2023
September
06
Wednesday

Monitor Daily Podcast

September 06, 2023
Loading the player...

TODAY’S INTRO

What will we uncover this year?

Ira Porter
Education Writer

Issues important to higher education seem endless.

The United States Supreme Court ended race-based admissions in June, which I’m sure made millions of teenagers of color around the country and the world anxious about whether they would get accepted into dream schools. Legacy admissions for scions of wealthy or well-connected alumni at some of those same schools were challenged as a result of that same ruling, sending shivers of nervousness to privileged people, too.

Artificial intelligence threatens to take away the discovery process of young people studying and figuring out problems on their own by giving them the words to craft would-be research papers. National security concerns have pushed some campuses to ban TikTok on their public Wi-Fi. Students can’t afford housing. Controversial faculty appointments have been made and rescinded. Financially strapped universities are cutting majors and disciplines. A war on woke education finds new targets daily.

With all of this before us, I will travel to California this week to gather with reporters at the Education Writers Association conference on higher education. We will talk about how we can best present these stories to the public. Every issue matters deeply to someone, from the pots of gold available in reshuffling in athletic conferences, to the urgency of finding housing to keep students from being homeless.

I am honored to be able to present some of these issues to you in the Monitor’s pages, and I hope along the way that you suggest a story or two to me. School is back in session. What will we uncover this year?

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

In Trump’s Georgia case, large cast portends complex trial

The Georgia case against Donald Trump and his 18 co-defendants, all of whom have pleaded not guilty, is massive and complex. Each individual’s legal strategy has the potential to impact the rest.

Fulton County Sheriff's Office/Reuters
A combination picture shows police booking mug shots of former President Donald Trump and 11 of the 18 people indicted with him, including (left to right, and from the top down) lawyers Ray Smith, Rudy Giuliani, Jenna Ellis, and Sidney Powell; former Georgia Republican Party leader Cathy Latham; Trump campaign attorney Kenneth Chesebro; former Georgia Republican Party leader David Shafer; Republican poll watcher Scott Hall; lawyer John Eastman; Harrison Floyd, former head of Black Voices for Trump; and former White House chief of staff Mark Meadows.
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 6 Min. )

The people who allegedly helped then-President Donald Trump try to overturn the 2020 election constituted a large, loosely linked, and surprisingly diverse group.

According to prosecutors in Fulton County, Georgia, those involved in Mr. Trump’s efforts to “find” enough votes to change Georgia’s results include Rudy Giuliani, the former New York mayor – but also lesser-known defendants such as Scott Hall, a Georgia bail bondsman, and Stephen Lee, a pastor from Illinois.

In a way, the sprawling Georgia case could be seen as just one piece of a larger picture. According to the federal indictment filed by special counsel Jack Smith, the Trump team pressured officials in at least six other key states to help it block President Joe Biden’s election.

Mr. Trump’s false charges of Democratic election fraud implied a vast national conspiracy for which no evidence has emerged. In the Georgia and federal election cases, prosecutors will in essence assert that the conspiracy was on the other side.

“If the facts are true as reported, this was a pretty wide-reaching, many-tentacled operation that was trying through any means possible to prevent certification of the presidential election, or reverse its outcome,” says Caren Morrison, an associate professor at Georgia State University’s College of Law.

In Trump’s Georgia case, large cast portends complex trial

Collapse

It was not just Donald Trump. The people who allegedly helped the then-president try to overturn the results of the 2020 election constituted a large, loosely linked, and surprisingly diverse army of longtime allies and newly minted supporters.

That’s reflected in the state election interference charges in Fulton County, Georgia. According to prosecutors, those involved in Mr. Trump’s efforts to “find” enough votes to change Georgia’s results include Rudy Giuliani, the famous former mayor of New York – but also lesser-known defendants such as Scott Hall, a Georgia bail bondsman, and Stephen Lee, a pastor from Illinois.

Mark Meadows, Mr. Trump’s former chief of staff, is one of those indicted. So are Trevian Kutti, a former publicist for rapper Kanye West (who now goes by Ye), and Harrison Floyd, an ex-Marine active in the group Black Voices for Trump.

The sheer scale of the Georgia case against Mr. Trump and his 18 co-defendants, all of whom have pleaded not guilty, will likely tax both prosecutors and defense attorneys, say legal experts. That’s perhaps why special counsel Jack Smith streamlined his federal election case, charging only Mr. Trump and leaving six alleged co-conspirators unindicted.

But in a way, the sprawling Georgia case could be seen as just one piece of a larger picture. According to the federal indictment, the Trump team pressured officials in at least six other key states – Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin – to help it block Joe Biden’s election as president.

Jim Vondruska/Reuters
Pastor Stephen Lee, an alleged co-conspirator related to the harassment of election workers in Georgia, stands for a portrait outside Living Word Lutheran Church in Orland Park, Illinois, Aug. 27, 2023.

