Coach Luiz Felipe Scolari tried to explain their 7-1 defeat by Germany in purely footballing terms, saying their opponents played superbly and took their chances against a Brazil side that played poorly.
But that is only half the story. In truth, the Brazilians lost the match in their heads as much as on the pitch.
"Let's put it into context. The hosts were unable to cope with the pressure," Germany coach Joachim Löw told reporters after the astonishing match.
"After two goals, they were confused and they never got re-organized. We realized they were cracking up and we took advantage of it."
Former German goalkeeper Oliver Kahn also believed Brazil's downfall was due to the weight of expectation of 200 million fans who demanded that on home soil their team would win the World Cup a record sixth time.
"This team didn't have enough experience to come to terms with the pressure of a big tournament like this in their own country," Kahn said.
"They fell apart emotionally today completely."
A Brazilian psychologist offered a different explanation.
"I don't think that these factors are distinct, the emotional, physical, the technical," Jose Anibal Azevedo Marques told Reuters.
"The way I see it as a sports psychologist is that it is unfair to say we lost 7-1 because we were unfit, or we lost 7-1 because we weren't emotionally prepared. It's all part of the one thing."
Marques said Brazil switched off during a 10-minute period and were punished mercilessly for it. Teams often have these blackouts, he said, but rarely does one side's disastrous spell coincide exactly with their opponents' purple patch.
"I work with football and it is not uncommon to see players switch off during games. What is uncommon is a team like Brazil switching off during a game as big as the semi-final of the World Cup."
At the end of the match, Brazilian midfielder Oscar fell to the ground, his face buried in his hands, and wept openly on the pitch. Captain David Luiz was also in tears.
Midfielder Luis Gustavo and left back Marcelo fell to the ground in prayer, as some fans wept, others booed, and many just looked on open-mouthed.
There had been signs of Brazil's emotional fragility in previous matches at this World Cup but against Croatia in the tournament's opening game and Chile in the second round they managed to hold it together.
The loss of Neymar to injury in the quarter-final against Colombia triggered an outpouring of grief that seemed to weigh on the team.
Asked about Neymar's absence and the emotional state of his players going into the match, Scolari said: "Let's not try to find an excuse in Neymar, or emotions.
"What happened is that Germany at a certain moment imposed a fantastic rhythm ... that has nothing to do with Neymar, or emotions."
Throughout the tournament, the Brazilian players entered the pitch with hands on each others' shoulders, praying, crossing themselves and sometimes crying with emotion.
Whereas that showed their passion, it also pointed to anxiety and an emotional fragility that contributed to their downfall.
The contrast with the grounded Germans who, even after such an astonishing victory, were calm and collected, could not have been greater
Bloomberg Businessweek opined that this game was the fruition of 14 years of German planning:
Germany beat them with the precise and inspiring soccer it’s played all month in Brazil. This is not an accident, a golden blessing of a generation of talented fussballers. It follows a 14-year plan to find all the kids among 80 million Germans who can really play soccer, train them young, and get them attached to a professional team.
All countries do this, kind of. Belgium does it really well. After tonight’s game you could argue that Germany does it best.
(Editing by Ed Osmond)