Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Complaints arise about White House kibitzing in key Senate primaries

Team Obama has picked favorites for races in Pennsylvania, Illinois, and New York. Local party figures say that undermines democracy – and is not the national party's job.

(Page 2 of 2)



National Republicans are also getting into the Senate primary act. In Florida, the national establishment prefers moderate Gov. Charlie Crist (R), who has announced for the Senate seat being vacated by Sen. Mel Martinez (R). But some powerful local Republicans – including former Gov. Jeb Bush and the Club for Growth – are saying not so fast. They’re backing the more conservative Marco Rubio, former state House speaker.

Skip to next paragraph

A good track record for central casting

Sen. Charles Schumer (D) of New York set the modern standard for direct involvement in picking winners in primaries, as chairman of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee in both 2006 and 2008 – and he has the track record to justify it. In both cycles, the Democrats picked up multiple seats, taking control of the Senate in 2006 and building on their majority in 2008.

The Obama White House is shy about fully disclosing its actions in trying to shape races. When asked at a Monitor breakfast June 25 about President Obama’s recent meeting with Ms. Madigan, who he knows from their days in the Illinois state Senate, White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel said: “What happens in the Oval stays in the Oval,” referring to the Oval Office.

But Mr. Emanuel, who ran the Democrats’ successful House recruitment effort when he was a member, made clear his view of Madigan’s potential in the Illinois Senate race. “She’s the most popular figure in the state of Illinos,” he said, calling her “the 800-pound gorilla” in the race.

Peril for Specter, newly minted Democrat

In Pennsylvania, the Democratic establishment tried to scare off primary challengers to Senator Specter, having gotten him to switch to their team. Gov. Ed Rendell, in an MSNBC interview May 29, said Rep. Joe Sestak (D) of Pennsylvania “would get killed” if he ran against Specter in next May’s primary. But Congressman Sestak has all but formally announced that he’s running anyway, and analysts say he could win. Specter’s popularity in Pennsylvania has plummeted since he switched parties.

In New York, Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D) is also defying her party’s establishment in deciding to run against the incumbent Senator Gillibrand. But she is standing on principle, declaring that New Yorkers have the right to make their own decision. “People around the world watched and were inspired as people in Iran risked their lives to vote,” she said in the July 2 New York Times. “New Yorkers deserve the same.”

If Sestak or Congresswoman Maloney wins the primary, it would be an embarrassment to the Obama White House. But if they win their races in November 2010, keeping those seats in Democratic hands, Obama would probably forgive them.