Rewards cards aren't always worth the trouble

Personal finance Q&A with Steve Dinnen

Q: I'm being offered a new credit card by the bank that has my home mortgage account. It's a home-rebate credit card with 1 percent of purchases applied to the principal of my mortgage. Do you think it's worth having? How will a new card affect my credit score?

M.W., via e-mail

A: This offer from your lender leaves New York-based certified financial planner Erika Safran distinctly underwhelmed.

"I should spend $1,000 to reduce the principal on my mortgage by $10? So what?" she says. "I would have to spend $100,000 in one year to reduce it by $1,000."

So while it may sound like a nice feature, Ms. Safran places little value in it.

She is not averse to credit cards that offer bonuses, mind you. But she would just prefer one that was a little richer with its rewards.

A word of caution from her on picking up new credit cards: They'll increase the amount of credit available to you, potentially reducing your credit score.

Submit your question to Steve Dinnen at

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.