Mr. Trump’s false charges of Democratic election fraud in 2020 implied a vast national conspiracy for which no evidence has emerged. In the Georgia and federal election cases, prosecutors will in essence assert that the conspiracy was on the other side.

“If the facts are true as reported, this was a pretty wide-reaching, many-tentacled operation that was trying through any means possible to prevent certification of the presidential election, or reverse its outcome,” says Caren Morrison, a former assistant U.S. attorney and associate professor at Georgia State University’s College of Law.

One case, 19 defendants, disparate charges

The 19 Georgia election interference defendants were scheduled for a Wednesday arraignment, in which they enter a plea before a judge and are told the charges against them. State law allows defendants to waive their right to appear in person, however, and all opted to enter their “not guilty” pleas remotely, thus avoiding televised courtroom appearances.

Mr. Trump and other top defendants are charged with multiple offenses. The former president and Mr. Giuliani both face 13 felony counts in the Georgia case.

Among other things, Mr. Trump participated in a recorded phone call with Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger in which the then-president falsely claimed he had won the state by “hundreds of thousands of votes.” 

Meanwhile, Mr. Giuliani claimed that Georgia’s voting machines had been rigged. He falsely charged that two state election workers, Ruby Freeman and Wandrea “Shaye” Moss, had been caught on tape participating in election fraud. In a separate case last month, Mr. Giuliani conceded that he had made defamatory statements about the two women.

Brynn Anderson/AP
Rudy Giuliani speaks at the Fulton County Jail, Aug. 23, 2023, in Atlanta. Mr. Giuliani surrendered to Georgia authorities to face an indictment alleging he acted as former President Donald Trump’s chief co-conspirator in a plot to subvert the 2020 election.

Other defendants were charged for one or two particular actions. Trevian Kutti flew to Atlanta from her Chicago home on Jan. 4, 2021, and allegedly tried to get Ms. Freeman to confess to election fraud. At a meeting in an Atlanta police precinct, she told Ms. Freeman she “needed protection and purported to offer her help,” according to the indictment. 

Mr. Floyd allegedly helped recruit Ms. Kutti to talk to Ms. Freeman. According to the indictment, he joined in the conversation via phone.

Mr. Lee also traveled to Ms. Freeman’s home to pressure her, according to prosecutors. They said Mr. Hall was involved in an effort to illegally access voting machines in Coffee County, Georgia, to check them for alleged fraud.

Three other defendants were charged with participating in a scheme to replace Georgia’s 16 presidential electors with an unauthorized, unelected pro-Trump slate.

Similar groups of fake electors were organized in six other states. In a Tuesday court filing, Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis compared such efforts to claiming that “a homemade badge” could turn someone into “a genuine United States Marshal with all the powers afforded that position.”

Will some defendants be tried separately? 

The federal case filed by special counsel Smith has only one charged defendant: Mr. Trump. Legal experts say it is designed for speed – speed to trial, speed in the courtroom, perhaps a quick verdict prior to the 2024 presidential election.

The Georgia case isn’t like that. With its cast of characters and interweaving plotlines, it recounts a lengthy story. This may reflect Georgia’s expansive racketeering law, which Ms. Willis has often used to bring charges against what she deems to be organized criminal enterprises.

“By its very nature, the Georgia case is sprawling,” says Daniel Urman, a law professor at Northeastern University.

Trying a case with 19 defendants can be challenging for prosecutors. At a Sept. 6 hearing, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Scott McAfee sounded highly skeptical of such an all-inclusive approach, saying it sounded “unrealistic.”

At the same time, Judge McAfee denied a request from former Trump lawyers Kenneth Chesebro and Sidney Powell to sever their cases from each other, for now.

If defendants do split into groups, those scheduled for later might have the advantage of getting an early look into the prosecution’s case and courtroom methods.

“It’s almost like you’re a football team and you get to see your opponent in preseason games,” says Professor Urman.

But if the prosecution gets an early conviction, the pressure on the remaining defendants might increase. Should they cut a plea deal and testify against the others? If they don’t, will someone else turn against them?

In such a situation, “there’s a really great incentive for [co-defendants] to provide evidence, strike deals, and get out from under these charges,” says Anthony Michael Kreis, an assistant professor at Georgia State University’s College of Law.

The legal strategies of the defendants are already beginning to diverge, in ways that could perhaps damage the person at the top. The three Georgia defendants charged with serving as fake electors now say they did so because they were acting upon the instructions of then-President Trump. An attorney for Mr. Meadows has intimated that his client may similarly point at Mr. Trump as the primary force behind the Georgia effort.

Dustin Chambers/Reuters
Former Trump chief of staff Mark Meadows (center, below arrow) walks out of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, where a hearing on his petition to move the Fulton County case to federal court in the 2020 election case took place, in Atlanta, Aug. 28, 2023.

