Magnetism May Be Visible in Migrating Bird's-Eye View

HERE'S an intriguing notion for bird watchers. Birds may actually see Earth's magnetic field when they use it for navigation.

This possibility goes to the heart of the mystery of how some animals sense Earth's magnetism. And, remarkable as it may seem, it has begun to receive some indirect experimental support.

Some biologists, such as Klaus Schulten of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, think the visual sense of some animals may be involved in their ability to sense magnetic fields. Dr. Schulten theorizes that pigment molecules in the eyes of migratory birds combine magnetic information with certain light colors to give visual clues. He speculates that the birds may actually see a visual distortion due to Earth's magnetic field when they fly.

Biologist John B. Phillips at Indiana University at Bloomington says he thinks such theorizing is "on the right track." Work in his laboratory using male Eastern red spotted newts has produced the "first clear demonstration that the [animal] magnetic compass is light dependent," he says.

Reporting this research in the Sept. 10 issue of Nature, Dr. Phillips and his colleague S. Chris Borland explain how certain wavelengths of light directly affect the compass sense of these semiaquatic salamanders. For example, long-wavelength light rotates the animal's magnetically derived directional sense 90 degrees anticlockwise from what it is under full spectrum light.

Commenting on this finding in a telephone interview, Phillips says that establishing the light-dependence of the animal "compass" is the "first step" in the long process of demonstrating the Schulten thesis. He added that his laboratory is getting the same kind of light-dependent response in the magnetic sense of certain species of flies. He believes there is little doubt that the magnetic field is affecting the flies' photoreceptors. He calls the accumulating evidence of a visual-magnetic link "pretty c ompelling evidence that Schulten is on the right track."

Evidence is abundant that a wide variety of life forms use Earth's magnetism for orientation. They are as diverse as bacteria, birds, and salamanders. Yet biologists have been unable to identify a specific magnetic sense organ in any species. Many life forms, including humans, do have tiny magnets in their bodies. Yet there's little evidence that these magnets, by themselves, confer a magnetic sense. It now looks as though magnetic sensing is too complex to be explained in terms of a simple organ.

Research in this field has also been hampered by lack of repeatability. Magnetic responses of animals that show up clearly one day may not appear at all on other days. Phillips says he thinks scientists have overlooked an uncontrolled disturbing factor. He notes that fluorescent lights, computers, and other standard equipment generate high-frequency electromagnetic noise. Equipment operating in another room can sometimes scramble an animal's magnetic sensing process, which operates at a molecular level. He says "the modern laboratory is a disaster area" for this kind of research. His group works in out buildings well removed from such interference.

The link between sight and magnetism is what Phillips calls "a nontrivial product" of biological evolution - "a fundamentally new function of the visual system." This has implications beyond the specialized field of animal navigation. It suggests that animal and human physiology, generally, has overlooked an important aspect of visual systems.

Meanwhile, bird watchers should remember that there's more to bird migration than meets the (human) eye.

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.