Health-care battle: A third US appeals court weighs law's constitutionality

Lawyers representing 26 states square off Wednesday against the Obama administration. Both sides bring top legal talent to the appeal of a ruling by a federal judge in Florida who invalidated the entire health-care law.

By , Staff writer

  • close
    In a July 27, 2007 photo, US District Judge Roger Vinson is seen at the US District Court in Pensacola, Fla. Vinson declared the Obama administration's health-care overhaul unconstitutional in January, siding with 26 states that sued to block it, saying that people can't be required to buy health insurance.
    View Caption

Lawyers representing 26 states are squaring off Wednesday morning against the Obama administration in a federal appeals court in Atlanta in the latest clash over the president’s health-care reform law.

Both sides are bringing impressive legal talent to the battle. Appearing for the president is Neal Katyal, who has served as acting US solicitor general following the appointment of Elena Kagan as a US Supreme Court justice.

On the other side, representing the states, is Paul Clement, a Washington lawyer who served as US solicitor general during the administration of George W. Bush.

Recommended: Beyond Obamacare: 5 opinions on health care reform

At issue is whether the law’s individual mandate requiring Americans to buy a government-approved level of health insurance exceeds Congress’s power under the Constitution's commerce clause.

Critics say Congress has the power to regulate interstate economic activity, but that power does not reach individuals who choose not to purchase health insurance or otherwise participate in the health-care market.

On Tuesday the White House reaffirmed its position that the argument is “without merit.”

“Individuals who choose to go without health insurance are actively making an economic decision that affects all of us,” Stephanie Cutter, assistant to the president, said in a White House blog Tuesday afternoon. “When people without insurance obtain health care they cannot pay for, those with insurance and taxpayers are often left to pick up the tab.”

The appearance before a three-judge panel of the 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals will mark the third such appellate hearing in a series of lawsuits examining the constitutionality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, signed into law in March 2010.

Arguments have already been heard in separate cases pending before the Fourth Circuit in Richmond, Va., and the Sixth Circuit in Cincinnati.

The case in Atlanta is an appeal from a decision by a federal judge in Florida who ruled in January that Congress overstepped its authority under the commerce clause. Although his finding related to the constitutionality of the individual mandate, US District Judge Roger Vinson invalidated the entire law.

Legal analysts expect one or more of the pending appeals court cases to eventually reach the US Supreme Court for a final determination of the legal challenges.

Lawyers for the state of Florida and 25 other states say the health-care law represents an “unprecedented assertion of power Congress simply doesn’t possess.”

“In the over 200 years that Congress has sat, it has never before attempted to exercise its commerce clause power in this manner. That is not a product of remarkable restraint; Congress has not exercised such a power because it does not exist,” wrote Mr. Clement in his brief on behalf of the 26 states.

By requiring Americans to purchase health insurance, Congress is forcing them to engage in commerce – an activity that the government then claims as the underlying authority for its regulation.

“Sanctioning such a power would eliminate all meaningful limits on Congress’s authority and sound the death knell for our constitutional structure and individual liberties,” Clement wrote.

Lawyers with the US Solicitor General’s Office are asking the appeals court judges to overturn the Florida judge. “The minimum coverage provision is a quintessential exercise of the commerce power,” the solicitor general’s brief said.

The commerce clause allows Congress to regulate not only interstate commerce but also conduct that substantially affects interstate commerce, the brief says.

Government lawyers reject the claims of critics that the individual mandate seeks to regulate nonactivity by forcing people to purchase a product or service that they wouldn’t otherwise purchase. Instead, they say, the ACA seeks to regulate the broader market for health care that includes everyone.

“[Congress] can regulate the conduct of participants in the overall health care market even if they are currently ‘inactive’ in the insurance aspect of that market,” the government brief says.

The arguments are scheduled to last about two hours. The randomly selected three-judge panel includes Chief Judge Joel Dubina and Judges Frank Hull and Stanley Marcus.

The chief judge was appointed by President George H.W. Bush, and Judges Hull and Marcus were appointed by President Bill Clinton.

The case is State of Florida v. US Department of Health and Human Services (11-11021 and 11-11067).

