Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

After Senate passage, stimulus bill moves to next hurdles

Senate's $838 billion package of tax cuts and new spending must be reconciled with the House bill. There may be little room to maneuver.

By Staff writer / February 10, 2009

Stimulus shepherd: Sen. Harry Reid, the majority leader, said Tuesday that President Obama is urging House and Senate conferees to agree on a final stimulus package as soon as possible.

J. Scott Applewhite/AP



With the United States facing the most severe economic crisis since the 1930s, the Senate passed a massive stimulus plan Tuesday, valued at $838.2 billion, and House and Senate negotiators within hours began work to reconcile differences between the two chambers' versions of the legislation.

Skip to next paragraph

While most of the Senate bill closely tracks the House version, spending cuts negotiated to guarantee Senate passage are shaping up as flash points. The three Republican senators who voted for the bill and who helped to shape it, including $110 billion in cuts from the House bill, say they will not back a final version that restores those cuts.

Both the House and Senate will have to vote on the legislation in its final form.

Senate majority leader Harry Reid expressed optimism that most of the differences could be resolved quickly. Lawmakers have said they want to have a final bill on President Obama's desk by late this week or early next.

“We expect to have much of this down in the first 24 hours,” Senator Reid said in a briefing after the vote.

About one-third of the Senate package goes to tax relief, including a $69 billion fix to curb the reach of the alternative minimum tax and $19 billion in tax credits for home buyers in 2009.

Key elements on the spending side include $39 billion to help states avoid layoffs, especially in public education; $27 billion to extend emergency unemployment benefits; $40 billion for the development of clean energy, and $23 billion for programs to help those most hurt by the economic downturn.

The Senate bill also includes a provision to curb bonuses at companies receiving government bailout help – a move that will end up costing the Treasury $10.8 billion in lost tax revenue, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

But Reid acknowledged that the 61-to-37 vote in the Senate, including all Democrats and just three Republicans, gives the conference committee little room to maneuver. Sixty votes are needed in the Senate to move legislation to the floor, meaning it is crucial to retain GOP votes.

Sen. Arlen Specter (R) of Pennsylvania, one of the three, staked out his position early. “My support for the conference report on the stimulus package will require that the Senate compromise bill come back virtually intact including, but not limited to, overall spending, the current ratio of tax cuts to spending, and the $110 billion in cuts,” he said in a statement Monday.

Sens. Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe of Maine, the other two Republicans voting for the stimulus plan, also said they could not support a final deal that strayed too far from the Senate bill.

“It’s got to keep to the contours of the bill that was passed here,” said Senator Snowe, after the Senate vote. “It is crucial to separate spending that is stimulus from spending that is not. We have to get it right. Expectation is high. We cannot fail.”