A busy legal calendar ... and a coming election

At the least, the complications of the Georgia prosecution and the various other court cases Mr. Trump will face in coming months are likely to produce a frenzied period of legal motions, disputes, countermotions, and hearings that could steal voter attention away from U.S. politics.

The first major court date will come in early October, with the beginning of New York Attorney General Letitia James’ civil suit against Mr. Trump, his business, and family members for allegedly fraudulently inflating the value of their assets by billions of dollars.

Trials will then ramp up through 2024, beginning in January with a second defamation case against Mr. Trump filed by writer E. Jean Carroll. The federal election interference case is currently scheduled to begin in March, and the federal trial on illegal retention of classified documents at Mar-a-Lago is scheduled to start in May.

Given the legal competition and the size of the case, the trial of Mr. Trump in Georgia could wind up being pushed back past next November, says Professor Morrison.

“I think it will be hard to get it done before the election,” she says.

Graphic

Sea ice is shrinking. These maps show by how much.

Heat waves this summer from the U.S. to Europe and Asia have caught the world’s attention. But it has also been unseasonably warm in the Antarctic winter – with visible effects.

It can be hard to visualize the magnitude of change underway on a warming planet. What does a hundred gigatons of ice look like? How many millions of Olympic swimming pools can you imagine?

Our charts with this article aim to contextualize the massive changes underway in the Antarctic, with data from the U.S. National Snow and Ice Data Center.

The headline: A warm southern winter has produced far less sea ice than normal, indicating a fundamental change may have taken place in this historically variable climate.

By the end of August, Antarctic sea ice extent (the total region with at least 15% sea ice cover) was about 860,000 square miles smaller than the average August extent from 1981 to 2010. That’s a patch of ocean the size of Saudi Arabia, normally filled with ice but now open ocean, the lowest winter level since recording began 45 years ago. And the overall trend of sea ice growth in Antarctica has reversed in the past few years, from growth to a slight decline. – Jacob Turcotte

SOURCE:

National Snow and Ice Data Center

|
Jacob Turcotte/Staff

How a Buddhist-inspired high school is boosting Hungary’s Roma

In a Hungarian high school, members of the long-oppressed Roma community are taking inspiration from the way another such group, the Dalits in India, set its sights on reform and took control of finding a better future.

  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 6 Min. )

Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar, India’s first post-independence minister for law and justice, never set foot in Hungary.

But members of Hungary’s Roma community learned about Dr. Ambedkar’s transformative work, in which he helped outlaw India’s caste system last century and improved the lives of his fellow Dalits in India. And they recognized a kindred spirit.

Today, the Dr. Ambedkar School is working to empower intellectual and political leaders from within Hungary’s Roma community, based on the Indian social reformer’s example. Teachers prepare students for Hungary’s national graduation exams in areas like mathematics, literature, and history. But students also learn lessons drawn from Dr. Ambedkar’s life of activism.

Romanis and the Dalits are the same, says 20-year-old student János Kun. “We are a caste,” he declares. “We are at the very bottom level of society. But I’m not embarrassed to be poor.”

Mr. Kun is honing his activism by organizing summer camps for younger Romani children, where he helps show them paths out of poverty. “My friends and I who go to this school strive to show people that it doesn’t have to be this way,” he says.

How a Buddhist-inspired high school is boosting Hungary’s Roma

Collapse
Marc Loustau
Students hang out in the school courtyard between classes at the Dr. Ambedkar School, May 3, 2023, in Miskolc, Hungary. Teachers prepare students for Hungary’s national graduation exams, but students also learn lessons drawn from Dr. Ambedkar’s life of activism.

Classes begin with a gong, not a bell, at the Dr. Ambedkar School.

Each morning, 125 students in grades nine through 12, all from the local Romani community, enter the school grounds beneath a brass plaque embossed in both Hungarian and Hindi. The text marks the life of the school’s namesake, Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar, India’s first post-independence minister for law and justice.

The inscription finishes by invoking the school’s religious mission: “[Dr. Ambedkar] is a Buddhist saint,” it reads.

Dr. Ambedkar never set foot in Hungary, much less in the provincial northwestern city of Miskolc where the school was established in 2006. But members of Hungary’s Roma community learned about Dr. Ambedkar’s transformative work, in which he helped outlaw India’s caste system last century and improved the lives of his fellow Dalits in India. And they recognized a kindred spirit.

The Dr. Ambedkar School is working to empower intellectual and political leaders from within Hungary’s Roma community, based on the Indian social reformer’s example. And while his neo-Buddhist worldview may seem like an odd bedfellow for Roma activism, the two are finding remarkable synchronicity among the school’s students.

