Reader recommendation: Redeployment

Monitor readers share their favorite book picks.


If you have not fought in Iraq, nothing will ever allow you to know what it was like – but Redeployment by Phil Klay will get you agonizingly close.  His short stories show the unbridgeable gulf between those who’ve been there, and those who haven’t.  One wonders – will it ever be possible for a veteran who has been redeployed two or three or more times to relate to a civilian... or the reverse. The veterans in his brief chapters often lie, apparently thinking:  “Why bother to tell it as it was;  they’ll never never understand.” In "Fire in the Furnace," an outstanding vignette (but they all are)  a priest sees on a soldier’s face “the space where rage ends and violence begins.” The priest is trapped in a Catch-22 of morality ... and listens to soldiers who wonder if he and they will be forgiven – and by whom. This is a brilliant evocation of war and leaves you wondering if  we will be forgiven for entering into it.


We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.