2022
December
22
Thursday

Monitor Daily Podcast

December 22, 2022
Loading the player...

TODAY’S INTRO

What is progress, anyway?

The notion of progress can be fraught. Whose progress? Whose ideals? Whose metrics?

In the West, progress has long been inextricably intertwined with economic and technological growth. In the postwar period, economists like Walt Whitman Rostow envisioned progress as a linear path toward modernization. Wealthy nations had arrived. Poor nations could follow in their footsteps with the right economic policy and machinery. Yet that kind of progress has trapped humanity in a seeming paradox: unprecedented wealth and technological capacity paired with deepening inequality and environmental degradation.

The technocratic view of progress has earned its share of critics. Post-development scholars began insisting in the 1980s that “developed” societies offer no model to follow, given the damage done by overconsumption. They decried society’s obsession with economic and technological advancement, which tended to silence other cultural ways of thinking about progress.

As the Monitor’s Points of Progress writer, I’ve thought a lot about the meaning of progress. First, I learned what progress is not. It’s not a one-size-fits-all model. It’s not a tool to get others to do things your way. It’s not a race with any particular destination at all. Instead, progress is incremental. It’s messy and imperfect. And it can feel painfully slow and incomplete.

While 25,000 unhoused individuals moved into homes in Houston this year, for instance, another 500,000 Americans remained on the streets or in shelters. But that step forward transformed lives. And how the city made it happen can be instructive.

At the Monitor, we take a somewhat unfashionable stance on progress. The idea is this: Some values are so innate to human nature, they are universal. Progress occurs as these values unfold around the globe. Values like ingenuity, dignity, and cooperation are not ideological, nor do they prescribe a particular political solution. Looking back at 2022, I found these and other values paving the way for solutions to emerge, fine-tuned to the needs of the place.

Economic and technological advancements do matter. But maybe these are better seen as the result, rather than the source, of progress. The good news is that we can all tend and nurture the values that bring our humanity to light. That drives real progress.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Letter from the Capitol

In Congress, Zelenskyy champions freedom from tyranny

The unlikely wartime leader, the first to speak to Congress since Winston Churchill, celebrated the West’s victory in winning global hearts. He added that Russian freedom would start by defeating “the Kremlin in their minds.”

Jacquelyn Martin/AP
Vice President Kamala Harris (left) and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi hold the Ukrainian flag flown on the front lines that was presented to them by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy after he addressed a joint meeting of Congress in Washington, Dec. 21, 2022.
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 5 Min. )

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, dressed in his signature olive fatigues, strode into the U.S. House of Representatives last night to a standing ovation that lasted a full four minutes.

“I hope my words of respect and gratitude resonate in each American heart,” he finally began, celebrating Ukraine’s triumph over the odds, thanks to U.S. and global support. “We defeated Russia in the battle for minds in the world.”

Mr. Zelenskyy asked Congress, which is weighing another $47 billion in aid to Ukraine, to use its authority to “save millions” of people. But he also underscored that as much as military equipment is crucial to winning a war on the ground, the most important battlefield is in hearts and minds. His case was simple, yet profound: Your commitment to ideals drove your seminal victories, which inspires our own war of independence. But this is your fight, too. This is a battle to preserve the values you hold dear – not only for us, or for you, but for the whole world, including Russians.

“Russians will stand a chance to be free only when they defeat the Kremlin in their minds,” said Mr. Zelenskyy.

In Congress, Zelenskyy champions freedom from tyranny

Collapse

At a time when so many see American democracy imperiled by division and discord, members of Congress came together last night to champion a man fresh off the front lines of a more raw fight for democracy.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, dressed in his signature olive fatigues, strode into the chamber to a standing ovation, took the podium, and then shuffled uncomfortably as the crowd whooped and cheered for a full four minutes. 

“Thank you, it’s too much for me,” Mr. Zelenskyy said, when the applause finally waned. “All this for our great people, thanks so much.”

“I hope my words of respect and gratitude resonate in each American heart,” he began. “It’s a great honor for me to be at the U.S. Congress and speak to you and all Americans. Against all odds, and doom and gloom scenarios, Ukraine didn’t fall. Ukraine is alive and kicking.”

Another standing ovation.

“And,” he continued, his right pointer finger tracing the words on the page of his prepared speech, as he emphasized each one in heavily accented English, “it gives me good reason to share with you our first joint victory: We defeated Russia in the battle for minds in the world,” he said. “We have no fear, nor should anyone in the world have it.”

His case was simple, yet profound: As much as military equipment is crucial to winning a war on the ground, the most important battlefield is in hearts and minds. You, America, know this. Your commitment to ideals drove your seminal victories, such as in the Battle of Saratoga during the Revolutionary War, or the Battle of the Bulge against Nazi troops in 1944. Your history is an inspiration as we fight our own war of independence. But this is your fight, too. This is a battle to preserve the values you hold dear – not only for us, or for you, but for the whole world. 

