Look closely: mutual funds return more than they yield

Q. Would you please explain the arithmetic about returns on mutual fund shares? For instance: If a person would invest $1,000 in Fund A, which sells for $40, I suppose she would get 25 shares, and the same amount invested in Fund B selling at $100 would get her 10 shares. Assuming they are both no-load funds, the expenses are the same for both funds, and the investor gets a return of 20 percent from both funds, what would she get from Funds A and B? Are return and yield the same? - A.C., Cumberland, R.I.

A. If the funds earned 20 percent, says fee-only financial planner Gary Schatsky, in New York, they would now each be worth $1,200, or a gain of $200. Shares in Fund A would be worth $48 ($200 divided by 25, equals $8, which you would add to the original $40); Shares in Fund B would be worth $120 ($200 divided by 10 equals $20, added to the original $100.)

Return and yield, he says, are not the same. "Yield is the cash payout, the income distribution, by a fund.

"Return is the distribution plus the capital appreciation (increase in profits) in the fund - the underlying added value of each share."

Be sure "you never look just at yield in measuring a fund," says Schatsky. Sometimes "yield is inflated through a return of principal." That usually happens with bond funds, but even some stock funds boost yields to look good.

Q. My mutual funds are earning terrible returns. The fund company, a load-fund company, is not helpful in guiding me to better-performing funds. If I sell the funds, which are not in tax-sheltered accounts, I will incur a large capital-gains bill at the end of the year. What alternatives do I have? - Name withheld, New York

A. You really have only two choices, says David Bendix, of Bendix Financial Group, Uniondale, N.Y. Keep the funds, and hope for a rebound, or sell them and invest elsewhere.

The second option means biting the bullet on the capital-gains tax, he adds, even if you switch to another non-tax-sheltered, fund within the same fund group.

Perhaps you have some other low-performing investment that you could sell for a loss to offset your gains.

"From the sounds of what you say, I'd get my money out of your fund group and go elsewhere," says Bendix.

Questions about finances? Write: Guy Halverson The Christian Science Monitor 500 Fifth Ave., Suite 1845 New York, NY 10110


We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.