Why a British Capital Gains Tax increase is a bad idea
The increase, estimated to be at around 40 percent would be an erosion of value and a wealth tax in disguise. Here's some advice about what you should do before the increase.
The news is that the rate of Capital Gains Tax is to be increased to around 40%. My hope is that the CGT allowance of £10,100 will remain, but I note that the Liberal Democrats have suggested reducing this to £1,000.Skip to next paragraph
The Adam Smith Institute is the UK's leading innovator of free-market economic and social policies. Politically independent and non-profit, the Institute promotes its ideas through reports, briefings, events, media appearances, and its website and blog.
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
The previous Labour government sought to simplify CGT by removing taper relief and indexation. To compensate for the loss of these reliefs, the rate of CGT was reduced to 18%. It would be most unfair to now increase the rate of CGT without either rebasing the book costs for long held assets from 1982 values or reintroducing indexation relief to compensate for the effects of inflation. Otherwise, if a share price simply rises in line with inflation, the value remains the same, so on disposal the investor is taxed not on the gain but on the increase in price. Such tax is therefore an erosion of value and a wealth tax in disguise.
The timing of the proposed change remains uncertain. It is possible that the changes could start immediately, or they could be backdated to the start of this financial year, or they could take effect from 6th April 2011. Given the need for speed to address the country's economic problems, I expect action sooner rather than later.
Investors planning to make disposals would be wise to do so before the emergency budget, in case the proposed increase in CGT takes immediate effect. Remember that the same shares bought back within a month match against the sale leaving the original holding undisturbed. You could hedge your bets by selling just before the budget, see what happens and then decide whether to unwind your position by buying back within a month.
Given the Tory commitment to reward marriage I think it unlikely that any action will be taken to remove the free transfer of assets between spouses. You should ensure that assets are held by the partner on the lower tax rate, and make transfers accordingly. Similarly, make transfers so sales are made in the right name to maximise the use of CGT allowances.
Three other points:
- Capital gains arising within ISAs are free from CGT and this has just become significantly more valuable. It is therefore even more important that you utilise your ISA allowances.
- If gains are realised on sales to fund a SIPP contribution, the income tax relief on the contribution can offset the CGT arising.
- Capital gains arising from VCT investment are exempt from CGT so I suspect that there may be a revival of interest in this area.
The Christian Science Monitor has assembled a diverse group of the best economy-related bloggers out there. Our guest bloggers are not employed or directed by the Monitor and the views expressed are the bloggers' own, as is responsibility for the content of their blogs. To contact us about a blogger, click here. To add or view a comment on a guest blog, please go to the blogger's own site by clicking on the link above.