Ready or Not, Here Comes Wal-Mart

Communities square off against the discount retail chain, even taking their fight to Congress

THE little red S.O.S. signs look starkly out of place on the stately leaf-speckled lawns of this quaint New England town.

But a Wal-Mart megastore would be even more incongruous here, says Carol Goodwin, a mother of six who is leading the Save Our Sturbridge (S.O.S.) campaign to keep the world's biggest retailer out of town.

``Tourists don't come to Sturbridge to shop at Wal-Mart. They come for the ambiance and flavor of New England. How do you make a three-acre building with 2,000 parking places look colonial?'' Mrs. Goodwin asks.

S.O.S. is the latest of more than 100 civic groups nationwide squaring off against what disparagers call ``Sprawl-Mart.'' The discount chain is becoming a lightning rod for the charged debate about small versus big business, and Americans' lust for low prices versus the NIMBY (not in my backyard) preservationists of Small Town USA.

``There's more to life than cheap underwear. If Wal-Mart costs you the quality of life in your community, is it worth it?'' asks Al Norman, a political organizer who helped keep the discounter out of Greenfield, Mass., last year.

Many small-town groups across the nation - from Cleveland Heights, Ohio, to North Elba, N.Y. - have been encouraged by the success of Greenfield and other New England towns now blocking Wal-Mart's expansion plans. They're networking, developing the media savvy and political sophistication to do the same. Mr. Norman, responding to the surge in anti-Wal-Mart forces, offers advice and a monthly newsletter ``Sprawl-busters Alert.''

Wal-Mart's reputation is taking a hammering. The Bentonville, Ark.,-based chain is also being skewered by Pulitzer Prize-winning cartoonist Gary Trudeau in Doonesbury. Last month, the United States House of Representatives' committee on small business held a hearing on the discount-retail trend.

There are other big discount retailers, but none are more successful or aggressive than Wal-Mart.

Ironically, company founder Sam Walton was fond of saying, ``Wal-Mart is small-town America.'' The company success formula is to avoid head-to-head competition with large regional department stores by putting its stores in small to mid-size towns. The strategy has worked spectacularly well since 1950, when the first Walton 5 & 10 opened.

By 1974, Wal-Mart had become a $4.7 billion chain. This year, with more than 2,400 stores, sales are expected to top $80 billion. It is one of the nation's largest employers. One out of $10 spent in US department stores is rung up on a Wal-Mart register, calculates economist Thomas Muller, who testified at the congressional hearing.

In Arkansas, Mr. Muller says, 30 percent of all department-store sales go to Wal-Mart. He warns that Wal-Mart may be a national monopoly in the making. Last month, after a pitched battle, Vermont was the last state to join the Wal-Mart republic. ``In a few years, if current trends continue, one corporate entity may have a substantial share of all retail trade in the US,'' Muller says.

But Wal-Mart's arrival is prized by many sleepy American towns. The store is seen as a source of jobs, taxes, and new clients. ``I don't look at Wal-Mart as hurting business. It draws customers to our area,'' says Don Sarette, owner of Don's Family Sports Center in Hooksett, N.H., where the first Wal-Mart in New England arrived in 1991.

In Sturbridge, Wal-Mart has run radio and newspaper ads touting its $50 million in scholarships and charitable donations last year. The new plaza promises to bring $220,000 a year in tax revenues, 600 permanent jobs, and $1 million in road improvements to the town famous for its working 1830s village.

``That's Wal-Math,'' chides Sturbridge resident James Glickman. ``They only know how to add.'' Most jobs are low-paying, part-time posts; tax revenue will go toward fire equipment and police; and 19 intersections will be changed to handle increased traffic, which will reduce home values, he claims.

In an August town meeting, Sturbridge residents voted 600-to-100 against Wal-Mart coming. But the company isn't giving up. ``Thanks to all the publicity the S.O.S. people have generated, we've been inundated with calls, letters, and faxes of support. Clearly, a majority are with Wal-Mart,'' says company spokesman Don Shinkle.

In Sturbridge and elsewhere, preservationists worry that discounters represent a growing threat to small businesses and downtown commercial districts.

``It's a zero-sum game in lots of places where the population isn't growing,'' says Kenneth Stone, an Iowa State University economics professor who has studied Wal-Mart's impact on Iowa towns. ``If a 100,000-square-foot store does $30 million a year, that money doesn't come out of thin air.''

Doug Loescher, of the National Trust for Historic Preservation in Washington, argues that small downtown businesses provide greater economic benefits to a community than big discounters. Local firms attract foot traffic, reducing the need for new roads; they use local suppliers, sponsor Little League teams and community events, and keep their money in local banks, he claims.

One solution to this dilemma is to encourage Wal-Mart and other discounters to move downtown.

Last month, Wal-Mart agreed to locate in downtown St. Johnsbury, Vt. ``We have no aversion to downtown locations,'' says Mr. Shinkle, if there is enough vehicle access, acreage, and parking.

But for some, the attempt to stop Wal-Mart and the march of free enterprise is like trying to sneak the sunrise past a rooster.

In 1947, Wal-Mart didn't exist. But Southern writer William Faulkner was already lamenting the destruction of a hometown historic courthouse to make way for ``a sprawling octopus'' dispensing ``cut-rate bargain lots, bananas, and toilet paper. They call this progress,'' he wrote. ``But they don't say where it's going; also, there are some of us who would like the chance to say whether or not we want the ride.''

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.