“The role of the school is more than that of an educational institution, but rather a community institution that treats students with respect and dignity, providing a sense of hope and respect to Roma who are otherwise treated as outcasts by the mainstream society,” says Jekatyerina Dunajeva, a political scientist with Central European University’s Romani Studies Program. “What permeates the culture of the school is a keen awareness of justice, fairness, and opposition to oppression.”

Lessons from the Dalits

Dr. Ambedkar was a leader in India’s independence movement in the 1930s as well as a member of the country’s oppressed Dalit group. In 1956, he founded the neo-Buddhist movement, also known as Ambedkarite Buddhism, which looked at Buddhism as a vehicle for social reform. In particular, neo-Buddhism turned into a means for Dalits – who face rampant discrimination at the bottom of Hinduism’s caste ladder – to leave the system that was oppressing them.

Romani activist János Orsós learned about neo-Buddhism in the late 1990s by reading a biography of Dr. Ambedkar. Then in 2005, he traveled to India, from which the Roma ethnic minority originally emigrated nearly 1,000 years ago.

There he saw that both members of the Roma community and Indian Dalits struggle with problems like racism, discrimination, and segregation. In his memoir about finding Buddhism, Mr. Orsós noted he was most impressed by his visits to Dalit Buddhists’ schools.

“The Dalit people run these institutions themselves, not white people,” he wrote, “I saw people like me take their destiny into their own hands through Buddhism and that is what I wanted to do.”

Hungary’s educational system is highly segregated. Many Romani children attend Roma-only schools that are often underfunded and staffed by poorly trained teachers who do not understand Roma’s distinctive culture and history. Today, 60% of Romani children drop out of school, compared with 8.9% of the general population.

Mr. Orsós believed that his Roma community could be empowered and emboldened by Ambedkarite Buddhism’s basic principles: educate, agitate, organize. So he founded the Dr. Ambedkar School in 2006.

Marc Loustau
Like Dr. Ambedkar, János Kun has grown up in extreme poverty and struggles against racism. “I would call myself an activist, too,” he says.

“We are a caste”

The school draws its 125 students from Miskolc, which has a population of around 161,000, and its surrounding villages, of which around 58,000 are Romani, according to Hungary’s 2012 census. Teachers prepare students for Hungary’s national graduation exams in areas like mathematics, literature, and history. But students also learn lessons drawn from Dr. Ambedkar’s life of activism.

“I would call myself an activist, too,” student János Kun says. Like Dr. Ambedkar, Mr. Kun has grown up in extreme poverty and struggles against racism.

“There are eight of us in my family,” the 20-year-old says. “Six of us children live in one room.” His parents have only a sixth grade education, and he will be the first of his family to graduate from high school. He is the eldest child and helps care for his younger siblings in a house without running water.

Romanis and the Dalits are the same, Mr. Kun says, down to their social status. “We are a caste,” he declares. “We are at the very bottom level of society. But I’m not embarrassed to be poor.”

Mr. Kun is honing his activism by organizing summer camps for younger Romani children where he helps show them paths out of poverty. But he also organizes on behalf of his school. He personally recruited nearly half of his graduating class to attend the school, including Petra Békési, Mr. Kun’s 21-year-old classmate, who says that he first told her about the school when they ran into each other on a Miskolc city bus.

“My friends and I who go to this school strive to show people that it doesn’t have to be this way,” Mr. Kun says. “Anyone can learn. Anyone can develop themselves.”

Plenty of obstacles

Dr. Ambedkar’s story and the activism-oriented school of Buddhism that he founded help students develop a positive self-image, says Tibor Derdák, the school’s director. “We are all equal in our spiritual development,” he says.

Few students actually convert to Buddhism, he adds, although he says the message of equality and self-esteem touches everyone: students, teachers, and parents alike. But while several staff members, including Mr. Orsós, are Buddhist, the school does not offer courses on Buddhism and does not condone proselytizing. Publicity about Buddhism in the school and community has incurred harassment from the authorities in the past.

Jacob Turcotte/Staff

Even without the suspicion that authorities show toward Buddhism, the school and its community still have to deal with the government’s prejudice against Roma and desire to control the country’s education system.

Hungary’s current government, led by Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, has drawn broad criticism for using racist rhetoric to promote xenophobic, anti-migrant policies. On campus, Mr. Orbán’s hostility to minorities is nothing new.

Governments have come and gone in Hungary, says Mr. Derdák, but none have improved living conditions for Roma. “Thirty-four years have passed since the fall of communism, and nothing has changed,” he says.

Mr. Orbán’s allies in his Fidesz party donated the school’s Miskolc building as well as 100 million forints ($280,000) for renovations. However, as a private, independent school, the Dr. Ambedkar School does not receive regular government funding and opted against receiving any additional state aid.

Other private schools serving Roma communities decided to accept state funding – and saw the government immediately step in to replace teachers and staff. Mr. Derdák calls it a cautionary tale. “We don’t like the way the state is influencing the school’s day-to-day functioning,” he says.

