Culture wars over Christmas displays: where the law stands

It’s become as much of a holiday tradition as eggnog and tree-trimming. Controversies over religious displays during the Christmas season have been stirring emotions for years, and 2009 is no different.

The latest dispute cropped up in California's Sonoma County, when an atheist complained that the stars and angels on Christmas trees amounted to a government endorsement of Christianity. Earlier this week, the ornaments in question were banned.

“People can worship in their homes. They can celebrate Christmas in their church. They can do all that,” Irv Sutley, an atheist activist, told the Santa Rosa Press Democrat. “They just don't have the right to intrude on government property.”

Later in the week, however, after the incident received widespread attention, the ban on the ornaments was lifted.

The legal standard for holiday displays was established by the US Supreme Court in 1989 in the case Allegheny v. ACLU. The court ruled that a Nativity scene at a county courthouse in Pittsburgh was a violation of the Constitution's "establishment clause" (prohibiting government establishment of religion), the foundation for separation of church and state. But the court also ruled, in the same case, that there was nothing unconstitutional about a display of a Hanukkah menorah on city property, and in a separate ruling the court decided that municipalities can use religious elements in Christmas displays if they don’t appear to advocate any one religion.

A controversy over a cross in Holliston, Mass., has also added to the culture wars over Christmas decorations. Earlier this month, city officials denied a firefighter’s request to erect a cross on top of a fire station. Erecting the cross had been a firefighter tradition until the city ordered it removed over legal concerns in 2004. While the city decided not to give the firefighter permission, it did say the cross could be placed in front of Town Hall in an area that the town has designated for holiday displays.

In Kokomo, Ind., many residents complained when holiday lights on the courthouse lawn included a whale and the Loch Ness Monster.

1 | 2

Next