Ethnic studies classes illegal in Arizona public schools as of Jan. 1
Much of the controversial Arizona immigration law remains tied up in court, but a law banning ethnic studies in Arizona is set to take effect Saturday. A Tucson school district vows to fight it.
(Page 2 of 2)
“The state has no business telling the local school board what to teach,” says Roberto Rodriguez, a professor at the University of Arizona and member of the district’s Mexican-American studies advisory board. “The state superintendent is overreaching – meddling, literally.”Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
Mexican-American studies has evolved over several years and has had “some pretty significant achievement results,” says John Pedicone, the district’s newly-hired superintendent. “It’s done some very important things, we believe, for an underserved population. The students that go through the program seem to do very well.”
Mr. Pedicone says district data shows that about 70 to 75 percent of the students that go through the program go on to college, compared with 20 to 25 percent of a similar demographic group.
Despite the risk of losing state funds, the district plans to keep its program. Officials believe it is in compliance with the law. “The law was created listing the things that a course of studies cannot do, and the district’s position all along has been that this course of studies does not do that,” says Pedicone.
Once Horne declares the district is breaking the new law, school officials have 60 days to present evidence of compliance at a hearing, Pedicone says. The ultimate decision rests with Horne’s successor, John Huppenthal, a Republican senator from the Phoenix area who also has been critical of ethnic studies both at the Tucson district and at the University of Arizona.
Impact beyond Arizona
The impact of the law is worrisome to educators and students around the state. Teacher representatives at the University of Arizona recently formally stated their opposition to a law they say sends the wrong message to Arizona students.
Concerns over the law also reach beyond the state. In early December, teachers and students attended a discussion and presentation about the Arizona ethnic studies law on the University of California, Los Angeles campus.
“They thought it could have implications in California,” says Shaena Engle, a spokeswoman with UCLA’s Graduate School of Education and Information Studies.
Professor Rodriguez says it’s not the first time such programs have been singled out, but now “it’s being acted upon.” He views the state’s ethnic studies and immigration laws as attacks on all Hispanics and as reasons why some people might refer to Arizona as “the new south.”