The school’s independence has limits, though. The same economic policies that affect Roma throughout Hungary are also negatively impacting the Dr. Ambedkar School.

The biggest threat to the school’s future, Mr. Derdák says, is the Fidesz government’s “work-based society” program. Under this scheme, the government lowered the mandated school attendance age from 18 to 16, and expanded government work programs to provide employment to young people. Mr. Orbán has promoted the idea that those who aren’t succeeding in school should be diverted into the workplace where they can practice practical trades.

But the work-based society program creates problematic incentives for Romani students, who are already struggling against discrimination in hostile school environments, to leave and seek out an easy and immediate paycheck, according to Mr. Derdák. Instead, they end up in dead-end, menial employment for village and town governments, which have little incentive to provide additional professional training. “The vast majority end up in the same subordinated, oppressed situation,” he says.

But the Dr. Ambedkar School’s empowerment-centered educational model could change that, says Dr. Dunajeva, the political scientist. Dr. Ambedkar’s philosophy is the key. “It’s the inspiration for Roma youth to not only acquire basic skills,” she says, “but also develop a strong identity that will equip them in their future quest for social justice.”

Jacob Turcotte/Staff

Books

What one author discovered about racial equity in schools

Do efforts to racially integrate cities help schools with equity as well? In “Dream Town,” reporter Laura Meckler examines her Ohio hometown’s tenacious push to help students.

Portrait photo © Jeanne Van Atta
Laura Meckler
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 4 Min. )

Washington Post journalist Laura Meckler stumbled on a story about racial equity that she didn’t want to stop reporting. So she wrote a book about it.

The narrative unfolds in her Ohio hometown of Shaker Heights – a Cleveland suburb that over the decades has been lauded for its racial integration efforts. Did that lead to racial equity within the city’s public schools, though?

“Dream Town: Shaker Heights and the Quest for Racial Equity” highlights the connection between housing choices, neighborhood demographics, and schools. Equitable school systems and equitable communities go hand in hand, Ms. Meckler suggests.

“What this book tries to do is look at it the next level up, which is what’s happening inside those walls once everybody gets into the school system together,” she says in an interview. Ultimately, she sees what’s happening in Shaker Heights as a hopeful story. 

“Even if these problems don’t get solved,” Ms. Meckler says, “the fact that they’re still working on them and pushing the ball forward ... that is meaningful, and it puts them ahead of a lot of this country.”

What one author discovered about racial equity in schools

Collapse

Laura Meckler never intended to write a book, but then she stumbled on a story about racial equity that she didn’t want to stop reporting. The narrative unfolds in her Ohio hometown of Shaker Heights – a Cleveland suburb that over the decades has been lauded for its racial integration efforts. Did that lead to racial equity within the city’s public schools, though?

Ms. Meckler, a national education reporter for The Washington Post, started to explore that question in a story published in 2019.

“When I was done with that, I just had this feeling like there was more to say,” she says. “Even though the story that ran in the Post was quite long, I still felt like I was barely scratching the surface on so many elements.”

Her first book, “Dream Town: Shaker Heights and the Quest for Racial Equity,” finishes what she started with the initial newspaper story. Ms. Meckler spoke recently with the Monitor. 

Your book digs deep into how housing policies shaped Shaker Heights and, in some cases, encouraged residents to band together for the sake of racial integration. Why is that so important?

Where we go to school depends on where we live, and the diversity of our schools very often depends on the diversity of our neighborhoods. So these two things cannot be separated.

I think, innately, people understand how tightly those are tied. The way it usually works is a couple gets married, and maybe they’re living in the city or they’re living in an apartment somewhere. Then they decide that they’re going to move. They’re thinking about having kids or they have young kids. Where they decide to move is always informed, for most people, by what the schools are like. 

You write about two school systems within one: “Black and white students were together – but also apart.” Given that scene, what would true racial equity look like in practice?

In Shaker Heights, you have something that most of the country does not, which is this economic diversity and racial diversity within one school district. Some people are paying much higher taxes, and that’s benefiting people who have higher needs. That is a huge step toward equity. But what this book tries to do is look at it the next level up, which is what’s happening inside those walls once everybody gets into the school system together. And true equity looks like everybody having the same opportunities for success. There are a lot of systemic barriers built into schools everywhere – and in Shaker – that have stood in the way of that happening.

What are examples of those barriers?

There are issues of implicit bias. I heard so many stories from Black parents and students who had tales of assumptions being made about them. Not knowing about an advanced class that was an option. Being discouraged when somebody else might have been encouraged.

There are also institutional barriers. Some parents have jobs that allow them to stop by the school more often. Other people might be working more than one job or be so exhausted from being on their feet all day that they just don’t have the energy to go into something at school.

The book also examines the school district’s more recent “detracking” efforts, which put students of mixed abilities in the same classroom. From your observations, what was the key to making that work?

