Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Randy Jackson will be an American Idol judge, Take 12

Randy Jackson will indeed be joining his 'bestie' Mariah Carey on American Idol's judging panel. Will Randy Jackson be joined by Nicki Minaj and Keith Urban?

By Contributor / September 11, 2012

American Idol judges Mariah Carey and Randy Jackson at the 2012 BMI Urban Awards in early Sept., 2012, in Beverly Hills, Calif. Who else will join the American Idol judging panel?

(Photo by Arnold Turner/Invision for BMI/AP Images)

Enlarge

Despite earlier reports that Randy Jackson would be hanging up his judging cap, insiders (and Simon Cowell's Twitter feed) are now claiming that Randy Jackson will in fact join Mariah Carey on the judging panel for the 12th season of American Idol.

Skip to next paragraph

Why the sudden turn of events – aside from a desperate attempt to create drama and generate buzz in the off-season? Obviously producers recognized Mr. Jackson's unwavering devotion to the show, his innumerable contributions to the juggernaut that has defined a generation, his ability to astutely and succinctly provide priceless industry advice to fledgling artists, his . .  wait, what's that? Randy Jackson was a last minute fill-in after negotiations with Enrique Iglesias collapsed due to his demands for an eight-figure salary?

Well, it's great that Mr. Jackson is shrewd enough to not let his pride get in the way of another lucrative year on the judging panel. You can't teach an old dawg new tricks after all . . .

And, since we're on rumor overdrive, reports are that Nicki Minaj and Keith Urban are quite close to being confirmed as the third and, completely extraneous, fourth judges on the panel. A four-judge format is a questionable choice for Idol since their previous experiments with four judges seemed to weigh down a show that has been known to struggled with time-management issues even with three judges. But many of Idol's recent decisions seem to be directly influenced by the show's main competitors, FOX's The X-Factor and NBC's The Voice. The four-judge format, the rumored addition of Nicki Minaj (a direct response to The X-Factor's addition of two young, female pop artists to their judging panel) and the token, good-looking male country artist, Keith Urban also known as Blake Shelton 2.0.

While playing musical judging chairs might be a good way to keep American Idol in the viewer's collective unconscious, especially when The X-Factor and The Voice are battling for early-season supremacy, it doesn't necessarily mean that the results will prove beneficial to the show; a show that, in some respects, has been on full tilt since the fateful decision to bring on 4th judge Kara DioGuardi in Season 8; a change that seemed to herald the beginning of the end of the Randy-Simon-Paula magic.

In fact, keeping Randy Jackson as a judge may be the best decision Idol's made in quite a while. Despite his shortcomings (and there are many) he is the only tie to the magic that once propelled American Idol into the stratosphere and while evolution is necessary if the show wishes to remain current, staying current should never come at the expense of individuality. It is troubling that Idol's producers seem to be focusing more on what makes other shows successful rather than recognizing what made/makes them special. 

Will the additions of Carey, Minaj, and Urban recapture the magic of Idol's yesteryear? It seems highly unlikely, especially since the saturation of celebrity judges have shifted the focus of the entire genre. What was once a talent show about contestants has quickly become a platform for celebrities to further their careers, supplement their incomes and yes, to stroke their egos.

At least we still have our resident dawg. Who knew that someday Randy would come to embody all that was right with American Idol?

Permissions

  • Weekly review of global news and ideas
  • Balanced, insightful and trustworthy
  • Subscribe in print or digital

Special Offer

 

Doing Good

 

What happens when ordinary people decide to pay it forward? Extraordinary change...

Danny Bent poses at the starting line of the Boston Marathon in Hopkinton, Mass.

After the Boston Marathon bombings, Danny Bent took on a cross-country challenge

The athlete-adventurer co-founded a relay run called One Run for Boston that started in Los Angeles and ended at the marathon finish line to raise funds for victims.

 
 
Become a fan! Follow us! Google+ YouTube See our feeds!