Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

Health-care reform law: How Supreme Court ruling affects families

The US Supreme Court ruling upholding President Obama's health-care reform law carries major import for millions of American families. Notably, many who are uninsured will gain access to health coverage.

(Page 2 of 2)

The law provides for people who don't have an employer-based plan to shop for insurance on "exchanges" set up at the state level, with coverage plans ranging from "bronze" to "platinum." The Kaiser Family Foundation's calculator focuses on the cost of a "silver" plan, and the example given above assumes the household is headed by a 45-year-old.

Skip to next paragraph

Note this: The subsidies are designed to phase out as household income rises, so the family of four would see the cost of health-insurance jump once their income exceeds about $93,700 – making them ineligible for federal subsidies.

Some will remain uninsured

Even with the Supreme Court's ruling to uphold the law, many Americans are likely to remain uninsured.

As the Kaiser Family Foundation explains, some citizens would be exempt from the mandate (such as for religious reasons, being in prison, being an undocumented immigrant, or not being able to afford insurance). The law deems insurance to be unaffordable for people when insurance premiums after subsidies and employer contributions exceed 8 percent of family income.

For whom would insurance be "unaffordable"? While low-income families would be eligible for Medicaid, and families in the next rung up the ladder would get generous subsidies, the phaseout of tax credits would put insurance in the zone above that 8-percent-of-income threshold for many families with middle to high incomes. At the top of the income scale, such as a four-person family earning above $180,000, insurance becomes "affordable" again.
Of course, even with subsides that make insurance technically "affordable," spending 7 percent of income on health premiums won't necessarily feel easy for working-class families. 
In upholding the whole law, the court preserved a range of other ACA provisions that affect families, including a guarantee that insurers will provide coverage to people with preexisting conditions. 

This "guaranteed issue" provision matters to many Americans, even if they now have insurance. For example, that provision eases the worry that if you lose your jobs, you might not be able to get insurance on your own.

Similarly, the ACA includes some "community rating" provisions designed to limit variation in the cost of insurance. Firms can't charge an older purchaser more than three times what they charge a young person. They can't charge a tobacco user more than 1.5 times what a nonuser would pay.

Overall, ranks of insured to increase

In all, millions more Americans are expected to have insurance as key ACA provisions take effect in 2014.

The Congressional Budget Office estimates that some 20 million people would gain coverage by buying their own insurance through exchanges.

Beyond that, the law also has tax implications for many families. The biggest are for high-income individuals who will face a Medicare-tax increase and a 3.8 percent tax on investment income, designed to help pay for the ACA's costs.

Opinion polls have found that a majority of US adults like many provisions in the ACA. The federal subsidies, "guaranteed issue," and the Medicaid expansion all were supported by more than two-thirds of Americans in an early 2012 Kaiser-sponsored poll.

At the same time, many Americans don't like the individual mandate (and the related threat of fines), view the law as an instance of government overreach, or worry that the law won't control health-care costs. Those factors go a long way toward explaining why the law overall hasn't garnered majority support.


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story

  • Weekly review of global news and ideas
  • Balanced, insightful and trustworthy
  • Subscribe in print or digital

Special Offer

Become a fan! Follow us! Google+ YouTube See our feeds!