Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

George Pataki isn't 11th GOP presidential candidate, after all

Former New York Gov. George Pataki has reportedly decided not to enter the crowded field of GOP presidential hopefuls. It's hard to see where he could have carved out some turf, say analysts.

(Page 2 of 2)

Indeed, Pataki’s moderate stance on social issues is at odds with the current mood of the tea party-tippling GOP base and would not have inspired much support in a nominating contest.

Skip to next paragraph

“He’s on the wrong side of the culture war,” says Douglass Muzzio, a professor of public affairs at Baruch College in New York.

If Pataki were to run as a fiscal conservative, it probably wouldn’t have gotten him far, either. Spending and state income taxes swelled during the governor’s three terms in office, with an average spending increase of 6.3 percent per year during his first six years. In 2006, near the end of his term, the libertarian Cato Institute gave him a ‘D’ for fiscal policy. Pataki would have been hard-pressed to defend his policies at a time when the GOP is more antitax and antispending than ever.

As a moderate, establishment Republican, Pataki would have occupied the same space as former Massachusetts governor and GOP hopeful Mitt Romney, but with far less name recognition and money (or as former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr., who’s struggling to poll around 2 percent).

“If the electorate is looking for a Northeastern moderate Republican, Romney has captured that,” says Carso. “If they’re looking for charisma, [former New York Mayor Rudy] Giuliani fits the bill better than Pataki.”

Pataki, like former candidate Tim Pawlenty, is charismatically challenged, a weakness that can’t be underestimated in modern-day campaigning – and in a nominating race.

In a field crowded with larger-than-life personas and tea party populists, Pataki would have faded into the background with his low-key, retiring style. Or, as Professor Muzzio puts it: “He’s dull. Find him in the sleep aid section in the pharmacy.”

Still, the decision may have disappointed some moderate Republicans or independents who were looking for more representation in the field, says O’Connell. “He could raise some questions a lot of independents want to see raised,” he says.

Pataki’s decision not to enter will register barely a blip on the campaign strategies of his contenders, most of whom didn’t feel threatened by the moderate Republican. The same cannot be said of Sarah Palin, who has been flirting with a White House bid for months and who could be a game-changer if she decides to run.


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story