A thriller with extra dimensions. Controversial murder case makes exceptional video drama

The Murder of Mary Phagan NBC, Sunday, 8:30-11 p.m, and Tuesday, 9-11:30 p.m. Stars: Jack Lemmon, Peter Gallagher, Richard Jordan. Writers: George Stevens Jr. and Jeffrey Lane, based on a story by Larry McMurtry. Director: Billy Hale. Producer: George Stevens Jr. On the surface, ``The Murder of Mary Phagan'' is a compellingly entertaining fact-based thriller, made with uncommon skill and sensitivity.

But dig just a bit deeper, and you will discover it is much more than that. It is an incisive study of individual integrity pitted against mass hysteria, Southern xenophobia, class discrimination, anti-Semitism, bureaucratic dishonesty, populism gone awry, and political manipulation.

If that seems like a great burden to lay on an unpretentious two-part drama, let me make it worse by adding that it is also impeccably acted by Jack Lemmon, Peter Gallagher, and Richard Jordan; subtly directed by Billy Hale; exquisitely photographed by Nick Knowland; and authentically costumed by Judy Moorecraft and Merrily Murray-Walsh. In addition, it has a surprisingly restrained score by Maurice Jarre.

The cleverly multilevel script by George Stevens Jr. and Jeffrey Lane is based on the controversial 1913 Atlanta murder of 13-year-old Mary Phagan, a worker in a pencil factory. A Jewish manager from New York, Leo Frank, was allegedly the last person to see her alive. Public sentiment against Frank was stirred up by newspapers and rabble-rousers as well as a politically motivated solicitor general. In the end, the governor was forced to make a stand, based mainly on his own conscience. The price he paid was the ruin of his political career.

Most shocking in this drama is the true-to-life conclusion and ending note that explains what actually happened to all the main figures. It provides a punch-in-the-solar-plexus touch of reality.

Jack Lemmon, as Gov. John M. Slaton, plays a very small role in the Sunday night part of the drama, but really comes into his own in the Tuesday conclusion, where he gives an Emmy-quality performance. Richard Jordan, in a difficult and ambivalent role, skillfully manages to make the solicitor general obnoxious but understandable.

The same murder case was used as the basis for a 1930s movie, ``They Won't Forget,'' in which Lana Turner made her debut as the young girl. That film, however, offered no final twist to clarify the real-life events, as this version does.

``The Murder of Mary Phagan'' is not merely entertainment television at its best; it is contemporary cinema at its best.

Producer Stevens tells what drew him to story of Mary Phagan

The Leo Frank case is one ``where the Jewishness of the main figure played a part in the judgment of him,'' says George Stevens Jr., producer and co-author of ``The Murder of Mary Phagan.''

``One of the things that attracted me most to the story,'' he continues, ``was the fact that the most popular governor in Georgia history got entangled in the events, and it caused him to make a difficult choice, to test his own conscience. ... The difficulty of a politician remaining true to himself is still a problem in our political system.''

Though there has been a recent revelation of evidence pertinent to the Frank case - evidence which, according to Stevens, seems to clear Frank once and for all - there are many people in Georgia who still believe Frank was guilty. When asked if the film won't help change their minds, Stevens says, ``Prejudice dies hard. But ... this film is not a polemical film. It's about basically good people who allowed their prejudices to become inflamed. My father [Hollywood director George Stevens Sr.] used to say that films give people an opportunity to live lives that they haven't lived themselves. Audiences don't come just to be entertained; they come to learn about themselves, too.

``I don't want to sound pretentious. But .... I think, in general, audiences are made up of pretty good people, and if this increases their awareness of an era, an event that actually happened, well, that's all to the good.''

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
QR Code to A thriller with extra dimensions. Controversial murder case makes exceptional video drama
Read this article in
https://www.csmonitor.com/1988/0122/lphag.html
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
https://www.csmonitor.com/subscribe