Abu Ghraib abuse: degrees of outrage

Regarding your May 3 article "To Arabs, photos confirm brutal US": It's understandable that Iraqis and the rest of the world should feel a sense of revulsion at pictures of prisoners being abused. One wishes they had expressed a similar sense of outrage at the burning of the corpses of the American contractors not too long ago, the cold-blooded execution of an Italian prisoner, or the videotaping of reporter Daniel Pearl's beheading. Instead, the best they could muster was an attitude of defiance or jubilant cheering in the streets of Baghdad. What a fickle bunch they are, indeed.
Miguel A. Guanipa
Whitinsville, Mass.

I propose that such reprehensible behavior is not surprising. Teaching, learning, and worst of all, practicing the killing of fellow human beings is in itself dehumanizing. It is noted in the article that, without broad surveillance, such violence will continue, "be it Iraqis against Americans or, in this horrifying instance, Americans against Iraqis." Intentional killing, for any reason, cannot promote intended good or lasting peace.

Though I have never been present in a war zone, I have been afforded too many opportunities to ponder what such an experience must entail. I firmly believe that such an experience has the potential of turning even the best of us into the worst perpetrator of abhorrent behavior. It would take great spiritual and moral stamina to prevent such occurrences in the midst of warfare. In order to repair our image in the Middle East, as the article correctly points out, we need a fairer policy that would promote and bring about lasting peace.
Susan G. Lapointe
Lexington, Mass.

Abu Ghraib is no My Lai

Regarding your May 3 editorial "Sadistic Abuse of Iraqi Inmates:" Your comparison of the terribly unfortunate but now vastly over-reported incidents involving a few American military police and Iraqi prisoners with the 1968 My Lai massacre only exposes your consistent political bias. These two situations are in no way similar. The huge majority of US soldiers are done a great disservice by media fixation with atypical incidents.
Jamae Wolfram van Eck
San Marino, Calif.

Offending the old and new Europe

Your April 30 article "Two worlds meet in the expanded EU" managed to be offensive to everyone in Europe, the old EU as well as its new members in one sentence: "The new members are twice as poor as the old." No one likes to be called poor, and you have blithely applied that label to some of the countries that have long been among the top economies in the world. It would have been better to use the perhaps slightly longer but accurate wording, "The new members have only half the income per capita [or whatever] of the old." The Monitor must do better.
Mary Woolf
Chevy Chase, Md.

Bias staining journalism's reputation

Regarding John Hughes's April 28 Opinion piece "A newsroom detour on path to truth": What you're missing is the real scandal in American journalism, which is the bias that slips through journalists' stories.

From the editor who decides what subjects to cover to the journalist who writes those stories, the underlying political leanings of those people are revealed. It's been reported that most American journalists identify themselves as Democrats. This is the scandal. This is what has given rise to the alternative sources of news - from Internet sources to talk radio. The nation's traditional news sources have morphed into propaganda machines for the left. That's the indelible stain on journalism's reputation, not Jayson Blair.
Bill Reilly
Bay Village, Ohio

The Monitor welcomes your letters and opinion articles. Because of the volume of mail we receive, we can neither acknowledge nor return unpublished submissions. All submissions are subject to editing. Letters must be signed and include your mailing address and telephone number.

Any letter accepted will appear in print and on www.csmonitor.com .

Mail letters to 'Readers Write,' and opinion articles to Opinion Page, One Norway St., Boston, MA 02115, or fax to 617-450-2317, or e-mail to Letters.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
QR Code to Letters
Read this article in
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today