Amid recession, is San Francisco losing its heart?
The famously liberal city slices aid for the needy. Advocates cry foul, but others see a need to curb spending.
(Page 2 of 2)
More broadly, liberal leaders say conservatives here are using the recession to move social policy to the right.Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
"The shock of the deficit is being used to make some of the changes that more-conservative forces in the city have been trying to make – privatization, reduction in services to the most needy, cutting health services that are primary care services," says city Supervisor John Avalos, who represents a largely working-class district.
But Supervisor Sean Elsbernd sees it differently: "These are horrible cuts across the board – they're not disproportionately impacting the poor. Every San Franciscan is going to feel the effects of this budget." Argues Mr. Elsbernd, "There needs to be a recognition that we're not in this budget situation just because of the downturn, but because of our spending practices over the years."
Mayor Newsom's press secretary, Nathan Ballard, says the mayor "has made decisions in the best interests of the city, and he stands by his decisions ... there are no easy choices. Every cut has a constituency."
Indeed, social programs are not the only budgetary victims: Police, fire, and other departments have been asked to slash one-quarter of their spending, and all but the Public Defender's Office have complied, says Mr. Ballard.
The federal stimulus will pump about $50 million into city coffers, but it's not nearly enough to fill the budget gap. Instead of cutting programs, some city leaders are pushing for a special election this summer to raise taxes – possibly a gross receipt tax and hikes in levies on commercial property and sales.
Says Supervisor Avalos, "I don't think we can just cut our way out of the problem ... we can't lay off people to get out of this, we have to raise some revenue. We have a lot of wealth in this city, and we have to move it around to alleviate the deficit."
The mayor has yet to endorse or oppose a tax increase to avoid the cuts.
"We're open to new revenue measures," insists Ballard, "but it's got to go hand in hand with reform, which includes consolidating departments and streamlining government."
As programs are cut, advocates report that needs are rising as the recession deepens. One measure: More homeless people are being turned away from shelters each night.
"We have this huge increase in the number of people who are poor and a disintegration of the cornerstone poverty abatement programs" such as job training and affordable housing, says Jennifer Friedenbach, executive director of the Coalition on Homelessness.
"It's the exact opposite approach of what you would want," argues Ms. Friedenbach. "You would want in this time of recession and increased needs to have this really creative response from city government to turn it around, and instead the proposals on the table are to balance this huge deficit on the backs of the most vulnerable San Franciscans."