“The Russian tyranny has lost control over us, and it will never influence our minds again. Yet, we have to do whatever it takes to ensure that countries of the global South also gain such victory,” Mr. Zelenskyy said, going on to include those living under the thumb of his adversary, Russian President Vladimir Putin, as well. “Russians will stand a chance to be free only when they defeat the Kremlin in their minds.”

Evelyn Hockstein/Reuters
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy received a four-minute standing ovation before his speech to the joint session of Congress. He was the first wartime leader to address a joint session since British Prime Minister Winston Churchill in 1941.

Congress weighing another $47 billion in aid

“Just like the brave American soldiers, which held their lines and fought back Hitler’s forces during the Christmas of 1944, brave Ukrainian soldiers are doing this same to Putin’s forces this Christmas,” he said. “Ukraine holds its lines and will never surrender.”

The crowd whooped again. There’s just something about this guy in a sweatshirt leading a country with less than 1% of American gross domestic product – a former comedian turned overnight global hero – that fires up people like Rep. Rosa DeLauro, a petite Connecticut Democrat who was shouting and shaking her head of purple hair. 

Then came the pitch.

“Your support is crucial not just to stand in such fight, but to get to the turning point, to win on the battlefield,” Mr. Zelenskyy said. “We have artillery, yes – thank you,” with a big nod. “We have it – is it enough? Honestly, not really.”

The timing of the trip, arranged by President Joe Biden and facilitated by a U.S. Air Force ride out of neighboring Poland, is not coincidental. Mr. Biden announced the United States would be sending Patriot missiles to Ukraine. And Congress is weighing a $47 billion aid package this week that has met with some resistance from Republicans. Prominent GOP critics either didn’t attend the speech, or conspicuously remained seated during the numerous standing ovations. GOP Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, the front-runner to become speaker of the House next month, applauded halfheartedly, yawned, and was always among the first to sit down. 

“Financial assistance is critically important, and I would like to thank you, thank you very much, thank you for both financial packages you have already provided us with and the ones you may be willing to decide on,” the Ukrainian president said. “Your money is not charity. It’s an investment in the global security and democracy that we handle in the most responsible way.”

Retiring GOP Sen. Rob Portman of Ohio, who has visited Mr. Zelenskyy more than any other member of Congress, said afterward that he struck a good balance between gratitude and the case for continued support.

“He expressed the appreciation, but also made it clear that now’s not the time to pull back,” said Senator Portman. “The territorial integrity of Ukraine is important to Ukraine, but also to the global world order that would otherwise be destroyed.”

J. Scott Applewhite/AP
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy holds an American flag, which flew above the Capitol on the day of his visit, gifted to him by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi after he addressed a joint session of Congress, Dec. 21, 2022.

Flying the flag for freedom

Fresh off a visit to the front lines in eastern Ukraine on Tuesday, Mr. Zelenskyy presented a flag to Speaker Nancy Pelosi from the “heroes” defending Ukraine’s borders.  

“This flag is a symbol of our victory in this war,” he said. “We stand, we fight, and we will win because we are united: Ukraine, America, and the entire free world.”

Speaker Pelosi then presented him with an American flag flown atop the Capitol that day in his honor. 

He leaned across the dais to kiss her cheek – then dashed out of the chamber like a man who had a war to lead. 

“It was just as remarkable a speech as I’ve ever heard in the Congress of the United States,” said Speaker Pelosi afterward, walking past historic figures in Statuary Hall on her way back to her office. 

“I take great pride in saying that my father was in Congress when Churchill came here and ... asked for help to fight tyranny in Europe” in 1941, after the Pearl Harbor attack, she added. “And now, 81 years later, I had the privilege of being in the house to hear another courageous leader ask for help.”

Mr. Zelenskyy would welcome America’s support, he made clear. But he also underscored that Ukrainian determination was not contingent on foreign assistance, nor would it be thwarted by foreign aggression. 

“We’ll celebrate Christmas,” he vowed, in the bomb shelters or the dark, if necessary. “And even if there is no electricity, the light of our faith in ourselves will not be put out.”

UK’s National Health Service is beloved. And now, it’s fraying.

The British people rely upon the National Health Service like no other institution. With the NHS “on the brink of collapse,” the country is fretting over the future of its long-trusted safety net.

Alastair Grant/AP
Demonstrators show support for a strike by nurses outside St Thomas' Hospital in London, Dec. 20, 2022. Nurses staged a walkout of hospitals amid a growing crisis across the National Health Service, as staffing and management issues impede the institution's ability to provide health care.
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 6 Min. )

The National Health Service is the United Kingdom’s pride and joy, more beloved by the public than any other British institution because of the safety and security it provides to all without precondition.

But it is facing a crisis like never before. The health care system is being pushed beyond its capacity, creating record delays in emergency services and raising the number of excess deaths nationally to higher than it was during the pandemic.

At the same time, NHS doctors, nurses, and front-line workers feel so overworked, underpaid, and undervalued by the government that pays them that they are taking to the picket lines in ways never before seen in Britain.

