Crisis spares Russia's 'average Joe'
But the 25 richest Russians listed by Forbes have lost a combined $230 billion – a possible opportunity for the Kremlin to bolster conservative business allies.
Moscow — While many Americans are watching as their pensions crash with the markets, across Russia it's a different story. Though their stock market crash has been longer and deeper than in almost any other country, most Russians remain relatively unaffected. Meanwhile, Russia's wealthiest man, aluminum king Oleg Deripaska, has reportedly lost $16 billion over the past month.
As Russia's economy struggles under the weight of the global economic crisis, the effects on the country vary drastically among different segments of society. While Russian industrial barons are falling like kingpins, the government has maintained a budget surplus thanks to oil revenues and sovereign debts paid off by former President Vladimir Putin. Additionally, the general population has also been largely protected due to outmoded financial practices and social beliefs that kept pensions separate from the stock market. The varied effects of the market crisis are likely to alter the underpinnings of Russian society, say many Russian economic analysts.
Plunging oil prices, fallout from Russia's August war with Georgia, and ongoing uncertainties about the Kremlin's intentions toward private business have taken a toll on the Russian markets. Since their peak last May, Moscow's two key stock indexes have lost over two-thirds of their value, while big Russian corporations are sagging under total debts reported at over half a trillion dollars, mostly owed to international financial institutions.
The Russian government, on the other hand, remains largely debt free, and its oil-fed foreign reserves are the world's third largest at $600 billion as of August. About 10 percent of those reserves have melted away in the past two months as the Kremlin has moved to prop up the ruble, inject liquidity into troubled banks, and support selected companies.
Many financial analysts say the crisis has greatly accelerated the growth of "Kremlin capitalism," which involves direct state ownership over strategic economic sectors as well as indirect control over larger swaths of the economy through backing for businesses run by Kremlin cronies.
"A huge redistribution of property is taking place due to the crisis," says Nikolai Petrov, an expert with the Carnegie Center in Moscow. "The political elites in the Kremlin are sure now that they've been right all along about the need for greater state control, and believe that even the West is now coming around to their point of view."
A special $50 billion line of credit to support distressed companies, approved by the Russian government last week, will go largely to state-connected firms. The state oil firm Rosneft will receive $4.5 billion and the gas monopoly Gazprom about $1 billion. Other state firms producing arms, aircraft, and other "strategic goods" will be given priority, according to Russian media reports.
"Everybody is losing money, but the further they are from the state the more businesses are losing," says Mikhail Delyagin, scientific director of Moscow's independent Institute of Globalization Problems.
The global meltdown will have minimal impact on the country's real economy that, two decades after communism's collapse, has yet to fully integrate with world markets. According to a report prepared by Alfa Bank, a leading Russian financial institution, the country's entire banking sector has assets totaling 60 percent of gross domestic product, and just 3 percent of those are vested in mortgages.
The average Russian has little consumer debt and no exposure to the stock market via pension plans. The stock market is "totally speculative and not a place where most Russians would ever choose to put their money," says Sergei Glazyev, director of the independent Institute of New Economy in Moscow.
Earlier this month, the International Monetary Fund estimated that Russia will clock 7 percent economic growth this year, but that will sink to 5.5 percent in 2009. The government's budgetary surpluses will swiftly erode if global prices for oil – that account for 67 percent of the country's export revenues – sinks below $70 per barrel for an extended period.
But pain is reaching Russia's equivalent of Main Street. Last week Russia's auto giant, KamAZ, slowed to a four-day workweek, the huge Magnitogorsk steel works has slashed production by 25 percent, and other major Russian companies are showing signs of slowing down.
Though many affluent Muscovites say they're not hurting yet, a number of the city's giant shopping malls, luxury boutiques, and car dealers are much less crowded than usual.
After nearly a decade of booming real estate markets, Moscow's powerful mayor, Yury Luzhkov, last week announced a surprise $2 billion aid package for leading local property developers.
Social protest, which Mr. Putin appeared to banish, could return amid worsening conditions. "If oil prices continue to drop, there could be political unrest because all this prosperity and self-assurance we have seen [under Putin] will disappear," says Marshall Goldman of Harvard University's Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies.
When Putin came to power eight years ago, he dealt harshly with big business "oligarchs," and vowed to eliminate them "as a class." Most tycoons were left alone as long as they showed political obedience, but as recently as July trouble was flaring again between now-Prime Minister Putin and the Russian coal and steel giant Mechel.
The 25 richest Russians listed by Forbes have lost a combined $230 billion in the financial meltdown. Aside from Mr. Deripaska, another big loser is Roman Abramovich, famous for buying the British Chelsea Football Club, who is reportedly down $20 billion.
"Russia's vulnerability to the storm blowing through world markets will force the authorities to be pragmatic," says Yevgeny Gavrilenkov, an expert with Troika Dialog, a Moscow-based investment bank. "But it's understood that the state will first support its own companies. In Russia, the state is a megaoligarch."