Now students take field trips online
High fuel prices make virtual field trips popular with schools – but no substitute for the real thing.
(Page 2 of 2)
Like many proponents of the trend, she dislikes the term "virtual field trip" because it suggests that virtual trips might replace, rather than supplement, traditional trips.Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
"It would never take the place of a field trip, and in fact, I take as many field trips as I did before," says Ms. Dultz. "I use the tool as an opportunity to have my students interact with experts in the field."
That's what organizations hosting virtual field trips are hoping. California State Parks, for instance, set up the elephant seal trip to introduce a new, more diverse generation to the parks – and spur interest in eventually visiting.
The goal is laudable and part of pioneering efforts by park systems across the country to reverse declining attendance, says Richard Louv, author of "Last Child in the Woods."
"The problem is I can see school districts saying, 'Why should we pay for buses if we can just do this?' " he says. "Classroom learning about nature is terrific, including a virtual field trip. But I would not classify that as experience. What kids are missing now is not information. What they need most is the hands-dirty, feet-wet experience in nature."
Many a school trip to the ocean has foundered on the expense and scheduling nightmares involved with busses. And that's before diesel topped $4 a gallon.
"Fuel is the biggest reason currently for reducing field trips or cutting them altogether. In fact, it's officially reached a dilemma," says Ryan Gray, editor in chief of School Transportation News. He says some 40 states will enter the 2008-09 school year with a deficit in transportation funding.
Virtual field trips, by comparison, are often free once the school invests in the equipment. The cost of one teleconferencing system, says Marshall Middle School Principal Ron Small, is only slightly higher than that of busing two classes to see those elephant seals in person.
That said, Dr. Small emphasizes that he doesn't anticipate reducing traditional trips. He still plans to send his students to the state capitol. But the students might later do a teleconference with their state representative.
Beyond cost, virtual trips can often be more focused and easily aligned to educational objectives, says Small and others.
"Take the kids to the zoo and they are all over the place. Take them the Bronx Zoo, virtually, and they can go behind the scenes and see the hairs in a buffalo's nose," says Blankenbaker.
The California state parks program, which reaches about 20,000 students a year, designed the elephant seal trip around the seventh grade curriculum on evolution.
Dressed in a park uniform and hat, guide John Goldberg asks the class of 24 students what adaptations the seals have developed for keeping warm in the Pacific waters. The kids raise their hands, their attention still holding steady after 40 minutes. Mr. Goldberg can see the kids, but lets their teacher call on students since he doesn't know their names. Someone comes up with body fat. Goldberg calls it "blubber" and wins some playful giggles.
After the bell rings, the students say goodbye to Goldberg. One says: "I'm going to come to your park."