“Over the last 10 years in this country, we’ve not tried to grow our workforce at the rate we needed to and we’ve not invested in the basic facilities you need for modern health care,” says Siva Anandaciva, chief analyst at charitable organization The King’s Fund. “As a result, you’ve basically got a system that hasn’t got enough resilience to cope with shocks. When you get multiple shocks, it’s no wonder that waiting times and patient care are at the poor level they’re at now.”

UK’s National Health Service is beloved. And now, it’s fraying.

Collapse

They call in at all hours of the day and night. The man who said he wouldn’t be able to play with his children if it hadn’t been for an operation. The woman who’s thankful for a front-line worker who offered aid and support amid a family crisis. A 10-year-old who underwent surgery after the pandemic.

This is Hopeline19, a free phone line, which began as a way for the grateful British public to leave messages of support for Britain’s National Health Service (NHS) workers. Within days of its launch in September 2021, some 17,000 people had called in to the service. Today, 18 months later, 6,000 people still call in each week.

“I don’t know if you’re hearing this on your 10-minute break, or the only break you’ve had from a 12-hour shift, but I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart,” said one caller.

The NHS is the country’s pride and joy, more beloved by the public than any other British institution, including the royal family, the armed forces, and the BBC, because of the safety and security it provides to all without precondition. But it is facing a crisis like never before – with trust waning in its ability to support both its workers and the public effectively. The health care system is being pushed beyond its capacity, creating record delays in emergency services and raising the number of excess deaths nationally to higher than it was during the pandemic.

At the same time, NHS doctors, nurses, and front-line workers feel so overworked, underpaid, and undervalued by the government that pays them that they are taking to the picket lines in ways never before seen in Britain. As they do, they are receiving the support of a public that wants to protect those who provide such a critical social safety net.

This has drawn new attention to a fact that Chancellor Jeremy Hunt acknowledged last month: “The NHS is on the brink of collapse ... with doctors, nurses on the front line frankly under unbearable pressure,” he said.

“The NHS,” says Alastair McLellan, editor of Health Service Journal, “has reached the point where it can no longer save your life.”

Britain’s favorite public institution

The NHS came into existence on July 5, 1948. It was the first universal health care system to be financed by taxes, and is “free at the point of delivery,” meaning that treatment is provided according to need, not by a person’s ability to pay. The service has outlasted two monarchs, 15 prime ministers, and 29 health secretaries.

Kin Cheung/AP
Britain's Chancellor Jeremy Hunt leaves 11 Downing St., Nov. 17, 2022. Mr. Hunt acknowledged last month that “the NHS is on the brink of collapse ... with doctors, nurses on the front line frankly under unbearable pressure.”

But spending on health care has faltered in Britain over the last decade. The United Kingdom invests around 0.3% of gross domestic product on health care capital spending, less than any other country in the G-7. This is now reflected in the worsening health of British people, which is holding back economic growth for the first time since the Industrial Revolution, former Bank of England chief economist Andy Haldane said in a recent speech.

Today, the NHS situation is stark. A record 7.21 million people were waiting for treatment in England at the end of October. Around 4,000 patients a day are spending more than 12 hours in emergency departments, a record high that far exceeds the target of four hours. Most alarmingly, figures from the Office of National Statistics show that, on average, the number of excess deaths is currently higher than it was during the pandemic, with a quarter of those attributed to the disruption of emergency care.

There are two key problems, says Mr. McLellan, and one of them has nothing to do with treatment. Rather, it’s logistical.

Patients are getting stuck in emergency departments (called “accident and emergency,” or A&E, in the U.K.) rather than being transferred to hospital beds because wards are occupied by people medically fit enough to leave, but who cannot be discharged because they lack the necessary care at home. As much as a third of beds in some institutions are occupied by people in this situation.

“If you can’t get people out of hospital, then you can’t get people out of A&E,” says Mr. McLellan. “If you can’t get people out of A&E, you can’t get them out of the ambulance queuing outside A&E. And if an ambulance is queuing outside A&E, it’s not responding to life-threatening calls.”

The second, extremely urgent, problem is staff shortages, exacerbated by the departure, post-Brexit, of thousands of foreign-born health professionals, including 4,000 European doctors.

Many of the remaining hospital staffers have taken to skipping breaks and working overtime for free, so as to maintain care standards, and selling annual leave to make ends meet, or resorting to food banks.

Such stress has taken its toll: In the year leading up to last June, 1 in 9 nurses quit the NHS, and a Royal College of Nursing (RCN) survey found that 6 in 10 were contemplating or planning their resignations. Already, more than 30,000 nursing positions remain unfilled.

At a time when the country is still feeling the impacts of COVID-19, and suffering a cost-of-living crisis, a recession, and an energy crisis, the NHS is under more pressure than at any other time in its history, says Siva Anandaciva, chief analyst at The King’s Fund, a charitable organization that works to improve health and care in England.

Steve Parsons/PA/AP/File
Military co-responder Lt. Corydon Morrell steps out of an ambulance at Bracknell Ambulance Station in Bracknell, England, Jan. 12, 2022. Military personnel have been called in to make up shortfalls in NHS staffing during the current crisis.

