On eve of Facebook IPO, GM pulls millions in ads
General Motors yanks $10 million in Facebook ads. Will this affect the Facebook IPO?
Facebook, by all accounts, will soon become the most valuable company ever to go public, surpassing even United Parcel Service, which received a valuation of $60.2 billion for its 1999 IPO. Much of that value is tied to the ability of Facebook to rake in cash from online and mobile advertisements. For its part, Facebook has bragged that it offers its advertisers unparalleled reach and accuracy.
But not all of those advertisers are happy.
According to The Wall Street Journal, which first broke the news, car-maker General Motors is set to yank its advertisements from Facebook – a direct result of the failure of the ads to impact consumers' purchases. The move, the Journal notes, "puts a spotlight on an issue that many marketers have been raising: whether ads on Facebook help them sell more products."
In an interview with Bloomberg News, Greg Martin, a GM spokesman, said the company "regularly review[s] our overall media spend and make[s] adjustments as needed. This happens as a regular course of business and it's not unusual for us to move our spending around various media outlets." Still, for Facebook, the timing is notably bad.
"This does highlight what we are arguing is the riskiness of the overall Facebook business model," Brian Wieser, Internet and media analyst at Pivotal Research Group told Reuters today.
But over at PC World, Tony Bradley argues that the loss of GM as an advertiser is not necessarily super-problematic for Facebook. The social network, after all, has long been about "word-of-mouth" interactions.
"The value of marketing on a social network is the sharing between friends and family," Bradley writes. "One person tries a restaurant and likes it, and shares that experience with the rest of their social network. Someone finds a pair of shoes that are comfortable, and posts it online for everyone to see. That type of interaction is less likely for big-ticket items like cars, but it’s a gold mine for small businesses that can’t afford Super Bowl ads."