NFL head-butting all about millionaires vs. billionaires

National Football League players and team owners opted to keep talking, despite the expiration of the current contract. But in the $9 billion sport, the biggest stumbling block remains money.

Evan Vucci/AP
National Football League Players Association Executive Director DeMaurice Smith speaks during a news conference about labor talks, Friday in Washington. Players and team owners opted to keep talking, despite the expiration of the current contract.

So far, no NFL player lock-out.

For pro-football fans, that's perhaps the most encouraging thing that can be said as the National Football League owners and players continue for another week their testy talks over money, schedules, and benefits for retired players.

Both sides opted on Friday to keep talks going, despite the expiration on Thursday of the current contract between players and team owners.

The biggest stumbling block remains money in a sport that pulls in some $9 billion in revenue a year.

Many team owners feel they gave away the store in a 2006 agreement in which they get $1 billion off the top, then split the remaining $8 billion 60-40, with players getting the 60 percent.

Then the economic crisis hit, which owners say cut into revenue and actually sliced roughly $20 million from the average value of an NFL team. Now, owners want $2 billion off the top, while retaining the 60-40 split – in essence cutting player salaries.

At the same time, however, owners want to extend the regular season by two games, something players who already endure a bruising 16-game regular season balk at unless it comes with more, not less money. Money aside, players-union representatives also note the irony in adding more games while the league has been expressing greater concern over player injuries.

For many recession-weary Americans, the tug of war over cash may seem little more than a distant spat between millionaire players and billionaire owners.

In a frosty, you've-got-to-be-kidding-me blog post, ESPN sports commentator Rick Reilly points out that half of the owners have a combined net worth of $40 billion, more than the majority of countries on the planet are worth.

"Yes, many of the players are diamond-coated knuckleheads," he writes. On the other hand, he writes, "Paul Allen, owner of the Seattle Seahawks, has a 414-foot yacht called ‘The Octopus’ with two helicopters, two submarines, a swimming pool, a music studio and a basketball court. He also has two backup emergency yachts."

For many observers, the event that may have done the most to prompt the one-week extension to the negotiations in hope of reaching a new contract agreement was last Tuesday's decision by a US District Court judge in Minneapolis. In effect, that voided as illegal a deal between the league and TV networks that would have provided the league with $4 billion in TV revenue even if a lock-out meant no games to televise during the 2011 season.

The deal would have provided income for team owners in the absence of games.

If a lock out occurs, the players say they are ready to dissolve the players' union, a move that would allow them to sue the league under anti-trust laws. Lining up as quarterbacks for the plaintiffs in any action, according to Yahoo sports columnist Dan Weztel: Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, and Drew Brees.

Following Friday's announcement of the negotiating extension, the league's lead negotiator, Jeff Pash, told reporters that bridging the gaps between the two sides remains "a challenge."

"We've got very serious issues. We've got significant differences," he said.

But league commissioner Roger Goodell said he saw hopeful signs in the extension.

"The fact that we're continuing this dialogue is a positive sign," he said. "Talking is better than litigating."

of stories this month > Get unlimited stories
You've read  of 5 free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Only $1 for your first month.

Get unlimited Monitor journalism.