“We’ve run our system on what I’d say is the red zone on the dial for a long, long time,” he says. “Over the last 10 years in this country, we’ve not tried to grow our workforce at the rate we needed to and we’ve not invested in the basic facilities you need for modern health care.”

“As a result, you’ve basically got a system that hasn’t got enough resilience to cope with shocks. When you get multiple shocks, it’s no wonder that waiting times and patient care are at the poor level they’re at now.”

Pushing back against the government

For the first time in its 106-year history, the RCN called a strike this month, demanding a pay rise. Nurses walked out for two days, and strikes will continue into the spring if they fail to reach an agreement. The action was supported by 59% of Britons, a recent poll found.

“Anger has become action, our members are saying enough is enough,” RCN General Secretary Pat Cullen said in a statement. “Our members will no longer tolerate a financial knife-edge at home and a raw deal at work.”

Ambulance workers also struck for 24 hours on Wednesday.

While the strikes primarily have to do with pay, front-line workers also cite underfunding and staff shortages that they say create working conditions that leave them with no choice but to strike. A recent survey by the GMB trade union found that 1 in 3 ambulance staffers had been involved in a delay that had resulted in a patient’s death.

“We’ve got higher levels of PTSD in our nursing staff than recent returns from combat zones,” says Claire Goodwin-Fee, founder and CEO of Frontline19, a service that set up Hopeline19 and provides psychological support to front-line workers.

Regardless of how things stand at the moment, Britons are near-unanimous in their desire to see the NHS survive and – eventually – thrive.

“Generally speaking, the public on the street are huge fans of the NHS and supporters of health workers, which we saw during the pandemic,” says Ms. Goodwin-Fee. “I’ve never come across anybody who wants to get rid of it.”

2022: A space-comic odyssey

Asteroid dust. Pulsating auroras. An astral slide deck. This past year brought a flurry of scientific advancement in space exploration. Each development opens a new window into the mysteries of the universe.

In 2022, Earth dwellers passed milestone after milestone in space exploration in a flurry of scientific activity that has felt, to many, like a rekindling of the Apollo era.

We launched an exploratory rocket straight into the green clouds of pulsating auroras, sent a mission to the moon for the first time since 1972, and retrieved stunning images from the James Webb Space Telescope.

It may seem hard to imagine that we can mine the secrets of this vast universe. But with every new eye trained on the sky, we come closer.

Jules Struck/Contributor

Points of Progress

What's going right

The values that led humanity forward this year

In 2022, we chronicled 233 moments of progress around the world. In each case, values pointing to a global, shared humanity cleared the way for the right solution to take shape. We take a look at five of the values that drove much of the progress we saw.

The values that led humanity forward this year

Collapse

Ingenuity

Much of 2022’s progress was propelled by inventive efforts to find solutions or make discoveries. Sometimes these inventions began with one small idea.

An entrepreneur from Ivory Coast noticed that his parents, who don’t read, couldn’t use smartphones – so he designed one himself. In Rwanda, “smart canes” expanded mobility for those with visual impairments, just as all-terrain wheelchairs gained ground in U.S. parks. One resident of a Kenyan refugee settlement helps provide internet access to hundreds of others using solar panels. And an engineer in Canada began building furniture from recycled chopsticks.

In other cases, new ideas took years of collaboration. In a first for ocean energy, a wave energy converter completed a successful first year off the coast of Australia’s King Island. Turkey opened Europe’s first carbon-negative biorefinery, while Finnish engineers pioneered the first “sand battery” for storing green power. The Nature Conservancy helped Belize restructure its debt, freeing up $4 million annually for marine conservation over two decades. The largest vertical farm in the world opened in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. And all around the world, people are reaping the power of the sun: East Africa’s first tests of agrivoltaics began outside Nairobi, Kenya, and Europe’s largest floating photovoltaic farm is operating in Portugal.

Responsibility

MARCO UGARTE/AP/FILE
Butterflies at the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve near Chincua, Mexico. A successful reforestation effort included planting oyamel firs at higher elevations.

Around the world, people are caring for the planet and each other. In large-scale action for the environment, more than 5,100 square miles of protection for water, land, and glaciers was established in Argentina, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Colombia, and Chile, while the island nation of Niue is protecting 100% of its ocean. In Niger, researchers estimate that farmers encouraged at least 200 million trees to grow back across 15 million acres. South Korea now recycles nearly 100% of its food waste. And Austria is helping pay for repairs to electronics instead of landfilling them.

The United Nations will create a binding framework by the end of 2024 to guide the elimination of plastic pollution. It declared access to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment a universal human right.

The commitment was seen at the community level, too. More than 355,950 pounds of trash was removed from the Ohio River. Using a payment for ecosystem services model, citizens have planted over 2 million trees in southeastern Brazil since 2005. Gazans were able to return to their beaches after massive infrastructure improvements. And refugees in Algeria designed useful furniture out of plastic waste. There are signs environmental responsibility will become second nature for future generations; the United Kingdom’s Department of Education began work on a national climate curriculum. And in a commitment to improving safety, Hoboken, New Jersey, has eliminated traffic fatalities for four years running.

