Google Halloween versus Bing Halloween. Who wins?

A Google Halloween or a Bing Halloween? That's the question.

Skip to next paragraph

No, it's probably not

most important showdown in the history of civilization. But it probably ranks up there with the very important debate over what breakfast cereal is better: Count Chocula or Frankenberry.

Google and Bing are in a battle for Halloween supremacy today as both search engines tweaked their respective home pages to commemorate the holiday.

Google changes their logo all the time to recognize holidays, birthdays, and weird stuff. So, it's not a surprise that they've done it today.

Bing offers a new image every day. So, the Halloween photo today? Expected.

In terms of search volume, of course, there's no competition. Google clobbers all comers -- although Bing is trying mightily to take a bite of that pie.

Creativity wins

But in terms of commemorating a holiday, it's a more even playing field. It's a creativity contest.

Google goes for the more traditional approach by replacing their logo with pieces of Halloween candy. Pieces, you say? Do you only see one offering of candy? Well, click the logo again. And again. They present four different home page displays.

Bing, on the other hand, has a more menacing character on its home page. No, not Dick Cheney, but a vampire bat with plenty of "hot spots" where you can find more spooky information about Halloween stuff.

And the winner is...

What do web users prefer?

You could say it's a battle of good versus evil. Happy little Halloween candies against a flying, blood-sucking beast.

If you listen in to Twitter -- who has sadly decided

to celebrate Halloween -- you can watch the discussion. And it appears as though when people compare the two that Bing is the winner.

"Today at least, Bing's homepage image is cooler than Google's," tweets chivalrybean.

Amantedellapa echoes those thoughts. "Halloween Page? http://www.bing.com/ over http://www.google.com/ by a long long mile. Larry, Sergey and crew - not even trying!"

Zebb not only agrees, but he's rubbing it in. "@Google search Halloween image is the weakest they have ever had, glad I switched to @bing."

Epic battle

Sure Google has the overwhelming majority of search traffic, but Bing appears to be the big winner the very important Halloween home page image contest thingy.

Maybe Bing is the Google-killer after all...

See also:

Google celebrates Halloween with trick or treat doodle

Bing celebrates Halloween with a vampire bat 

The origin of that terrible Monster Mash song