Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Wikipedia bans edits to its Scientology pages. But at what cost?

By Matthew Shaer / June 1, 2009

In this 2008 photo, a new sign is raised over the Church of Scientology mission in Malibu. The online encyclopedia Wikipedia recently decided to block edits to Scientology-related articles from Internet addresses inside church headquarters.

Jonathan Alcorn/ZUMA Press/Newscom


What ever happened to neutrality?

Skip to next paragraph

Recent posts

That's the question hurtling around the blogosphere this week, days after Wikipedia banned some edits to its entries on Scientology, a religion founded by L. Ron Hubbard in 1952. (Editor's note: The ban only affects addresses based on Church property.) As Marissa Taylor writes in the Wall Street Journal, Wikipedia made its announcement only after determining that the level of "hostility" over the page had reached unacceptable levels.

For months, site administrators have sought to mediate a war between Scientologists and the organization's detractors. "Some 430 Scientology entries on Wikipedia resulted in constant battles over revisions between the two camps. User accounts were created for the sole purpose of deleting or adding information on Scientology, a practice seen as harmful to Wikipedia’s neutrality principles," Taylor writes.

A battle on two fronts
It's been a rough spring for Scientologists, here and abroad. Late last week, leaders of the French branch of the organization appeared in a Parisian court to defend against charges of organized fraud. According to Reuters, if the defendants are found guilty, they could be fined five million euros and ordered to cease their activities. Now the Church is fighting a second battle, one with equally wide-ranging consequences.

On the website Wikinews, Scientology spokesman Tommy Davis said church members had only ever used Wikipedia to "[confront] inaccuracies" on the Internet:

"The story that's being missed is there were people who were doing non-stop attacks on the church and using Wikipedia to do it. Those people have been banned." He said there had been no orchestrated campaign by church leaders to have members change Wikipedia articles: "The church is huge. Scientologists are going to say what they're going to say about their own religion."


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story