Dignity

People everywhere fought to protect the right to a dignified life. In many cases, that meant pushing for a decent standard of living, no matter one’s social class. Spain passed a law to give over 370,000 domestic workers the same labor protections as other workers. Morocco expanded paid paternity leave from three to 15 days for public workers. Some 25,000 previously unhoused people in Houston were moved into homes, California students were guaranteed access to free menstrual products at school, and banks across the United States canceled or lowered overdraft fees, which disproportionately affect lower-income households.

Steps were also taken to protect the dignity of children, marriage, and sexual orientation. Child marriage became illegal in the Philippines and has declined in Nigeria; forced marriage and sexual abuse were outlawed in Indonesia. France banned conversion therapy in defense of LGBTQ rights.

PARTH SANYAL/REUTERS/FILE
Women in Kanaipur, a village north of Kolkata, India, discuss health care and education in 2007.

Other initiatives gave marginalized communities new recognition and power. Residents of informal settlements in India received latitude- and longitude-based addresses – a step toward accessing resources and services – while women from villages in the northern part of the country, excluded from traditional governance structures, formed their own political assemblies.

Equality

The push for equal rights and opportunities was seen in government, science, sports, and beyond. In a year when women’s rights came to the forefront of protest movements in Iran and other places, women have continued to break barriers. The Netherlands achieved gender parity for the first time in its government, while Senegal came as close to parity as West Africa has seen. The first all-women newsroom opened in Somalia, and the U.S. women’s soccer team won equal pay with the men’s team. Nicole Mann became the first Native American woman in outer space. Ayesha Malik became the first woman on Pakistan’s Supreme Court. The drive for equality wasn’t limited to gender. Australia welcomed its most diverse government yet. Mexico, Andorra, and Cuba legalized same-sex marriage, and the latter commemorated Latin America’s first LGBTQ history month.

A wider appreciation of cultural diversity also took center stage. India’s Constitution was translated into Santali, a tribal language spoken in northeastern India. Tens of thousands of precious manuscripts of African scholarship saved from Timbuktu became available to all, while scholars began compiling the first Oxford Dictionary of African American English. And 3D technology helped Alaska Natives and other peoples to preserve traditional art forms and foster study of Indigenous cultures.

Cooperation

Progress was not an individual pursuit but required a willingness to work together amid differences. Many examples highlighted the need for Indigenous expertise. In Ecuador, a national court determined that extractive oil and mining projects need consent from Indigenous communities. In Canada, Indigenous groups joined forces with scientists, business, and government to triple the number of caribou in a British Columbia herd. Meanwhile in California, 523 acres of redwood forest were returned to Indigenous guardianship.

JUAN DIEGO MONTENEGRO/PICTURE-ALLIANCE/DPA/AP/FILE
A woman from the Waorani community speaks at a protest against new oil projects in the Amazon, in Quito, Ecuador, Oct. 18, 2021.

Communities around the world reaped the benefits of cooperative thinking. In a bid to prevent flooding from storms, over 500 New Orleans residents have banded together to build green infrastructure. In Egypt, a traditional peer-to-peer lending system gained new life through phone apps, helping small business owners get going. And couples in England and Wales can divorce cooperatively, and without having to point fingers, thanks to a “no-fault” law that went into effect last year.

Film

Beyond the blockbusters: The 10 best films of 2022

Our critic’s choices for the year’s top films feature a variety of themes, including the tenacity needed for a daring, real-life Thai rescue – and the defeat of a formidable fictional headmistress. 

Vince Valitutti/Metro Goldwyn Mayer Pictures
Ron Howard’s “Thirteen Lives” is a nail-biter about the real-life rescue of young, Thai soccer players from a mountain cave system.
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 5 Min. )

There were lots of movies to like in 2022, but the goodies were mostly to be found not in the Hollywood mainstream but on the outskirts. Maybe low-budget films, documentaries, and foreign language fare didn’t always take up the slack, but the best of them at least tried to be more venturesome than the usual ossified studio product.

Trends this year included the emergence or blossoming of several gifted female directors, a preponderance of semi-autobiographical coming-of-age movies, and a plethora of movies that dumped on the venal rich. 

If you craved popcorn movie action, you could be satisfyingly sated by “Top Gun: Maverick” or “Avatar: The Way of Water.” And if the Hollywood stuff didn’t grab you, you could glom onto “RRR,” S.S. Rajamouli’s phenomenally successful Raj-era Indian action epic.

Among the film’s in my Top 10 this year are “Hallelujah: Leonard Cohen, a Journey, a Song,” about the genesis of Cohen’s work, and “Thirteen Lives,” Ron Howard’s nail-biter about the real-life rescue of young, Thai soccer players from a mountain cave system. Also included is the family friendly “Roald Dahl’s Matilda the Musical,” which successfully brings the popular stage show to the screen, where the spirited young cast saves the day and then some. 