Share this story:

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.




eZ debug

Clear cache:

Quick settings:

Timing: Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Script start
Timing: Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Module start 'content'
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 158
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 175
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 158
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: path in /var/www/ on line 175
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: meta_class_identifier_ms in /var/www/ on line 111
Notice: PHP: E_NOTICE Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Undefined index: meta_remote_id_ms in /var/www/ on line 1028
Warning: eZTemplate:def @ extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tpl:10[1] Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Variable 'story_source' is already defined.
Timing: Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Module end 'content'
Timing: Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Before parse_includes
Strict: PHP: E_STRICT Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Non-static method MugoViewExtras::get_view_extras() should not be called statically, assuming $this from incompatible context in /var/www/ on line 37
Warning: eZTemplate:def @ extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/extra/archive.tpl:21[1] Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
Variable 'view_extra_node' is already defined.
Timing: Jul 09 2014 14:12:26
After parse_includes
Timing: Jul 09 2014 14:12:26

Timing points:

CheckpointElapsedRel. ElapsedMemoryRel. Memory
Script start 0.0000 sec0.0185 sec 1,286.2344 KB1,162.2578 KB
Module start 'content' 0.0185 sec2.3996 sec 2,448.4922 KB12,796.0625 KB
Module end 'content' 2.4181 sec0.0181 sec 15,244.5547 KB404.6094 KB
Before parse_includes 2.4362 sec0.0663 sec 15,649.1641 KB274.3516 KB
After parse_includes 2.5025 sec0.0011 sec 15,923.5156 KB-187.1563 KB
End 2.5036 sec  15,736.3594 KB 
Total runtime:2.5100 sec
Peak memory usage:21,521.2266 KB

Time accumulators:

 Accumulator Elapsed Percent Count Average
Load cache0.0087 sec0.3482%370.0002 sec
Mysql Total
Mysqli_queries0.2135 sec8.4975%2570.0008 sec
Looping result0.0759 sec3.0187%2460.0003 sec
Template Total2.4490 sec 97.5% 8 0.3061 sec
Template load0.0082 sec0.3282%80.0010 sec
Template processing2.4407 sec97.1290%80.3051 sec
Template load and register function0.0002 sec0.0094%40.0001 sec
state_id_array0.0132 sec0.5260%210.0006 sec
state_identifier_array0.0212 sec0.8429%280.0008 sec
Cache load0.0085 sec0.3388%1340.0001 sec
eZ Find
Search0.0905 sec3.6019%10.0905 sec
Query build0.0777 sec3.0927%10.0777 sec
Class attribute list0.0734 sec2.9228%10.0734 sec
Engine time0.0112 sec0.4462%10.0112 sec
MoreLikeThis0.0000 sec0.0000%00.0000 sec
Sytem overhead
Fetch class attribute can translate value0.0021 sec0.0842%50.0004 sec
Fetch class attribute name0.0003 sec0.0113%120.0000 sec
Image XML parsing0.0076 sec0.3036%50.0015 sec
Instantiating content class attribute0.0002 sec0.0061%150.0000 sec
String conversion0.0000 sec0.0014%30.0000 sec
dbfile0.0022 sec0.0886%710.0000 sec
View Extra building0.0193 sec0.7679%40.0048 sec
Total script time:2.5128 sec

CSS/JS files loaded with "ezjscPacker" during request:


Templates used to render the page:

UsageRequested templateTemplateTemplate loadedEditOverride
1node/view/full.tplfull/article.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/full/article.tplEdit templateOverride template
34content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/paragraph.tpl<No override>extension/ezwebin/design/ezwebin/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/paragraph.tplEdit templateOverride template
3content/datatype/view/ezimage.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezimage.tplEdit templateOverride template
2content/datatype/view/ezstring.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezstring.tplEdit templateOverride template
28content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/link.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/link.tplEdit templateOverride template
6content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/strong.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/strong.tplEdit templateOverride template
6content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/promotion.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltags/promotion.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/content/datatype/view/ezbyline.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezobjectrelationlist.tplcontent/datatype/view/story_images.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/story_images.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/eztext.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/content/datatype/view/eztext.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezstring.tplcontent/datatype/view/image_credit.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/image_credit.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezxmltext.tplcontent/datatype/view/story_info_box.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/story_info_box.tplEdit templateOverride template
1content/datatype/view/ezmatrix.tplcontent/datatype/view/ezmatrix_article_related_external_links.tplextension/csm_base/design/csm_design/override/templates/content/datatype/view/ezmatrix_article_related_external_links.tplEdit templateOverride template
1pagelayout.tpl<No override>extension/csm_base/design/csm_design/templates/pagelayout.tplEdit templateOverride template
1modules/mugo_view_extras/extra_cached.tpl<No override>extension/mugo_view_extras/design/standard/templates/modules/mugo_view_extras/extra_cached.tplEdit templateOverride template
1setup/debug_toolbar.tpl<No override>design/standard/templates/setup/debug_toolbar.tplEdit templateOverride template
 Number of times templates used: 90
 Number of unique templates used: 17
 Time used to render template usage: 0.0005 secs