. His family is Muslim, but he says he appreciates the sacredness of his new home and is just happy to finally have enough space to study.
After closing last summer, St. Matthew’s offered the building to Capital Area New Mainers Project (CANMP), which supports the growing number of refugees and other immigrants in the area.
The congregation chose CANMP because it “felt like we would be carrying on the mission,” says Chris Myers Asch, CANMP’s co-founder and executive director. “We take that responsibility very seriously. It’s hallowed ground.”
Mr. Myers Asch and his team of volunteers are currently renovating the sanctuary to create the Hallowell Multicultural Center. When it’s ready, anyone in the community will be able to host events: dinners, talks, movie screenings, weddings – whatever brings people of different backgrounds together.
“We see it as a wonderful space to bring cultures together, to learn from each other, to share stories with each other, to share food, break bread, and really build community,” says Mr. Myers Asch. It’s a place, he says, “where we can celebrate becoming America together, bringing the newest Americans into the fold.”
“A labor of love”
Further down the East Coast, in a church turned recreation center, there’s a different type of culture unifying the community – sports.
When Coach Curt De Veaux discovered that Our Lady of Hope, a Catholic church in a low-income neighborhood of Philadelphia, had sat vacant for 15 years, his wheels started turning.
After nine years as a basketball coach, he understood the power of sports to transform individuals. So he partnered with a local organization to purchase the space and began renovations to turn the church into a youth recreation center.
“A lot of kids in the area don’t have an outlet, or things to do,” he says.
City Athletics Philadelphia now offers basketball, volleyball, indoor soccer, lacrosse, spinning bikes, and other types of training at low to no cost to neighborhood youth.
“There are just so many life lessons that you can help a young person navigate,” says Mr. De Veaux. “I always tell the parents, ‘It looks like sports, but it’s really life,’ whether it’s emotional control or learning how to work with others, how to respect rules, how to compete, or practice makes perfect.”
At the end of the day, Mr. De Veaux’s goal is for the church to continue to be a gift to the neighborhood. Beyond his work at the youth center, he has also organized drives for coats, school uniforms, and sports-related toys.
“Every time I go there, I come in with a list of things I need to get done, and I come out and my list is always longer than when I went in,” adds Mr. De Veaux, who says it’s taken plenty of resources, energy, and anguish to stop roof leaks, wrangle the heating system, and bring the church up to standards.
“But it really is a labor of love.”