I’m not sure we yet know whether it was successful or not. Truthfully, I think that the detracking initiative was pretty poorly implemented.

One of the lessons actually from the detracking initiative is that if you’re going to try to do some hard things like this, you really need to do it very carefully and in a way that communicates with people and brings people along. You’re never going to win over everybody.

To the extent that it did work, though, ... it was because of the commitment of those teachers, I think, who were working really hard to do differentiated teaching. So, for instance, one person might reflect on a novel by making a podcast about it. Somebody else might write a paper. Somebody else might deliver a speech. Someone else might do a graphic novel-type drawing.

You note that Shaker Heights is far from perfect, but it’s still trying. What can other communities learn from the city’s racial equity efforts?

If this is something that’s important to you – to try to create a more equitable community and a more equitable system – it takes work and it takes commitment. You have to sustain that commitment over a long period of time. There is no one magic bullet, perfect solution. 

I concluded that this is really a story that’s more hopeful. Even if these problems don’t get solved, the fact that they’re still working on them and pushing the ball forward ... that is meaningful, and it puts them ahead of a lot of this country.

Points of Progress

What's going right

Hotlines, foreign policy, and monkeys

This week’s progress roundup offers hope that compassion is making a difference worldwide. Chile is paying attention to gender equality in its foreign affairs. And community collaborations in Tanzania made a rebound possible for the rare kipunji monkey. 

Hotlines, foreign policy, and monkeys

Collapse

1. United States

Four million people accessed mental health services through the 988 suicide prevention hotline in its first year. The number of calls, texts, and chats shows a 33% increase over calls in the previous year to a 10-digit number, which is still in operation. The hotline connects people experiencing mental health distress to crisis counselors, who provide immediate support and referrals.

A June survey found that 63% of Americans had heard of 988, with those ages 18-29 being most aware. LGBTQ+ people, who have a higher risk of suicide, were twice as likely to have heard of the hotline. In 2020, suicide was the second leading cause of death for Americans ages 10-14 and 25-34.

Katherine Frey/The Washington Post/AP/File
Sue-Ann Siegel takes a call in Maryland for the Montgomery County hotline, March 2020.


Officials want to increase awareness among older adults, especially veterans – though 988 also links to the Veterans Crisis Line, which handled nearly 1 million calls in the past year. Many people are dissuaded from calling because they believe counselors will contact law enforcement, although 98% of calls are de-escalated over the phone.

While the Biden administration has invested nearly $1 billion in the system of more than 200 call centers since 2021, mental health advocates say more state and local funding is needed for ongoing support.

Sources: KFF Health News, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

2. Chile

Chile is the first country in South America to implement a feminist foreign policy, joining at least four European Union countries, Canada, and Mexico. The initiative addresses gender issues and human rights in areas from climate change to science.

In bilateral agreements, the Foreign Ministry says it has been using concrete language on gender issues to “ensure a better distribution of benefits in international trade.” Other priorities include gender violence eradication and assistance through its consulates for Chilean women experiencing violence abroad. The government also seeks to expand its diplomatic corps by recognizing the traditional role of women as caregivers and the support that requires.

Esteban Felix/AP
Women raise scarves with a message against gender violence in Santiago, Chile, March 8, 2023.

“I don’t think we can conceive of democracy in the 21st century without thinking of gender equality,” said Gloria de la Fuente, undersecretary of foreign affairs. “We have to believe that a feminist foreign policy is not just a passing trend. It aligns with our broader objectives.”

Ms. de la Fuente emphasized that Chile intends to implement accountability mechanisms to ensure long-term commitment to the policy.

Sources: Americas Quarterly, Chilean Ministry of Foreign Affairs, United Nations Women

3. Israel

Israel is requiring solar panels on new nonresidential buildings, and new residential buildings must be equipped for future solar installations. Officials say the program will help the country meet its 2030 goal of producing 30% of its electricity with renewables.

Israel receives ample sunlight, but it lacks the large tracts of open land to support more solar fields. It is also not well suited for hydroelectric or wind power. Israel’s existing commercial solar plants are far from population centers, and much electricity is lost in transit.

“It is important to maintain open spaces,” Ron Eifer of the energy ministry said. “You can’t just cover the entire Negev desert in solar panels.” The initiative also mandates that 60% of required solar panels double as roofs, reducing construction costs. In March, the government canceled a paperwork requirement in order to reduce the red tape around installing panels on existing buildings.

Israel had success in 1976 with a residential requirement for sun-powered water heaters. Without them, the country would today need to produce 8% more electricity.

Amir Cohen/Reuters
Solar panels cover cowsheds in Kibbutz Or HaNer, southern Israel, June 19, 2023.


