Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Jeb Bush's book: more than just a flip-flop on illegal immigration (+video)

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush's changed stance on citizenship for undocumented immigrants fits into a broader repositioning on the issue of immigration – perhaps for a presidential run in 2016.

By Staff writer / March 6, 2013

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush (R) talks with the media following his address on education to the Texas Business Leadership Council in Austin, Texas, on Feb. 26. In a new book, Bush calls for a complete overhaul of US immigration policy but cautions against providing a pathway to citizenship for illegal immigrants – a position that puts him at odds with some Senate reformers within his own party.

Eric Gay/AP/File

Enlarge

Washington

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush’s waffling on whether most undocumented immigrants should be able to become US citizens was the quick headline from his new book, "Immigration Wars."

Skip to next paragraph

But the Sunshine State Republican has a slew of other ideas for the immigration debate.

For example, did you know Mr. Bush thinks all US citizens should have to pass a much tougher version of the US citizenship exam to graduate from high school?

There’s good reason the question about citizenship took top billing in discussing Bush’s book, released on Tuesday. He's been one of the most prominent Republicans advocating outreach to Latinos through a “pathway to citizenship” – an immigration code phrase broadly indicating that most of the nation’s more than 10 million unauthorized immigrants would be able to obtain US citizenship at some point – but his "Immigration Wars" argues the opposite.

Still, there’s a lot more to the book than just a flip-flop on who should become a citizen, and he takes on some of the right’s main critiques of comprehensive immigration reform.

Bush seeks to revamp the country's overall legal immigration system, shifting visas from the current system, which is largely family-based, toward employment-based migration.

In three important cases, Bush takes issue with fundamental components of his party’s opposition to prior immigration reform proposals. First, he disagrees with those who believe overall US immigration should decrease from its current level of roughly 1 million new permanent residents per year.

“Left to its own devices and without increased immigration, America’s population is shrinking,” Bush writes. “We need more immigrants to stem that debilitating demographic tide.”

Second, he rejects the idea, frequently voiced by conservatives, that they’ll only consider reforming the immigration system once America’s borders are secure.

“Many on the right say that we must secure the border before we do anything to reform our immigration system. The fact is that we can’t do one without the other,” Bush writes.

After going down a list of unsolvable riddles in immigration policy – for example, what counts as “operational control” of the border – he asks with some exasperation: “What exactly is the magic moment we must wait for before we can fix the broken immigration system?”

Third, he rebuts the idea that those wishing to come to the United States without family or employment connections can somehow “get in line” to become US citizens.

“Most Americans probably don’t realize that the traditional avenue of immigration is all but foreclosed by our current system,” Bush writes. There are 250 applications for each of the 50,000 slots in the nation’s annual “diversity visa” lottery system, he adds. This is the chief way those without family or employment ties can come to America.

Permissions

  • Weekly review of global news and ideas
  • Balanced, insightful and trustworthy
  • Subscribe in print or digital

Special Offer

 
Become a fan! Follow us! Google+ YouTube See our feeds!