India and China: The NEW 'New World'?
Optimism in India and China faces off against a weak economy in the West. Has the economic torch been passed?
We arrived at the Oberoi Hotel in Mumbai after President Obama had left.
As we were leaving, President Sarkozy was arriving.
It is a Grand Hotel. They come. They go. Nothing ever changes.
One of the problems with traveling so much is that you spend much of your time in a jet-lag fog. It was hazy when we left Mumbai. It is hazy in Kuala Lumpur. Was it the weather…or us?
But when we read the news, our eyes opened wide. Friday’s jobless numbers were shocking.
The latest figures show unemployment increasing, not going down. Here’s the New York Times write-up:
The United States added a total of just 39,000 jobs last month, down from an upwardly revised gain of 172,000 in October, the Labor Department reported on Friday. With local governments shedding jobs, the additions in the private sector were too small to reduce the ranks of the unemployed or even to keep pace with people entering the work force.
The unemployment rate, which is based on a separate survey of households, rose to 9.8 percent in November. It was the highest jobless rate since April and up from 9.6 percent in October.
The outlook remains bleak. More than 15 million people are out of work, among them 6.3 million who have been jobless for six months or longer. Many are about to exhaust their unemployment benefits, which have been extended repeatedly by the government because of the severity of the downturn.
The latest snapshot of the labor market cast a pall over what had been a brightening picture of a steadying economy.
The stock markets shrugged off the report, which was well shy of the forecast for a gain of 150,000 jobs, as all the major indexes rose slightly on Friday.
Part of the surprise in the November report was that layoffs, which had subsided earlier this year, picked up again. The number of people who were unemployed because they had been laid off or had concluded a temporary assignment increased by 390,000.
We don’t want to rub it in. But “we told you so” springs to the lips like a cup of beer to a football fan.
Meanwhile, the housing market is weakening. The Case Shiller index shows prices in such hot-spots as Phoenix and Las Vegas, at the lower part of the market, down by more than 40% – and still dropping. Some of them are now below their levels of 10 years ago.
So how can you have a real recovery when…
A) Fewer people have jobs (less household income)?
B) The average household’s major asset is losing value?
But heck, this is fantasyland now. Anything can happen. The feds are bailing out the banks all over the world…and entire countries, too.
Investors actually bid up stocks slightly even after the employment news.
The Dow rose 19 points on Friday.
Gold rose $16.
“What would you recommend to our viewers,” asked a Bloomberg reporter in Mumbai yesterday.
“Well, I don’t make recommendations,” we replied. “Especially not to Indians.
“But there are some periods and some places when it makes sense to be positive and optimistic…and there are times and places when it doesn’t.
“If you’re an Indian investor, I think you can be generally positive about the financial future. Yes, there are bound to be more crises…more corruption scandals…and more disasters. But there’s a trend going on that is probably too big to stop. It’s regression to the mean. India is catching up with the West. Wages are growing at maybe 15% per year. The stock market goes up almost every year. And many companies – in terms of growth – are still very cheap.
“The population is growing fast. The economy is growing fast. There’s plenty of capital for investment. There is plenty of knowledge and skill. There is no reason why this growth can’t continue for many, many years…
“So, an Indian investor can be optimistic. He should be optimistic. He should want to own a piece of that growth…a piece of the future.
“Alas, the situation is very different in the developed world…especially in the USA.
“The US and Europe are struggling just to stay in the same place. They’re mature societies…with populations that are getting old and economies that are largely worn out. In Europe this year, for the first time ever, more people will retire than join the workforce. And in America, the Social Security fund, for the first time ever, will pay out more than it takes in. These are two major developments. They signal the beginning of the end.
“I saw in the paper that China just set a new record with a passenger train that goes 300 mph. But almost all records are being broken – and they’re being broken in China or another ‘emerging’ market. The biggest, the most, the fastest…it’s all happening. But it’s not happening in the old, developed world.
“I think it was Karl Lagerfeld who noticed that Asia today is the New World. America and Europe are now part of the Old World.”
Add/view comments on this post.
The Christian Science Monitor has assembled a diverse group of the best economy-related bloggers out there. Our guest bloggers are not employed or directed by the Monitor and the views expressed are the bloggers' own, as is responsibility for the content of their blogs. To contact us about a blogger, click here. To add or view a comment on a guest blog, please go to the blogger's own site by clicking on the link above.