Why Mitt Romney is likely to get to Republican Party convention a winner

Rick Santorum needs to pull an upset in Illinois – an unlikely prospect given latest polls – and win in other winner-take-all primaries to push Mitt Romney to a brokered Republican Party convention.

Steven Senne/AP
Republican presidential candidate, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney speaks at Charlie Parker's Diner in Springfield, Ill., Monday.

What's Rick Santorum's best chance at the presidential nomination? Having the process drag on until the Republican Party's national convention in Tampa, Fla., in August.

Even Mr. Santorum acknowledges that it's nearly impossible for him to amass enough delegates on his own to get the nomination. He just hopes to be able to keep Mitt Romney from hitting that number – 1,144 – as well.

“If the other people stay in the race, it's going to be hard for anyone to get to that magic number," Mr. Santorum said on CBS's "This Morning" on Monday. "We believe we get to the convention, the convention will nominate a conservative. The convention will not nominate an establishment moderate from Massachusetts."

If he (along with Newt Gingrich and Ron Paul) can perform just well enough to keep Mitt Romney from sewing up the nomination, Santorum suggests, then the party establishment could vote to go with him.

How likely is that?

The short answer: not very.

Despite the fact that the media and political pundits have been salivating about the idea of a brokered convention for several months, it remains a highly unlikely scenario.

At this point, Mr. Romney has – barely – a majority of the nominees in play. According to the Associated Press count (which includes the preferences of superdelegates who can support whomever they choose), Romney currently has 521 delegates, Santorum has 253, Mr. Gingrich has 136, and Mr. Paul has 50. That puts Romney at about 54 percent of the current total.

Many of the upcoming state contests – especially the few that are at least in part winner-take-all states like New Jersey and California – seem to favor Romney.

Gingrich's momentum also seems to have stalled, and Santorum alone – especially given the relatively small portion of delegates he currently has – seems unlikely to be able to keep Romney from getting to the magic number.

While Santorum at one time seemed to have a chance at taking Illinois on Tuesday, that possibility now seems distant, as Romney has moved well ahead in polls there. And Romney would likely need to lose in Illinois and other key states for a brokered convention to become a reality.

In a blog Monday, New York Times polling expert Nate Silver posted his predictions for Illinois – and why it makes any hope of Santorum blocking Romney's nomination unlikely:

"Say that Mr. Romney wins the 16th Congressional District, which includes some areas on the far outskirts of the Chicago metro area, but Mr. Romney holds the other four," Mr. Silver wrote. "That would make the delegate count for the night Romney 40, Santorum 14, and put Mr. Romney ahead by almost 300 delegates – 561 to 267 – in the national total.

"That isn’t a close race, nor is it one that it is likely to require a brokered convention to resolve. If that is the count after Illinois votes, Mr. Romney would require only 46 percent of the remaining delegates to clinch a majority (he was won about 55 percent so far), and only 39 percent to clinch a plurality."

Brokered conventions are predicted fairly often, but seldom come to pass.

The last one was in 1952, when Democrats chose Adlai Stevenson as their candidate on the third ballot. In 1976, the GOP nominating process did go all the way to the convention – President Ford had a lead going into the convention but hadn't yet secured the nomination – but Ford managed to get the support he needed to win the nomination on the first ballot.

The New York Times reported over the weekend that the GOP is girding for the possibility of a brokered convention this year. It quoted Robert Duncan, a former Republican national chairman who presides over the council that hears disputes over delegates, as saying that "It's more likely than anything since '76."

But Mr. Duncan also said he doesn't really believe that it will happen, because momentum "is going to certainly push Romney – or somebody else – to the forefront."

On Sunday, the head of the Republican National Committee, Reince Priebus, denied The New York Times report, telling CBS's "Face the Nation" that "we're not making plans for a brokered convention."

If Santorum pulls a major upset and wins Illinois on Tuesday, expect talk of a brokered convention to increase.

But otherwise, it's likely that Santorum and others who don't want Romney will keep talking about it, but that Romney will eventually reach 1,144 – even though it may take him until June to get there.

of stories this month > Get unlimited stories
You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Unlimited digital access $11/month.

Get unlimited Monitor journalism.