Beyond the blockbusters: The 10 best films of 2022

Collapse

There were lots of movies to like in 2022, but the goodies were mostly to be found not in the Hollywood mainstream but on the outskirts. Maybe low-budget films, documentaries, and foreign language fare didn’t always take up the slack, but the best of them at least tried to be more venturesome than the usual ossified studio product.

One of the most promising developments has been the emergence or blossoming of a number of gifted female directors, some making their feature film debuts. Sarah Polley, in “Women Talking,” directed what is easily her most assured work. Nikyatu Jusu’s “Nanny,” about a Senegalese nanny in New York’s Upper East Side, is the year’s most evocative horror film. First-time Scottish director Charlotte Wells arrives on the scene with the uneven but affecting father-daughter study “Aftersun,” which also heralds the arrival of a major young actor, Frankie Corio.

I also admired two European filmmakers, Belgian Laura Wandel, who debuted with “Playground,” and Audrey Diwan, from France, who made the timely abortion drama “Happening,” based on a story by French Nobel Prize winner Annie Ernaux. Their films are both signal achievements and hopefully harbingers of what is to come.

Another burgeoning development this year was the preponderance of semi-autobiographical coming-of-age movies, most prominently James Gray’s “Armageddon Time” and Steven Spielberg’s “The Fabelmans.” Whatever their faults, both sensibly resisted the impulse to wallow in self-serving nostalgia.

There was also a plethora of movies that dumped on the venal rich, including “The Menu,” “Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery,” and, easily the best of the bunch, “Triangle of Sadness.” In the documentary realm, the raw, imperfect “All the Beauty and the Bloodshed” exposed profiteers of the opioid crisis, though that was not the film’s only focus. In a convoluted way, maybe this is how the issue of income equality gets a seat at the multiplex these days.

Courtesy of the Cohen Estate Movie
The documentary “Hallelujah” is a deep dive into how ferociously personal musicmaking could be for Leonard Cohen.

Good films, as well as bad, can come from anywhere. And terrific performances can often appear even in middling movies. You wouldn’t want to miss Jennifer Ehle and Samantha Morton in “She Said.” Colin Farrell, Brendan Gleeson, and Kerry Condon invigorated “The Banshees of Inisherin.” So, too, did Emily Watson in “God’s Creatures,” Olivia Colman in “Empire of Light,” and Cate Blanchett in the otherwise overrated “Tár.”

If you craved popcorn movie action, you could be satisfyingly sated by “Top Gun: Maverick” or, much better, “Avatar: The Way of Water.” You didn’t have to settle for “Jurassic World Dominion” or “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.” And if the Hollywood stuff didn’t grab you, you could glom onto “RRR,” S.S. Rajamouli’s phenomenally successful Raj-era Indian action epic that, for sheer boffo exuberance, outdid anything the studios churned out this year.

Why did this movie, which I enjoyed without joining the gaga conga line, have such global crossover appeal? I think it’s because audiences drawn back into the theaters still crave the same communal oomph the big Hollywood franchise movies are tasked to supply but so rarely do. And if that oomph comes from a Tarantino-esque mashup of Bollywood and spaghetti Westerns and the Mahabharata, so much the better.

Film Movement
In “Playground,” Nora (Maya Vanderbeque, right) tries to protect her brother Abel (Günter Duret) from bullies.

Another surprise cult hit was “Everything Everywhere All At Once,” a multiverse maelstrom starring Michelle Yeoh. I found it exhausting, but I can see why it’s such a smash, and for much the same reason as “RRR.” It makes the familiar phantasmagoric. Why accept just a couple of multiverses in “Doctor Strange” when you can have dozens here? You say you don’t like this universe? Don’t worry, there’s plenty others you can escape to. It’s the perfect pandemic-era bliss-out. 

I prefer to bliss out over the best, and so, in alphabetical order, here are my Top 10 films of the year:

A Couple – Frederick Wiseman, our finest documentarian, makes a rare foray into staged drama with this filmed monologue starring the French actor Nathalie Boutefeu. It’s drawn mostly from the diaries and letters of Sophia Tolstoy, the long-suffering wife of the great novelist Leo Tolstoy. As she wanders alone the grounds of a spacious estate, she asks of her husband, “Do you see me as a person?” It’s an anguished plea and a major performance. (Not rated; French with English subtitles) 

A Hero – Asghar Farhadi’s best movie since his Oscar-winning “A Separation” is about a hapless debtor whose attempts at restitution become ever more comic and tragic. In the process, we get a bustling, comprehensive view of contemporary Iranian society. Do not be deterred from seeing this film because of the recent controversy over the unacknowledged contribution from one of Farhadi’s film students. (PG-13)

Amazon Studios
Sahar Goldoust (left) and Amir Jadidi in the Iranian film “A Hero,” from Academy Award winning director Asghar Farhadi.