Sources: Reuters, The Times of Israel

4. Tanzania

Kipunji, rare primates endemic to Tanzania, are making a comeback. A 2022 study found that over 13 years, the population increased by 65% and its range expanded by one-fifth.

With its triangular crest and baboonlike muzzle, the monkey was first seen by Western researchers just 20 years ago. Nearly all live in the slopes of Mount Rungwe and the Livingstone Range Forest, where deforestation, charcoal production, and agriculture threaten habitats. The Udzungwa Mountains host 5% of the population, and a 2007 survey found only 1,117 kipunji in all.

The Wildlife Conservation Society, the government, and locals worked together to reduce habitat degradation and human-wildlife conflict. Habitats are protected in a national park and nature reserve, and income-generating projects such as beekeeping provide locals with alternatives to felling trees. Wildlife clubs have taught conservation principles in schools, and researchers worked with farmers to reduce crop raids by kipunji.

Although conservation began almost immediately after the kipunji became the first new primate discovery in Africa in 80 years, their numbers remain low. But the 2022 report notes that if trends remain positive, the kipunji population could double in the next 25 years and expand into new parts of the forest.

Source: Mongabay

5. China

Scientists created butterfly-inspired nanofilms that passively cool objects while giving them vibrant colors. Researchers hope the new films could be used on buildings, vehicles, and equipment to reduce the energy required for cooling while maintaining vivid colors.

A blue car appears blue by reflecting blue light and absorbing other colors. But such absorption also causes the object’s temperature to increase, and it takes large amounts of energy to counter these effects and cool the object. The films, inspired by how morpho butterflies create their vivid blue color with reflective scales, circumvent this with nanostructures that reflect light to produce color without heating up.

To create the nanofilms, scientists covered frosted glass with a multilayered material made of titanium dioxide and silicon dioxide and then placed the structure on a layer of reflective silver.

The films made colorful objects about 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) cooler than ambient temperatures, and blue films left outside during the day were 26 degrees Celsius cooler than conventional car paint. Next, researchers hope to optimize other aspects of the films, such as mechanical and chemical robustness, and replace silver with aluminum to lower production costs.

Source: Optica

Other headline stories we’re watching

(Get live updates throughout the day.)

The Monitor's View

A global reach for clean governance

  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 2 Min. )

In an opinion survey this year in 12 leading economies, people from Italy to China said they were more concerned about corruption than climate change. Such a popular expectation of integrity in governance helps explain why this week’s summit of the 20 biggest economies, known as the Group of 20, includes a renewed focus on lifting standards on accountability and transparency – which range from whistleblower protection to anti-bribery enforcement.

Together, the G20 countries can set an example for the rest of the world because they account for 80% of the global economy. This year’s summit host, India, has won some consensus among the group on how to cooperate better on asset recovery, or the winning back of stolen money sent abroad by corrupt players.

One helpmate for the G20 on fighting corruption is a Paris-based group of 38 developed countries called the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. In 1999, the OECD approved the Anti-Bribery Convention, the first binding international instrument to focus exclusively on bribery in business transactions. The work against corruption, says former OECD Secretary-General Angel Gurría, makes economies more productive, governments more efficient, and institutions more trusted.

“In short,” he said, “integrity delivers better lives.”

A global reach for clean governance

Collapse
AP
A motorcyclist drives past a poster of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi welcoming delegates ahead of this week’s summit of the Group of 20 nations in New Delhi, India, Sept. 4.

In an opinion survey this year in 12 leading economies, people from Italy to China said they were more concerned about corruption than climate change. Such a popular expectation of integrity in governance helps explain why this week’s summit of the 20 biggest economies, known as the Group of 20, includes a renewed focus on lifting standards on accountability and transparency – which range from whistleblower protection to anti-bribery enforcement.

Together, the G20 countries can set an example for the rest of the world because they account for 80% of the global economy – and more than 90% of foreign bribery convictions. This year’s summit host, India, has won some consensus among the group on how to cooperate better on asset recovery, or the winning back of stolen money sent abroad by corrupt players.

One recent example of asset recovery includes the United States’ repatriating $332 million linked to the former Nigerian dictator Sani Abacha and his co-conspirators. Britain is considering a measure to give law enforcement new powers to seize digital assets, which are often used to transfer ill-gotten gains. Such progress builds on the G20’s work over nearly a decade of summits to use the group as a vehicle for improving clean governance everywhere.

“Corruption is a crime that crosses borders,” according to the Accountability Lab, an anti-corruption activist group. “That is why international cooperation and collaboration are essential and have been a key area of focus for the G20 for many years.”

One helpmate for the G20 on fighting corruption is a Paris-based group of 38 developed countries called the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. In 1999, the OECD approved the Anti-Bribery Convention, the first binding international instrument to focus exclusively on bribery in business transactions. The work against corruption, says former OECD Secretary-General Angel Gurría, makes economies more productive, governments more efficient, and institutions more trusted.

