Next big global market: Unhappy women

A new study shows that women's economic clout is growing, but they are also more stressed. Tools to help women manage their lives will be an enormous business opportunity.

A worker puts the finishing touches on a garment at a factory in the southern Albanian town of Gjirokaster.

In the United States and elsewhere, women say there is a gender gap that goes beyond differences in pay between men and women – there’s also a gap between women's progress and their own hopes and expectations.

That's the conclusion of a newly released survey of 12,000 women in 21 nations.

As women work more and grow more educated, they are becoming more economically powerful. But that isn't buying happiness. The new survey, conducted by the Boston Consulting Group, finds that many females globally say they are overworked, overextended – and desperate for more time to manage their lives.

Some 48 percent of those surveyed say they feel pressure related to managing household finances. A similar percentage cite the stress of juggling a busy schedule.

The poll offers a window on gender roles in the economy at a time when the economic clout of women is growing. According to Boston Consulting Group, a global management consulting firm, women spend more than 70 percent of consumer dollars worldwide and will create 70 percent of global income growth at the household level during the next five years.

The survey included the United States, many developed countries in Europe, and a range of other nations including Brazil, China, India, Japan, Mexico, and Turkey.

It comes during a recession that, in America at least, has been particularly hard on men. Layoffs in fields like manufacturing and construction have pushed the jobless rate for men to 10.6 percent, while unemployment rate for women is 8.3 percent.

That big of a gap in favor of women is a new phenomenon not seen in past recessions. But if men are bearing the brunt of job losses, the strain on family incomes is affecting women as well.

The challenges for women appear to be rooted more in long-term trends than in current economic conditions, however.

In an academic study released in May, two economists described what they call "the paradox of declining female happiness."

By many measures, the well-being of both men and women around the world has been rising over time. Yet in subjective responses to surveys, women's happiness has declined in recent decades both in absolute terms and relative to men, say the economists, Betsey Stevenson and Justin Wolfers, both at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.

"The paradox ... is pervasive across demographic groups and industrialized countries," they say.

Why is this, given that women have never had it easy? The researchers haven't been able to pin down answers yet.

It's possible that, in part, what's at play is a new squeeze involving time and expectations. With greater earning power comes greater responsibility for family economic well-being, even as household duties remain large.

Meanwhile, rising opportunities can create hopes and expectations that are hard to fulfill. Ms. Stevenson and Mr. Wolfers say their research points to a provocative but unanswered question: Did men reap a disproportionate share of benefits from the women's movement?

Women globally have clearly been gaining economic stature and education. But a 2007 study of the gender gap in pay by the World Economic Forum concluded that the world could reap large benefits from further expanding opportunities for women.

The current combination of income and anxiety among women also represents a big business opportunity by itself, according to the newly released poll. Women will pay for products and services that do a better job helping them manage their time, for instance.

That’s a theme the consulting firm will develop when it releases the full survey results in a September in a book this fall, titled, "Women Want More: How to Capture Your Share of the World's Largest, Fastest-Growing Market."

of stories this month > Get unlimited stories
You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Unlimited digital access $11/month.

Get unlimited Monitor journalism.