Apollo 10½: A Space Age Childhood – Richard Linklater’s rotoscope animated ode to his NASA-obsessed Houston boyhood in the dawn of the 1969 Apollo 11 moon launch has the homegrown charm and lyricism that characterizes his best work. (PG-13)

Hallelujah: Leonard Cohen, a Journey, a Song – Dayna Goldfine and Daniel Geller’s documentary is not only about the genesis of Cohen’s famous song, but also a deep dive into how ferociously personal and even sacramental music making could be for him. (PG-13)

Nitram – Justin Kurzel’s slow burn dramatization of the wracked life of Australia’s most deadly mass shooter is a model of how to film incendiary material in a principled, nonexploitative way. Caleb Landry Jones, who won best actor at the Cannes Film Festival, heads a great supporting cast, including Judy Davis, Anthony LaPaglia, and Essie Davis. (Not rated)

Playground – No better movie has been made about the ramifications of schoolyard bullying than Laura Wandel’s extraordinary debut feature, shot almost entirely from the point of view of the little girl played by the precociously gifted Maya Vanderbeque. (Not rated; French with English subtitles)

Roald Dahl’s Matilda the Musical – For a change, a family movie that the whole family can actually enjoy. Emma Thompson as the evil headmistress is a hoot, and the spirited young cast, under Matthew Warchus’ direction, saves the day and then some. (PG)

The Good Nurse – True-crime dramas are a dime a dozen these days. This one, directed by Tobias Lindholm and featuring Eddie Redmayne as an anti-Florence Nightingale and Jessica Chastain as the fellow nurse and friend whose conscience led her to expose him, is exceptionally powerful. It is also an indictment of a hospital system that chooses to look the other way when one of its own goes rogue. (R) 

Thirteen Lives – Ron Howard’s nail-biter about the real-life rescue of Thai junior soccer players from a mountain cave system is a terrific example of how to meld action and empathy. We care about the rescue because we are made to care about the people. Viggo Mortensen and Colin Farrell give admirably unshowy star performances. (PG-13) 

Three Minutes: A Lengthening – Three minutes of rare color footage of a predominantly Jewish Polish town in 1938 is the forensic focus of this haunting documentary by Bianca Stigter. A metaphysical detective story, it is ultimately a movie about bearing witness. (PG)

Some other 2022 worthies in addition to those favorably cited in the opening section: “EO,” “The Automat,” “The Duke,” and “Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris.” 

Peter Rainer is the Monitor’s film critic. 

Other headline stories we’re watching

(Get live updates throughout the day.)

The Monitor's View

A new climate of trust-building

  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 2 Min. )

The world’s top industrial nations reached a $15.5 billion deal last week to help Vietnam shift toward a greener energy future. The agreement follows similar plans already reached with coal-dependent South Africa and Indonesia.

These “Just Energy Transition Partnerships” harness public and private funding to achieve a shared benefit, in this case reduced greenhouse gas emissions. What they reflect may be even more important than what they do. In a period of persistent distrust, they help show how humanity is forging new bonds of cooperation amid common threats.

“The present period of polycrisis has provided multiple tests for the concept of global trust,” the Edelman Trust Institute observed in a year-end collection of short essays on restoring trust. “History suggests that some of the most important steps forward in global cooperation came even at moments when trust was difficult to come by, and that these joint actions helped rebuild trust.”

The war in Ukraine offers another measure. Russian President Vladimir Putin “wanted to split the European Union, it became united,” former Finnish Prime Minister Alexander Stubb told the European news website Euractiv. “He wanted to destroy NATO. It’s back with a new purpose.”

Faced with extremity, humanity is uniting in opportunity.

A new climate of trust-building

Collapse
Reuters.
Ismail Sha studies with a rechargeable lantern in Cape Town in October. Power outages happen daily in South Africa. New partnerships with wealthy nations will help countries like South Africa, Indonesia, and Vietnam move from coal to green energy.

The world’s top industrial nations put the finishing touches on a $15.5 billion deal last week to help Vietnam shift toward a greener energy future. The agreement follows similar plans already reached with two other coal-dependent nations, South Africa and Indonesia.

These “Just Energy Transition Partnerships” harness public and private funding to achieve a shared benefit, in this case reduced greenhouse gas emissions. What they reflect, however, may be even more important than what they do. In a period of persistent distrust within and among nations, they help show how humanity is forging new bonds of cooperation amid common threats.

“The present period of polycrisis has provided multiple tests for the concept of global trust,” the Edelman Trust Institute observed in a year-end collection of short essays on restoring trust. “History suggests that some of the most important steps forward in global cooperation came even at moments when trust was difficult to come by, and that these joint actions helped rebuild trust.”

The energy partnerships, said United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres in comments last week about the Vietnam agreement, mark an “all hands on deck” partnership between rich and developing nations “to realize an energy transition that is global, sustainable, just, inclusive, and equitable.” 

The war in Ukraine offers another measure of unity emerging from crisis. Russian President Vladimir Putin “wanted to split the European Union, it became united,” former Finnish Prime Minister Alexander Stubb told the European news website Euractiv. “He wanted to destroy NATO. It’s back with a new purpose.” 