“In short,” he said, “integrity delivers better lives.”

A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Where we always belong

  • Quick Read
  • Read or Listen ( 3 Min. )

We can feel a deep sense of connectedness, even when alone, by digging into our unity with God, divine Love itself.

Where we always belong

Collapse
Today's Christian Science Perspective audio edition

The Christian Science Monitor shared a perspective on the United States Surgeon General’s May 2023 report about loneliness and isolation as a profound challenge to public health and well-being. The report offered social connection as the antidote, and yet, as the Monitor points out, many “are struggling to rediscover their spirit of community and connection after a pandemic that left behind an epidemic of loneliness” (Harry Bruinius and Sophie Hills, “One is the loneliest number: What will help people connect again?” June 9, 2023).

We can feel lonely when surrounded by a crowd or perfectly companioned when all alone. This hints, then, that connection is more a matter of thought than of circumstance. Beginning with prayer and in communion with our true source, God, divine Love, we discover that loneliness and isolation yield to dawning inspiration and spiritual discernment. Prayer shows us that we are actually never alone and that all of God’s children are beautifully connected through their shared source.

Each of us is firmly rooted in the family of God, a “universal family, held in the gospel of Love” (Mary Baker Eddy, “Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures,” p. 577). Awareness of this brings spiritual fulfillment and a clarity about our most fundamental connection – to God, where we always belong.

Jesus came to show us what this divine union means and does through his demonstration of Christ, or “Immanuel, God with us” (Science and Health, p. 107). The Bible tells of Jesus at times retiring to a quiet place, communing with God, his Father-Mother, in solitude. Here he must have felt divine Love’s power to inspire and lead him in his mission to heal and inspire others. Mrs. Eddy wrote of Jesus’ impact on his students, “When he was with them, ... the solitude was peopled with holy messages from the All-Father” (“Retrospection and Introspection,” p. 91).

Even during what might have been his darkest night, when Jesus acknowledged to his disciples that they would all desert him, he still said, “Yet I am not alone, because the Father is with me” (John 16:32). There is no feeling of separation when we lean on and understand divine Principle, Love; any sense of a void is already filled with the one constant, reliable, ever-present All-in-all – God.

When we seek to deepen our understanding of our inseparable oneness with God, we experience peace and contentment. We gain the vitality and joy that come from knowing we live right now in the kingdom of heaven, where we always belong.

This knowing of our inseparability from divine Love brings out more of the truth of our identity as the reflection or idea of God, infinite Mind. It keeps us from falling for the appearance of acceptance, affection, and belonging based on a tenuous foundation of trying to get approval from others or trying to fit in. Any fear or apprehension about what others think of us is a baseless distraction from the fullness of what divine Love is revealing to us each moment. We have confidence in our connectedness when we know the one true source of all.

Our loving Father-Mother God is continually embracing and caring for us, so we can trust that our needs are met, including the human longing for love and connection. Self-focused beliefs that would reinforce a feeling of struggling alone yield to the touch of Christ, the divine message from God that heals us and leads us forward, as Jesus showed. Breaking out of a focus on self brings us into true joy, where thought opens expansively.

When we deepen and increase our understanding of our unbreakable oneness with God, we become more aware of our natural connection to others, and we see this more fully realized in our lives. We connect to others through our connection to God. As we stay focused on the higher goal of growing closer to God as our most important relationship, we naturally grow closer to others.

Christlike prayer focused on learning to love impels us to seek to understand more about God as the source of all love. Growing in love expands our view of God and therefore of ourselves and our connection to one another. It’s Christ that makes clear our inseparable relationship to God and to all of God’s ideas in Love’s divine kingdom – and shows us that we always belong.

Adapted from an editorial published in the Sept. 4, 2023, issue of the Christian Science Sentinel.

Viewfinder

Nairobi’s declaration

Monicah Mwangi/Reuters
A delegate from the Indigenous Maasai community blows a horn as he arrives at the Africa Climate Summit 2023 in Nairobi, Kenya, Sept. 6, 2023. The three-day summit, which tens of thousands of global delegates attended, concluded today with the Nairobi Declaration. Among other points, it said Africa is ready to lead on clean energy and care for the environment but needs industrialized countries to support initiatives through more robust investment, rather than just offering aid amid crises. It also called for financial reforms to ease borrowing costs, as well as a global carbon tax. The declaration will be in play at a United Nations climate conference later this month in New York and the COP28 climate conference to be held in Dubai in late November.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Thank you for joining us today. Please come back tomorrow when columnist Ned Temko looks at how a “forever war” between Ukraine and Russia can be prevented. With an outright victory unlikely for either side, diplomatic negotiations seem inevitable. The question is when the two sides will come to that conclusion themselves. Kyiv’s current counteroffensive might have a role to play.

More issues

2023
September
06
Wednesday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.