Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Judge blocks Wisconsin collective-bargaining law

A county judge temporarily blocks the Wisconsin collective-bargaining law, pending further inquiry into whether the law was passed in accordance with the Legislature's rules.

(Page 2 of 2)

The matter of jurisdiction is likely to become an issue. The attorney general’s claims that the county does not have jurisdiction are “very debatable,” says Dennis Dresang, a political scientist at University of Wisconsin in Madison.

Skip to next paragraph

The attorney general will try to get an appeals court to temporarily lift the injunction so the bill will become law, but that will likely prove impossible considering they will need to prove that pausing the bill from becoming law immediately will cause harm, Mr. Dresang says. He contends the opposite is true: By rushing the bill into law, state legislators harmed local governments and school districts that may have been in the midst of negotiating with their respective unions in an attempt to lock in contract obligations for the next two years.

“Part of the impact of this is that it was rushed so much, local governments who were in the process of negotiating were told all the sudden that – boom – they can’t proceed,” he says.

Back to Square 1 for Republicans?

Although Friday’s ruling is considered a setback for state Republicans, Sumi made it clear they can act on the bill a second time. With all 14 Democrats back in the state, reaching a quorum is once again possible, making a do-over advantageous for Republicans. But some senate Democrats have said that if the bill was called for a vote, they would once again leave the state, while others indicated they would stay to try to change the bill to make it more amenable to their constituents.

“I would hope that the Republicans would take this opportunity to sit down with Democrats to try to work out a compromise that we can all get behind. It is time to show the world we can work together,” said State Sen. Jon Erpenbach (D) in a statement released Friday.

Legislators on both sides are facing multiple recall campaigns, resulting from the debate over the bill, which at one time drew hundreds of thousands of protesters to Madison as well as international media attention.

So far, the state’s Republican leadership has been quiet about what next steps they plan to make. In an e-mail sent to Wisconsin Politics Friday, Walker spokesperson Cullen Werwie suggested they are monitoring the what happens next in court.

“This legislation is still working through the legal process…. We are confident the provisions of the budget repair bill will become law in the near future,” Mr. Werwie said.


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story