The Edelman essays on restoring trust illustrate how societies are repairing trust in response to overlapping challenges like polarization, inflation, the pandemic, climate change, and hunger. In developing nations, governments and technology companies have sought to overcome trust deficits by expanding digital access to public services like health care and financial services like banking. That has helped them democratize economic opportunity and reduce economic vulnerability, write Nandan Nilekani, co-founder of Infosys, and Tanuj Bhojwani, co-author of “The Art of Bitfulness."

Manu Meel offers a view of a new generation’s response to polarization. A member of Generation Z, he founded BridgeUSA, an organization that promotes dialogue on college campuses across the United States. He hopes to restore faith in democracy among a generation shaped by repeated crises stretching from 9/11 to Jan. 6. That involves “cultivating a certain temperament that exists above ideology: a temperament that values open-mindedness over closed-mindedness; empathy over exclusion; building spaces that bring people in as opposed to building spaces that keep people out.”

“We are living in what should be a golden age of cross-border learning,” writes Parag Khanna, founder of Climate Alpha, a real estate analytics firm. “Both West and East have much to share in ... the essential task of rebuilding trust in government worldwide.” Faced with extremity, humanity is uniting in opportunity.

A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

The healing love of Christ

  • Quick Read
  • Read or Listen ( 3 Min. )

When we open our hearts to the timeless Christ that Jesus so fully lived, blessings naturally result.

The healing love of Christ

Collapse
Today's Christian Science Perspective audio edition

Perhaps there have been times in our lives when everything in us has cried out to feel loved in a way that would make a practical difference. Maybe we were facing a prolonged illness, or grieving the loss of someone dear to us, or fighting some internal battle with fear, discouragement, or sensuality.

For anyone in these situations, the core message of Christianity can resound with hope. It says to each one of us, “You can most certainly experience the love of Christ, which heals.”

The Gospels illustrate the love of our devout Savior, Christ Jesus, toward every individual who appealed to him for healing. It was a love that flowed freely through the very fiber of Jesus’ life and teachings and healing ministry.

So profound and enduring was its impact on the many lives that it touched, that this love must have been divine in origin. And this Christly, God-impelled love is as real and vital today as it was when Jesus walked the earth.

Christian Science takes up the important distinction between the human man Jesus – who was among humanity for a relatively brief period of time – and the Christ, Truth, which he said would be with humanity forever. For example, Jesus said, “I am the way, the truth, and the life” (John 14:6) and “The Son of man is come to seek and to save that which was lost” (Luke 19:10). We might take the first statement as referring to the divine and eternal Christ – the spiritual identity of the human man, Jesus, that the second quote refers to.

One way of defining the role of Christ in our lives is as the anointing love of God, revealing us all to be sons and daughters of the one divine Father-Mother God, who is Love itself. Christ comes to receptive consciousness, showing our true selfhood to be entirely spiritual, created in the likeness of God, Spirit, and so exempt from the vagaries of a so-called material existence.

In quietude and humility we experience the healing effect of this divine influence. It silences persistent doubt, self-judgment, sinful tendencies, even health verdicts associated with devastating outcomes. It disentangles thought enrapt with the seeming complexities of a situation, freeing us from the grips of fear. The effect of Christ welcomed in consciousness is moral and physical healing, and harmonious adjustments in our lives and relationships.

Jesus’ role in human history was unique and world-changing. Yet he didn’t claim for himself one iota of personal healing ability; rather, he said he couldn’t do anything without God (see John 8:28). Nor did he indicate that the spiritual healing he practiced was confined to that particular period in history or limited to a few immediate followers. He credited God with all the goodness and light and love that he expressed.

As a child I would sometimes think, “What if I could come to Jesus with this problem I’m having?” I would imagine what that might be like, naturally assuming that he would heal me.

Eventually I came to see that the entire gospel message points to the eternal grace of God, whose love for each of us is free-flowing, constant, full, and always present to heal and to save. Once when I was ill, a simple prayer acknowledging, “God’s eternal Christ is present in my consciousness now, doing for me what Christ would do were I in the presence of Jesus,” resulted first in a sense of peace and then in quick healing of the physical difficulty.

Mary Baker Eddy, a lifelong student of the Bible and devoted follower of Christ Jesus, writes in the textbook of Christian Science, “Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures,” “Christ is the true idea voicing good, the divine message from God to men speaking to the human consciousness. The Christ is incorporeal, spiritual, – yea, the divine image and likeness, dispelling the illusions of the senses; the Way, the Truth, and the Life, healing the sick and casting out evils, destroying sin, disease, and death” (p. 332).

We are free at any time during our day to entertain in prayer the healing Christ. Christ inspires us to know ourselves increasingly as God knows us, to feel our heavenly Father’s love, and to experience more and more consistently the healing impression of this love upon our lives.

A message of love

Holiday gifts

Marcio Jose Sanchez/AP
A young Haitian migrant stands next to his father after receiving holiday toys at an entry point in Tijuana, Mexico, Dec. 20, 2022.

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us today. Come back tomorrow to explore sparks of intimate illumination, during this season of hope and joy. 

More issues

2022
December
22
Thursday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.